An EGD reader asked me what books I've been reading during my convalescence. Good question. I'm working on my own book, about the benefits of Judaism, so for the past year have been trying to make a dent in modern Jewish literature, pressing forward on three fronts: audiobooks, physical books and, the first time and at my wife's urging, reading on my iPhone, since I can hold it easily in one hand.
The first book I read on my phone was "The Chosen," by Chaim Potok. I read it 50 years ago, but only vaguely remembered something about a baseball game. It's an excellent novel, a crisply-written character study of the friendship between the protagonist, Reuven Malter and his friend Danny — slated at birth to become the next tzaddik, or leader of his particular sect of orthodoxy. Plus their relationships with their demanding faith and strong-willed fathers. A reminder that, like all religions, Judaism is not a block of uniformity, but a spectrum; the various factions sometimes hate each other. The opening game is played between the Hasidim and a less rigorous sect. We might see them as both orthodox Jews, but the Hasids really despise their opponents, warning them that they're going to hell for being apostates.
Right before the surgery, I read Harry Golden's surprisingly-useful
"Only in America." I googled "10 best contemporary Jewish novels" and one of them was Howard Jacobson's "The Finkler Question" which I picked because it won the prestigious Man Booker award. The funny, thoughtful. book was published in 2010 and is surprisingly current, with much of the plot pivoting on the Palestinian situation. One character joins a group he calls "Ashamed Jews" and they go around apologizing for the continued existence of the state founded in their name.
The first book I read on my phone was "The Chosen," by Chaim Potok. I read it 50 years ago, but only vaguely remembered something about a baseball game. It's an excellent novel, a crisply-written character study of the friendship between the protagonist, Reuven Malter and his friend Danny — slated at birth to become the next tzaddik, or leader of his particular sect of orthodoxy. Plus their relationships with their demanding faith and strong-willed fathers. A reminder that, like all religions, Judaism is not a block of uniformity, but a spectrum; the various factions sometimes hate each other. The opening game is played between the Hasidim and a less rigorous sect. We might see them as both orthodox Jews, but the Hasids really despise their opponents, warning them that they're going to hell for being apostates.
Right before the surgery, I read Harry Golden's surprisingly-useful
"Only in America." I googled "10 best contemporary Jewish novels" and one of them was Howard Jacobson's "The Finkler Question" which I picked because it won the prestigious Man Booker award. The funny, thoughtful. book was published in 2010 and is surprisingly current, with much of the plot pivoting on the Palestinian situation. One character joins a group he calls "Ashamed Jews" and they go around apologizing for the continued existence of the state founded in their name.
The physical book I'm reading is James Loeffler's "Exceptional Hatred: Antisemitism and the Fight Over Free Speech in Modern America," published this month by Metropolitan Books. It's set in Chicago, beginning in 1949 with what is essentially an anti-Jewish pogrom in Englewood. One of the book's many shocks is realizing how American antisemitism cruised right through World War II, largely unaffected by the Holocaust, a term rarely used until 30 years later, after a TV series of the same name. Much real estate is given to Terminiello v. Chicago, a Supreme Court case that grew out of a anti-Semitic priest holding a hate rally on the West Side, and the question of whether groups can be protected from libel in the same way individuals are.
The center section is about the legal ramifications of the 1977 attempt of Nazis to march in Skokie, while the last third brings us up-to-date to the present day I'm going to write a column about it so I don't wanna get too far into it, but it makes her gripping read with a caveat that the center section explores every legalistic posture, maneuver, and nuance in microscopic detail.
I'm also finishing Andre Aciman's sweet and melancholy "Out of Egypt" on Audible, which I read years ago and was really just fact checking one passage but ended up listening to the whole thing. It's a sentimental look at his family before they were kicked out in 1965 part of the Arab world's purge of Jews into Israel, where it turns out they don't belong either. The book is billed as a memoir, though Aciman, who went on to write "Call Me by Your Name," recreates conversations and scenes from decades earlier that he couldn't possibly remember, and as a writer of memoirs myself, I wondered how much art embroiders the reality he is describing.
The center section is about the legal ramifications of the 1977 attempt of Nazis to march in Skokie, while the last third brings us up-to-date to the present day I'm going to write a column about it so I don't wanna get too far into it, but it makes her gripping read with a caveat that the center section explores every legalistic posture, maneuver, and nuance in microscopic detail.
I'm also finishing Andre Aciman's sweet and melancholy "Out of Egypt" on Audible, which I read years ago and was really just fact checking one passage but ended up listening to the whole thing. It's a sentimental look at his family before they were kicked out in 1965 part of the Arab world's purge of Jews into Israel, where it turns out they don't belong either. The book is billed as a memoir, though Aciman, who went on to write "Call Me by Your Name," recreates conversations and scenes from decades earlier that he couldn't possibly remember, and as a writer of memoirs myself, I wondered how much art embroiders the reality he is describing.
What's next? Beyond the obvious Philip Roth and Saul Bellow. I think I'm going to polish off Elie Wiesel's "Night," which I managed to miss in high school, when everybody else read it. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Very excited about this (understatement). You are the perfect wordsmith to tackle such a profound yet personal topic. Since you asked...check out the writings of Dara Horn. Her latest, and first non-fiction book, is "People Love Dead Jews". Also, the weekly podcast "Being Jewish with Jonah Platt" may be an excellent resource as it explores modern Jewish identity, culture, and current events through conversations with notable public figures, artists, and community leaders. Jewish pride and identity is front and center.
ReplyDeleteI read the Horn book — very good. I've seen the podcast on instagram, but never tuned in. I'll check it out, thanks.
DeleteAre you as disheartened as I am by El-Sayed's victory on Tuesday? And in paragraph four, the word should be spelled "pogrom."
ReplyDeleteNot particularly, I tend to take a long haul view of these things. Israel is on the ropes now, but it's been on the ropes before, isn't going anywhere and won't be undone by some congressman from Michigan. And I fixed the spelling, thanks.
DeleteEl-Sayed reminds me a lot of many Jewish politicians from the sixties and seventies. For the life of me I cannot understand why so many Jews are afraid of him, or other Muslims.
DeleteGrowing up, I was taught about the relationship between African American's and Jews. The march on Washington, the struggles, the fight for voting rights, white and black brothers and sisters murdered in cold blood for being black or Jewish. That relationship was destroyed by Israel.
Jews used to be fighters for just causes, for the downtrodden. Now, we hid behind antisemitism and fear. Unable to defend netenyahoos actions we turn into Jerry Seinfeld's uncle Leo and claim everyone is antisemitic.
The things in this world i fear the most... religious zealots. No matter what religion, they are all evil. I don't believe or even have reason to believe, El-Sayed is anything other than a progresive american.
Hmmm... For starters, "That relationship was destroyed by Israel" is nonsense. Jewish support for civil rights was mooted because they're still white. And some Jews still are supporters for just causes. TikTok is not an accurate representation of the community.
DeleteNeil, From what I've been told and read (and i hope I'm wrong) was that during the eighties and nineties there was a major rift brought about by the Israeli Palestinian issues. Many in the black communities felt that Israel was acting wrongly (a fair critique) and many Jews felt that this was antisemitic... seems strangely prescient of today's landscape.
DeleteBut it's more likely we were pushed apart by people who see us as a threat when we agree.
I plan on watching Henry Louis Gates' PBS piece on this.
Mr El Sayad appears not to have gotten the majority of Black votes.
Deletethe Black vote went about 60-40 against el sayad. his victory likely will lead to a dem loss in michigan, and there fore no chance at turning the senate
DeleteI have only read one Philip Roth book, back in college, but I found The Great American Novel to be hysterical! About a hapless baseball team who has to play all of their games on the road because their stadium is being used by the government during WWII. I know you are not much of a baseball fan, but I found this to be a very good read.
ReplyDeleteTry "The Universal Baseball Association, Inc., J. Henry Waugh, Prop.". Also not really about baseball, but deeply despairing.
DeleteReading on your phone? I highly recommend a Kindle! Easy one handed reading. Much better experience than phone reading. And really one with any shoulder issues should never carry books around. A kindle is perfect for train and vacation reading. You can even get a waterproof version.
ReplyDeleteI am a phone reader and love it. I switched from my kindle due to occasional severe arthritis in my hands that made using the kindle awkward especially while lying in bed which is my favorite position for reading. An added benefit is tab I can read no matter where I am as I always have my phone with me.
Delete"The Promise" by Chaim Potok (sequel to "The Chosen"). "The Plot Against America" by Philip Roth.
ReplyDeleteRead "The Plot Against America." Completely chilling.
DeleteEspecially the pogroms in Midwestern and Eastern cities. And the fictional Walter Winchell character is chilling. His assassination comes as no shock.
DeleteFor those unaware, the 1949 anti-Jewish rioting in Englewood is not fictional. It was basically anti-black, anti-Jewish, and anti-Communist. Not surprising, considering those nervous Cold War times. Just one of many white riots in Chicago, and its inner-ring suburbs, between the end of WWII and the late 70s.
Victor Frankl
ReplyDelete"Man's Search for Meaning"? Read it earlier this year.
DeleteI also did not read Night in high school... or college. I only read it after I saw Mr. Wiesel speak.
ReplyDeleteIt profoundly changed me.
As a Jew, it has also helped me remain steadfastly against the current actions of the Israeli government and its supporters.
I read "Night" about 25 years ago. So many years ago that I don't remember it well, other than it's disturbing. I read "The Chosen" about three years ago. An excellent book.
ReplyDeleteAs a volunteer docent with the Holocaust Memorial Foundation on Main Street in Skokie in the 90’s I received specific recommendations on what to read outside mainstream interests that provide deep, albeit dense context, extremely relevant today. A few sources; each author is worth looking up to learn of their lives and works:
ReplyDeleteWalter Laqueur’s The Terrible Secret: Suppression of the Truth about Hitler's Final Solution - or anything he wrote
Primo Levi - If This is a Man, formerly known as Survival at Auschwitz.
Andre Gides’ important novel, Last of The Just, is weighty and structured around the legend of the 36 righteous ones (lamed-vavniks) as followed through centuries of persecution. It’s a story of incredible endurance and more: readers meet with the unassuming righteous who do not know themselves that they represent the light of the world in all their base humanity.
There are many more, but I offer these as among the first to have affected me deeply and personally.
Oh, one more to keep your hope-heart beating: Philip Hallie’s true story-Lest Innocent Blood be Shed: The Story of Le Chambon and How Goodness Happened there. Check You-Tube for survivor Pierre Sauvage’s beautiful documentary on this called “Weapons of the Spirit.”
Best wishes as you “write into the world” the stories we most need, and have forgotten how to ask for. Those you reach may find their own lights by which to live more deeply in these difficult days.
Michael Chabon's The Yiddish Policemen's Union, about a Jewish settlement in Sitka rather than in the Middle East.
ReplyDeleteVery fun book. Read it when it came out. Also his "Kavalier and Clay."
DeleteThe new opera, Kavalier and Clay, at The Met was fairly well received.
DeleteParts of War and Rembrance. Iam not Jewish, but Wouk gave me much better and deeper understanding of what it was like to be Jewish during WW II. On both sides.
ReplyDeleteSurvival in Auschwitz by Primo Levi is a good companion memoir to Night
ReplyDeleteCold Crematorium by Josczef Debrezeni (sic?)
The Gatekeepers, not a book but an excellent documentary by 6 former heads of Shin Bet.
Last year I read a wonderful book by a local author. Fagin the Thief, by Allison Epstein. (Yes, Oliver Twist's Fagin.) I highly recommend. The book received the 2026 National Jewish Book Award for Fiction and the American Library Association’s Sophy Brody medal, and was a finalist for the 2026 Edgar Award for Best Novel. The author came to our book club (at a local bookstore) when we discussed the book.
ReplyDeleteIt's the accompanying photo. That's the problem.
ReplyDeleteYou're obviously proud of your collection, as am I, and I suspect most readers are.
But that's the rub. What do you do with them once you're done?
(slip this mortal coil and join the choir invisible)
Seems no one wants them any longer. Recently I've tried shedding some books and found it mostly impossible. I'd say, "But these are good books" to deaf ears. The best you can do is donate them to your library, where they receive pennies on the dollar.
Let me recommend Daniel Mendelsohn's memoir, The Lost: A Search for Six of Six Million.
ReplyDelete"Only in America" is definite due for a revival. Harry Golden was a very smart guy.
ReplyDeleteI read "Night" years after high school, but it's funny to me that, out of all the ones you mention which I haven't even heard of, I read one that you haven't yet. Which will not be the case for long -- as disturbing as it is, it's pretty short.
ReplyDeleteI've read a few novels by Philip Roth. a couple by Saul Bellow, and "Man's Search For Meaning," but would have to say that my knowledge of Jewish literature is not very developed. I'm afraid that, since I liked "The Mysteries of Pittsburgh," I wanted to enjoy "Kavalier and Clay" more than I did.
I appreciated "The Plot Against America" much better when it was fiction. If you haven't seen it, HBO made a fine mini-series of it, written by David Simon and Ed Burns, famous for "The Wire," among other things.
Roth's evocative description of the Newark glove factory in "American Pastoral" was enjoyable to me in a similar fashion to many of your columns about factories and assorted businesses, NS.
"American Pastoral" is the first Phillip Roth book I read many years ago. Very impressive. I read the "The Plot Against America" around the time the clown car was bursting open in 2016. Chilling.
DeleteIt's not a Jewish book. It's a novel about a bit of resistance against Hitler during the war years in Germany: Every Man Dies Alone by Hans Fadalla. He gets so close to his characters. It's based on a Gestapo file. Fadalla, a well respected writer, finished the book and killed himself. I think it was originally published in 1946.
ReplyDeleteThis post and the many comments bring to mind how wonderful people can be. Even when sharing some incredibly terrible things. We need each other.
ReplyDeleteOn the lighter side, I thought Crossing California by Adam Lanier was funny as hell.
ReplyDelete