![]() |
The last remaining building of the Robert Taylor Homes (Wikimedia Commons) |
Wednesday's column prompted several readers to sneer at me for residing in the relative safety of Northbrook, as if living in a nice place were something to be ashamed of. But my job has taken me to every corner of the city, sometimes at night, and I go because a) it's my job; and b) I know that peril is a calculation, danger = (location x time) — you can go to the most crime-ridden spot in the city in relative safety, depending on how long you spend there. Or as I often say: if people can live there, I can visit.
I'm writing a column that refers to this article, over 30 years old, that involved me visiting public housing projects at night. I thought I'd post it here so I can link to it. Maudlyne Ihejirika shared a byline on it with me.
What I remember most from this story is that the mother of the boy who picked up a melted large soda bottle and showed us how it had been transformed into a crack pipe, after publication called the paper, indignantly insisting that the teen was somehow coached by us — I was with photographer Bob Davis. As if either of us would have known, or thought to do that in a million years.
Remember: in 1994 Chicago registered 928 homicides, almost twice the figure of recent years.
Jenny Hodges up and left for Memphis. About a month ago. Took her kids and fled apartment 1310, on the 13th floor of the Rockwell Gardens high-rise at 2514 W. Van Buren. She wanted a better life.
Fine for her, says her neighbor, Gloria Lumpkins, who lives next door, in 1308, with her sister and their seven children. But Hodges' former apartment is vacant now — stripped, trashed, its door wide open, one of seven vacant apartments out of 11 on Lumpkins' floor.
"Nobody's in there but gang-bangers," says Lumpkins, 26. "They bust out the windows, throw things out the windows, use binoculars to shoot at people. There's lots of crime in here now because of vacant apartments."
Nearly one of every six CHA apartments is vacant – 6,184 of the CHA's 40,210 units citywide, now havens for crimes such as the murder of Eric Morris, 5, last Thursday. At Henry Horner homes, entire buildings are vacant. The top eight floors at 1847 W. Washington are sealed off.
"A lot of stuff used to happen up there — rapes and stuff," says Charlean Brown, 19.
"It's sealed off, but you can get in," says Johnny Brown, 22.
To show how accessible the apartments are, a trio of teenage boys – Michael Matthews, 15, Corey Bennett, 15, and Tony Dawson, 14 - go up to a vacant eighth-floor apartment at 1920 W. Washington.
"It's messed up inside," says Michael. "They smoke crack in here."
Broken glass is scattered around, along with beer bottles, blankets and an old foam mattress.
"See that," Corey says, picking up a plastic rubbing alcohol bottle and explaining how a certain addict uses it to smoke crack. "He uses this to push the drugs down," he says, holding the bottle like a pipe and jamming down imaginary drugs with a nail tamper.
"They put crack inside cigarettes," says Michael, who adds that the boys know because they've watched the addict through the open door. "He saw us looking, got mad, and threw stuff."
"We'll be playing in the hallways; he'll be smoking his pipe," says Corey.
Even those vacant apartments remaining empty add to the fear of residents in CHA developments.
"You don't know what it's like. You never know what might come out at you from those apartments," says Jan Murray of 3833 S. Langley in Ida B. Wells, where Eric Morris died last week. "You call and call CHA, and it takes forever for them to come out."
"If we don't make sure they board them up, they don't board them up," says Arthur Covington, 17.
Many CHA residents complain about the need those apartments could be filling.
"People want to get in and live in them and they can't get in," says Mike Hanson, 22.
"People need these apartments," says Kenny Harper, 33. "They could get them together, looking good, but they don't."
Officials are trying. Calling vacancies a major boon to gangs, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development allocated $10 million this summer for the CHA to reduce vacancies in Robert Taylor and Stateway Gardens, after a rash of shootings.
Last month, the federal government granted a record $30 million to fix up about a quarter of the CHA's vacant apartments.
"Until we get the money to tear down these high-rises, there are always going to be tragic cases like this," CHA Chairman Vincent Lane said, referring to Eric's death. "We board up those units and they tear them right back down."
A history of work orders for the board-up of Apt. 1405, a vacant unit in a 14-story building at Ida B. Wells, illustrates the agency's losing battle.
A CHA crew had just been out to board up the apartment — again – hours before two youths allegedly broke in and threw Morris out of a window.
CHA's dilemma is no comfort for residents of buildings with vacancies.
There are accidents. A 5-year-old boy wandered into a vacant unit in Rockwell Gardens last June and fell 13 stories from a window to his death.
There are rapes. A 23-year-old man was charged in 1991 with 10 rapes in the ABLA neighborhood, five of them in vacant units in the development.
Gangs use them. Seven-year-old Dantrell Davis was killed in Cabrini-Green in 1992 by a reputed gang member shooting at rivals from a vacant unit.
Not every building has a problem with vacancy. At 1900 W. Washington, a strong sense of community has kept the apartments occupied.
"This building is full," said Angela Doles, 22, who credits building president Della Walker with keeping people involved. "If you join your building group and participate you keep your building going."
—Originally published in the Sun-Times, October 17, 1994
Jenny Hodges up and left for Memphis. About a month ago. Took her kids and fled apartment 1310, on the 13th floor of the Rockwell Gardens high-rise at 2514 W. Van Buren. She wanted a better life.
Fine for her, says her neighbor, Gloria Lumpkins, who lives next door, in 1308, with her sister and their seven children. But Hodges' former apartment is vacant now — stripped, trashed, its door wide open, one of seven vacant apartments out of 11 on Lumpkins' floor.
"Nobody's in there but gang-bangers," says Lumpkins, 26. "They bust out the windows, throw things out the windows, use binoculars to shoot at people. There's lots of crime in here now because of vacant apartments."
Nearly one of every six CHA apartments is vacant – 6,184 of the CHA's 40,210 units citywide, now havens for crimes such as the murder of Eric Morris, 5, last Thursday. At Henry Horner homes, entire buildings are vacant. The top eight floors at 1847 W. Washington are sealed off.
"A lot of stuff used to happen up there — rapes and stuff," says Charlean Brown, 19.
"It's sealed off, but you can get in," says Johnny Brown, 22.
To show how accessible the apartments are, a trio of teenage boys – Michael Matthews, 15, Corey Bennett, 15, and Tony Dawson, 14 - go up to a vacant eighth-floor apartment at 1920 W. Washington.
"It's messed up inside," says Michael. "They smoke crack in here."
Broken glass is scattered around, along with beer bottles, blankets and an old foam mattress.
"See that," Corey says, picking up a plastic rubbing alcohol bottle and explaining how a certain addict uses it to smoke crack. "He uses this to push the drugs down," he says, holding the bottle like a pipe and jamming down imaginary drugs with a nail tamper.
"They put crack inside cigarettes," says Michael, who adds that the boys know because they've watched the addict through the open door. "He saw us looking, got mad, and threw stuff."
"We'll be playing in the hallways; he'll be smoking his pipe," says Corey.
Even those vacant apartments remaining empty add to the fear of residents in CHA developments.
"You don't know what it's like. You never know what might come out at you from those apartments," says Jan Murray of 3833 S. Langley in Ida B. Wells, where Eric Morris died last week. "You call and call CHA, and it takes forever for them to come out."
"If we don't make sure they board them up, they don't board them up," says Arthur Covington, 17.
Many CHA residents complain about the need those apartments could be filling.
"People want to get in and live in them and they can't get in," says Mike Hanson, 22.
"People need these apartments," says Kenny Harper, 33. "They could get them together, looking good, but they don't."
Officials are trying. Calling vacancies a major boon to gangs, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development allocated $10 million this summer for the CHA to reduce vacancies in Robert Taylor and Stateway Gardens, after a rash of shootings.
Last month, the federal government granted a record $30 million to fix up about a quarter of the CHA's vacant apartments.
"Until we get the money to tear down these high-rises, there are always going to be tragic cases like this," CHA Chairman Vincent Lane said, referring to Eric's death. "We board up those units and they tear them right back down."
A history of work orders for the board-up of Apt. 1405, a vacant unit in a 14-story building at Ida B. Wells, illustrates the agency's losing battle.
A CHA crew had just been out to board up the apartment — again – hours before two youths allegedly broke in and threw Morris out of a window.
CHA's dilemma is no comfort for residents of buildings with vacancies.
There are accidents. A 5-year-old boy wandered into a vacant unit in Rockwell Gardens last June and fell 13 stories from a window to his death.
There are rapes. A 23-year-old man was charged in 1991 with 10 rapes in the ABLA neighborhood, five of them in vacant units in the development.
Gangs use them. Seven-year-old Dantrell Davis was killed in Cabrini-Green in 1992 by a reputed gang member shooting at rivals from a vacant unit.
Not every building has a problem with vacancy. At 1900 W. Washington, a strong sense of community has kept the apartments occupied.
"This building is full," said Angela Doles, 22, who credits building president Della Walker with keeping people involved. "If you join your building group and participate you keep your building going."
—Originally published in the Sun-Times, October 17, 1994
Neil as I'm sure you know due to your extensive travel throughout Chicago the complexion of neighborhoods can change abruptly in just a block or two.
ReplyDeleteSometimes it as simple as passing under a viaduct the proverbial other side of the tracks
Garfield Park conservatory is one of the jewels of the city and I'm glad you've visited.
When we were looking for property we focused on this area as one of your commenters mentioned it has begun to gentrify. This was not the reason that we eventually settled on warren boulevard.
We looked at many buildings some of which were uninhabitable we finally found a two flat just one Street west of the park.
We pass by that building nearly every day and the vacant lots and boarded up buildings on that block have not changed in the last 2 years.
Fortunately we did not end up in West Garfield Park it's very dangerous.
The land that the conservatory is located upon is a broad boundary between two very different neighborhoods
It's close to where I work on Chicago and Cicero my business has been there for 27 years.
I was born in this neighborhood at Ohio and Trumbull and lived at North and Central until I graduated high school in 1976.
Raised three boys in the city and they attended public schools.
The main thing that drew me to this area was the urban agriculture that goes on over here people have bought multiple adjacent lots when it was very affordable and they do some terrific things here.
Right after high school I moved to North avenue and Halsted right across the street from the Cabrini-Green housing complex
I've always chosen to live in diverse communities in the midst of predominantly African-American families.
I'm a blue collar guy and I live in the heart of the City.
I too spent some time inside of the high rise housing projects my friends lived there.
I don't mean to sneer at you or indict you for your decision to live in a much more homogeneous area.
I'm not trying to cast aspersions at your decision to live someplace safer.
One of the great things about living in the United States is that you can reap the benefits of nearby communities while not paying taxes to support them you can send your children to excellent schools and still take advantage of the things the city provides that aren't available where you live . Native Chicagoans have always been suspicious of transplants that have come from other parts of the Midwest or the country or even from other countries it just seems embedded in our DNA
.
You all are welcome to come here to live here to enjoy what we have to offer heck I've invited you to come down where I live several times when I was at 70th and Woodlawn and now that I'm at Sacramento and Warren I know you're a busy man and you can choose who you interact with
I was careful where I chose to live when my children were young but now that they're grown men I can live in places that aren't as safe and not be concerned for their well-being and I'm old and I'm invisible chances are nobody's going to mess with me just like they don't mess with you you don't pose a threat to anybody's turf. Just another tourist.
Big fan of your writing don't always agree with your point of view.
Crime in Chicago is problem and the administration in City Hall does not seem to be able to get it under control. You don't seem to have any good ideas as to how to make that happen.
I think that Neil has from time to time recommended the very things that Brunan has termed necessary for a long term solution: "jobs, opportunity, community action and more law enforcement in high crime areas." And he has vehemently opposed the window dressing of imported military presence beloved of Trump and his henchmen.
Deletetate
Interesting points, Franco about those who don't live in the city. Perhaps you should move your business to a safer area.
DeleteFranco, you are wrong if you think a crime won't be committed against you because you are old.
DeleteGreat comment. Really makes me wonder why they don't mess with you, even if you're old and therefor invisible (as all old people eventually become), and are nota threat to any bangers. Some people of color just do not like white folks, and would mess with them for that reason alone. The opposite face of the coin, if you will...and quite literally. But can you blame them? I can't. Too many of them have led lives in which they always end up with "the fuzzy end of the lollipop"--as Marilyn Monroe famously put it.
DeleteBack in my Wrigley bleacher days, I was friendly with a very popular Greek/Italian guy. His main gig in Chicago, as far back as the Eighties, was on a CHA maintenance crew, repairing and renovating apartments in the public housing high-rises. He did them all...Henry Horner, Rockwell Gardens, Cabrini-Green, Ida B. Wells, and more.
My friend told me stories that would curl your hair...or straighten it. Among them was the terrible tale of Eric Morse. Two of the five-year-old's schoolmates, aged ten and eleven, asked him to steal candy from a store, but he refused. Eric was then taken to a vacant apartment on the 14th floor of a high-rise building in the Ida B. Wells Homes, dangled from a window, and dropped to his death.
Anonymous 10:59
DeleteI'm 67 years old and as I said my business has been there for 27 years. It's not going to be moved.
All the people that work their live nearby. It's my intention to be a positive force in the community. We support the public school across the street. This city is my home
Reader, enough with the negative vibes:)
Frank, enough with your high horse comments.
DeleteWhen you pack a lot of poor people into a neighborhood and most don't have a job they find other ways to survive. Now, the issue is being exaggerated and used as a political football. Bringing in the national guard may help lower the crime rate in the near term but will not offer a long term solution. Jobs, opportunity, community action and more law enforcement in high crime areas would help.
ReplyDeleteAbout 50 years ago I accidentally drove past a housing project. I honestly don't remember which one because at the time I didn't have any idea how I got there. I wasn't scared being there, more curious and sad. My traveling companion said we needed to get out of there, so that's what we did.
ReplyDeleteRegular reader here. I heard only one personal sneer, from a commenter you tend to regularly spar with. Maybe it's my rural Minnesota roots that interprets language and personal attack differently. I know it contributes to giving leeway to anyone dealing with illness.
ReplyDeleteAnd parental responsibilities must improve, esp. more so from dads.
ReplyDeleteEmptying the high-rise cha buildings through the clock resulted in tens of thousands of people with few options of where to go. many of whom left the city completely.
ReplyDeleteThe city failed to produce the low-income properties promised to these folks in some of them have ended up homeless.
It's really a shame that these folks first were warehoused and then abandoned these are people with very few resources almost no jobs in the area where they lived and were victims of brutal policing.
I've had some experience with public housing. First, I did community health nursing in Gary, IN in the 1970s. Back then, there was "honor among thieves" and nurses were considered untouchable. I don't think this is the case any longer, but I hope that unwritten rule of the street still applies. The guys hanging out on the street in front of the housing units would stop talking as I approached, and all would silently nod as I walked past them. Their conversations started back up after I entered the building.
ReplyDeleteThe most unsettling part about entering these apartments, for me, was the vermin. I would see cockroaches, mice and rats. I brought a cockroach home with me more than once. The people I worked with were nice, though.
Later in my career, I worked with residents of ABLA homes. When they began to tear down ABLA, residents were assisted with relocating to other places, but the options were awful. One woman I worked with was holding out for the promise of a better place. As her building emptied out, conditions became unlivable for those that remained. One morning she woke up and discovered pipes had been stolen, causing water to run down the hallways. It was winter and ice formed on the steps. She was pregnant and worried she might miscarry if she slipped on the ice.
I suggested she write a letter to Vincent Lane, who was head of Housing at the time. I had a personal computer in my office, and I let her compose the letter on the computer. I made sure she included her fears of falling on the ice in the letter. When she finished, I helped her print it and address the envelope. The very next week, she was relocated to the housing unit she had been promised. She was rightly proud of herself for advocating for herself and her family. I learned a lot from her, and from others who lived in CHA apartments over the years - about poverty, resourcefulness, inequity, and systems that are rigged for failure, to name a few.