For the offended

What is this?

Saturday, December 7, 2024

Facebook bludgeons Norman Rockwell


     Now that X has become an odious sewer, fled by the feeling, is Facebook next?
     And really, it's amazing, once some sort of critical mass was reached on Bluesky, a few weeks ago, how quickly Elon Musk's hallelujah chorus of haters and nutjobs became unbearable. I visit it now the way you hurry down a darkened street lined with drug addicts and derelicts. 
     Now Facebook is ... threadbare. What was once a pleasant coffee klatsch of your friends and relatives showing off newborns, surgical scars and lunch has, become, for me at least, a dumptruck unleashing its load on my head every visit.
     The breaking point came for me Friday, when I realized I was being pelted with Normal Rockwell paintings, some not even by Rockwell.
     Don't get me wrong — I like Norman Rockwell, or did, before Facebook grabbed me by the nape of the neck and began rubbing my face in his work. For years he was underrated, as a kitschy booster of American small town values. Even though he's not only an incredible stylist, but also an artist with a strong moral sense. Yes, he painted nostalgic, patriotic tableaus; but he also produced jarring dispatches from the civil rights era. He was a dramatist. He told stories.
     In 2015, driving out of Boston, I made a point of stopping in his studio and museum in Stockbridge, Massachusetts. Well worth a visit, particularly to see his almost invisible brushwork. He is America's Michelangelo.
     So maybe this is my fault. Maybe a few weeks ago I clicked on one of the histories that went along with a Rockwell painting that Facebook was serving up. Because suddenly I was getting them continually, every third post it seemed. I went to see who was sharing them, and found odd Facebook pages that didn't look like they were from actual people, but Korean kittens and oddly-named non-persons who only posted Rockwell's work. Some had the same Rockwell caption on various other paintings. Some ID'ed work of another artist as Rockwell.
     I started vigorously blocking  these AI Rockwell aficionados, requesting to see this kind of thing less. And it seemed to work, regarding Rockwell. But other artists, and old movies, and random historical facts, rain down. 
     Now Facebook seems like those slideshows before a movie — crude ads for used car lots and knick-knack boutiques. Many, many high end socks. All that trivia, all that capsule pop history. Enough already. Who needs to spend their life doing this? It's not interesting anymore. 
      In a way, I'm grateful, and sorry it took them this long to alienate me. Now I'm going to post my column every morning and scram, or try to. As I write that, there does seem a "two drinks is my limit" quality to saying that. Naive. I do like checking my memories on Facebook — 16 years of life served back at me. So one has to be careful, too, regarding sweeping pronouncements of that kind. Not a good idea to sign checks that you can't cash.

20 comments:

  1. I quit Facebook in 2018 and don’t miss it a bit. Logged out of Threads and IG. No more Zuck for me. I’m only on Bluesky now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree. I joined FB long ago because it was fun to reconnect with childhood & school friends, distant relatives, current friends and/or interests, and look at all their posted family news and photos. Now post after post on my FB is “Sponsored” or “You might like” or “Follow” or “Join” and very few are from people I actually know or purposely follow. I don’t want to have to go to each and every friend’s page to see what’s going on with them. I haven’t abandoned FB completely—something tugs at me—but I’m getting quite close. —Becca

    ReplyDelete
  3. Facebook certainly has issues. I've learned to just quickly scroll past obviously targeted posts related to something I'd searched for or just random stuff. That's probably annoying, but benign compared to the way it seems to be used by nefarious forces to influence elections or try to sway public opinion.

    The one thing FB has that I use heavily and don't see an equivalent on other platforms is groups. I like having these separated corners where people of various levels of acquaintance but united by an interest in a specific area or a similar background or dealing with a similar life problem can share expertise, answer each other's questions, gossip about current events, etc. without being infringed on by other issues and small enough that they can be moderated by a couple group members. I don't know if reddit is kind of like that, but I think the interface is not easy enough to use or just through force of habit I never got into it. If Blue Sky could implement some kind of similar thing, I'd cut my FB use drastically.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yet another reason why I've never had a Fecesbook page!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I never see posts from friends or people I follow anymore unless I actively search for them. Everything is ads, recipes, political commentary and comic strips.

    ReplyDelete
  6. a lot of my friends have similar complaints. when I say friends I mean actual friends and relatives . I dont have the same experience. FB is pleasant. I get what im hoping for. posts and pictures of peoples lives who I dont see as much as I would like to. like. have a little chat and move on . the ads aren't too bad . maybe its because you use it to promote your column and blog and dont spend enough time in the settings curating your page. or maybe because you have the FB app on your hand held device. I dont think its them . I think its us. if we want a pleasant experience we have to do a little work

    ReplyDelete
  7. Since deciding, a couple of years ago, to visit Facebook only 3-4 times a year, my life has been sweeter and more peaceful. I miss some of the baby and anniversary photos, and the occasional insightful remark by a friend, but not much else.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My wife and I have noticed the same thing, endless ads and very little content from friends.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Never started, never gonna…

    ReplyDelete
  10. I quit FB right after Jan 6. A surprising number of my "friends" turned out to be racist idiots. Poked my head in a few years later and the experience was even worse than I remembered. Deleted the account at that point and never regretted it. Twitter was great for a few years after that, but that too has been kicked to the curb.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh man, you fell into a Facebook hole. Don't touch anything down there, and if you see a hookah-smoking caterpillar, don't listen to it -- just run!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Our email provider changed to Yahoo. Four days ago I managed to get the number of messages (which was at 600 ) down to 200. Today - four days later - it is over 1200! I don't even know that many people!. I deleted and blocked the messages on Erectile dysfunction and I now have twenty on face creme, how to get a healthy gut, and how to get rid of my wrinkles. I think there's an algorithm that kicks into gear when you try to unsubscribe or block a sender. It's as if the algorithm thinks oh she doesn't want help with her sexuality, but I bet she'll be interested in one of these ten products.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Use this link when using a browser.

    https://www.facebook.com/?sk=h_chr

    It forces your timeline into chronological order and along with an ad blocker in your browser (or use the Brave browser), all that nonsense of stuff you don’t care about goes away.

    However, this link has no effect on the mobile site or any FB apps. Works on desktop only.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ok, since you brought it up, where is the famous Rockwell painting of the clock tender outside Marshall Field’s? Why isn’t it on display at Art Institute? Too plebian?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "The Clock Mender" painting is on display at the Chicago History Museum, where it's part of their collection. I hope that's acceptable to you. ; )

      Delete
    2. Longtime readers know the unusual and quite funny story of the adventures of that painting. https://www.everygoddamnday.com/2017/05/but-clocks-come-with-it-right.html

      Delete
  15. Canadian here. Zuck and co. have bullied govt for over a year by not allowing any news articles or links to news items to post. Our options are to take photos of links or simply express our opinions. In the words of my well admired fellow Canadian Norm MacDonald: “He’s a real jerk”. Facebook: Race to the bottom; X: The bottom.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Strongly resisted the siren call of the Motherzuckers for a good fifteen years. Didn't like all that damnable scrolling, didn't want to use my real name, didn't want to SHARE things, didn't care about what friends and relatives were doing or eating, or where they were traveling. Just don't have all that many people in my life anymore. So there's that, for starters.

    Plus, I had other outlets. Mainly message boards. Most of them eventually went the way of the pay phone. Was one of a handful of die-hards still left at a private message board that lasted for almost twenty years. Until its owner died (the Plague), and his daughter finally pulled the plug last year.

    And then there was Nextdoor. Until, after one suspension too many (for a year), I was booted for good in '21. Imagine my surprise, last summer, when I clicked on an old link, just for yucks, and there was my ND account, quietly waiting for me, like I had never been away for three years. Why ask why?

    But the thrill was gone. The folks at Nextdoor aren't the brightest crayons in the box. Just the whitest. The kind who see a Black kid in a hoodie on their sidewalk and get extremely nervous, and need to alert the whole neighborhood. Good place to find a handyman or an electrician, though. But that's about it.

    To make up for the void, I joined Farcebook. Turned my wife's dormant account into a hyphenated account...as in..."Izzy-Lizzy Grizzwald." This somehow infuriates innumerable users. They ask: "Which one of you cheated?"--- and then it's off to the races, and I rip them new orifices. Naturally, I have a rap sheet, and have been a repeat offender in FB Jail.

    But I don't get all the garbage that Mr. S and others seem to get. Sure, I get ads for things like expensive compression socks, because I have poor circulation in my legs, but I ignore or hide all the bullshit, or maybe I just don't get that much of it because I wasn't a heavy user in past years. Wasn't a user at all.

    Never SHARE at FB, and I don't FRIEND strangers...such a perversion of that lovely word. Nor do I let them friend me. I have exactly ten FB friends, and they are all real ones. Or cousins. People occasionally deride me for having ten friends. Anyone who judges anyone else by the number of FRIENDS or FOLLOWERS they have is just one thing... a shallow asshole.

    But I do have a LONG blocked list, though. Anyone gets in my face, for any reason, and I punch their ticket to Block Island. I've heard FB will let you block up to 5,000 names. Given enough time, I might get there one day.

    As someone else here alluded...the best thing about FB are the groups. Mine run the gamut of my eclectic tastes...Cleveland history...neighborhood groups...three Chicago-centric history/nostalgia outfits...streetcars...Chicago transit ("L" trains)... history...baseball...classic TV...cats...and politics. Oh, yeah, the politics.

    Spend way too much time behind a keyboard. Facebook is more addictive than tobacco. The Zuckers know how to hook...and make...billions. Is there a Facebook Anonymous? My time is fairly short, and I'm pissing it away, and I have a house and basement and garage to "death-clean" (that Swedish or Norwegian thing) before the whistle blows.

    ReplyDelete
  17. You can hide your friends list on FB, Grizz. Check settings.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.