Wednesday, March 11, 2026

With 2 Passover Seders, it helps to have 2 working wrists


     Two days after Thanksgiving, my wife broke her wrist in two places. Slipping on ice in the parking lot of Sunset Foods. And no, she didn't sue. Not yet anyway.
     For a few months, she couldn't twist the cap off a jar. She's a little better now, though the injury has been slow to heal. It still hurts, sometimes a lot. I try to help as best I can. Cooking, for instance, has become a two-person job. She instructs, I comply.
     Which matters, since Passover is bearing down on us: April 1, for you fans of irony. A Seder is a long, complicated feast, served to lots of guests. Seders would be a challenge to prepare with three strong wrists and a prehensile tail. For someone who's hurt ...
     And to top it off — because religion is, if nothing else, ritual excess — I'll tell you a secret that only Jews are privy to: There are TWO Seders. Not even all Jews know that — growing up a Reform Jew, I sure didn't. One Seder was plenty for us. It might take a whole hour. Giving up bread for a few days was our Golgotha.
     But observant Jews who aren't in Israel hold two — count 'em two — Seders, on consecutive nights, because ... well, it's complicated. Something about the crescent moon, and diaspora Jews not being sure when it appears over a land where we supposedly don't belong even though we've been living there continually for 2,000 years. So two Seders, to make sure the moon is in the right place over Israel.
     I'll be honest — twin Seders strike me as a lurch into fanaticism. Then again, I regularly indulge visiting cheder boys — young Hassidim in black garb — by praying with them when they stop by, our devotions somehow nudging the tarrying messiah along. So who am I to judge?
     Typically, my sister-in-law Janice holds the second Seder, a briefer, more casual affair. (Ours can clock in at six hours, speaking of pious excess, though that cuts down on outsiders angling for invites). But in one of those odd spasms of sisterly competitiveness, Janice contrived to recently break her wrist, too, just to one-up my wife.
     So now we're hosting both Seders.
     Madness, right? I started offering solutions.
     "Scrap the second Seder," I urged.
     No, my wife said. We man the ramparts of our faith and must stick our landing, moon-wise.
     "Let Prairie Grass cater them."
     No. We do not offload our religious responsibilities. We did not hire Sarah Stegner to bless our children when they married. Nor will chef Sarah be preparing our Seder feast, as delightful as the result would certainly be. Like Christmas trees, carryout festive meals are for the enjoyment of others. Not us.
     "I will prepare the Seder!" I announced.
     My wife snorted and gave me a pitying look. Really, it's as if, 35 years ago, I'd said, "OK, I will bear our children then!"
     "We could go to Paris again ..."
     One year, a decade ago, we shucked our responsibilities and fled to Paris during Passover, where we marked the holiday by walking arm-in-arm down the Rue Mouffetard, eating warm bread out of a paper bag. That's one beauty of Judaism — a very flexible faith. The last Jew excommunicated was Spinoza.
     Again no. I opened my mouth to point out that, what with the price of brisket at Romanian Kosher Meats, a trip to Paris might be cheaper. But ...
     The canyon floor is hurtling up, and this is the place where I'd typically offer a neat resolution, though one is not at hand. My bet: two Seders, prepared by my wife, me, and an "I am Spartacus!" cast of family volunteers. Seders were held in concentration camps. Our North Shore bed of ease and plenty will manage, even if our prime movers are creaky in the wrist department.

To continue reading, click here.

21 comments:

  1. lovely table setting

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love it that maintaining the tradition is still important to you. Especially in these times. Have a sweet and joyous Pesach.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was admiring the beautiful table setting, and about to ask if that china has been handed down from ancestors, when I zeroed in and realized they are paper plates (I think). Still striking, though, especially when you add the brisket, my favorite

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And Hassidics won't help Israel and fight for them. Same for the Orthodox that are there.

      Delete
    2. Yes, I know. Your point being ... that I should only ... interact with people who belong ... to groups whose conduct I entirely endorse? And which groups are those? I don't think you've thought your comment through.

      Delete
    3. Did two years of Hebrew school before dropping out. I vaguely recall twin-bill Seders, but they weren't back-to-back. More like day-night doubleheaders...one on the first night and one on the final night. But we're talking almost 70 years ago, so my memory might be failing me.

      Love the portrait you painted of your family Seders, Mister S. Brings back so many Passover scenes of my own...some good...some...well...not so much.

      My parents' dining room in Skokie when I was in fourth grade, with my mother tearing her hair out trying to be a good hostess, my grandmother's cooking, her Socialist/union organizer/hardware-store-owning husband yelling out dirty songs in Lithuanian. His grown sons and daughters cracking jokes, and his grandsons shooting dice with me in my bedroom. And their beautiful teen-age sister, the princess who later died tragically. Leukemia, at 17.

      Another Seder day-night, a few years' later, hosted by my now- widowed grandmother, with my abusive father barking at me...the sullen 14-year-old sneaking glasses of wine and getting tipsy and mouthy and snarky. The belt coming off when we got home, and me warning the old man I'd deck him. He knew I was serious. Last time he ever tried. A holiday memory one can't just pass over.

      They're all long gone now. Just me and my kid sister left.
      We will be joining them before too long.

      Delete
    4. NS: no one said not to interact with them. Just stating an observation.

      Delete
    5. What was your point then? To tell me facts you thought I didn't know. I know.

      Delete
    6. Others here might not know.

      Delete
  4. Your indulging the cheder boys, earnest and innocent as they are, is a bit surprising. The Hassidim, with their constrictive and gender specific attitude regarding women, and their overwhelming support of Don Whoreleone, would seem to be a dealbreaker. They do the rest of us Jews, assimilated and non-observant as we are, no favors.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They might look alike, but Hassidim actually differ. You're thinking of the Satmar sorts, who are big for Trump. These kids are Lubavitch, a more liberal gang. Besides, if I didn't deal with folks who lean Trump ... well, it would be a lonely life.

      Delete
    2. Have you ever been in a Lubavitch home?
      Everywhere are photos of their now dead rebbe, Schneerson, they worship as the messiah. The walls, the tables, everything has his photo!
      And more liberal than who?
      They still treat women as second class people!

      Delete
    3. My wife and I currently have no Trumpers in our lives. Pretty much cut them out of our existence before the end of his first term. Lonely? Perhaps. More like being isolated and reclusive and solitary. Trump didn't cause that. It started long before.

      And you could probably add "out-of-touch with today's world"...as my EGD comments so often reveal. Not counting relatives, you can count the people we're close to on two hands. No wonder I don't need a phone. But not a Trumper among them.

      Delete
    4. I have a cousin who is a regular gun toting Trumper and we have hours long conversations about life, our animals, growing older, whatever. We just don't go there. What's the point? Trump has made life harder in a lot of ways. I'll be damned if I'm going to give up family members because of him. And I'm really proud of my daughter. She's as so called woke as woke could be, and her father went all in on Trump. But she feels time goes by so quickly, and we're all getting up there, and she wants a relationship with her dad. And she does; they just try their best to avoid some subjects. Or even better: love your people, differences and all

      Delete
    5. Well said, Clark St.

      Delete
    6. Carol no no no no no no no no no no!

      If you're friendly towards people who support Trump the next thing you know they'll be forcing you to have a baby you don't want even though you don't have any insurance.

      These people are evil incarnate I'm skipping a funeral for my first cousin this weekend because it's in Missouri and they're all Trump supporting Christians.

      You don't understand they haven't made things harder they've destroyed this country and everything that it stands for.

      They're fascists and white nationalists.

      How can you even still be related to them?

      Delete
    7. Well, Franco, as I said, I've been able to maintain a relationship with my cousin by just not discussing Trump. I haven't always been like this. There's been times in the past when we started in and got into shouting matches over politics. But this is someone I care for, and I'm sorry, I think people, especially older people who have lived through a lot, are kind of ridiculous to throw away relatives over Trump. And as far as my daughter, her father is my ex husband, so not my problem. And if I am forced to have a baby, that might bring me my chance to meet Pope Leo as they investigate the miracle of a lady of my age giving birth. In the end, I guess a person has to pick their battles.

      Delete
  5. The table is lovely, paper plates and napkins notwithstanding. But do I see a second table in the background? How many people are you expecting? I'm getting anxious on your behalf.

    ReplyDelete
  6. So go-eth every holiday in my memory, and we aren't Jewish. Funny, that.

    Also, funny that: "I will prepare the Seder!" brought echoes of The Hero Who Would Pay The Rent (see: The World's Shortest Play, a.k.a. You Must Pay The Rent... which I immediately performed for my daughter [now nearly 40], convinced that I neglected her upbringing by never having done so before). Thanks for the laughs.

    And the thinks.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The comments herewent awry, in a direction I guess I shouldn't be surprised they did, as it seems everything comes back to politics these days. And that made me enjoy this article even more than I did before I read the comments. I didn't think about the state of things for a few minutes as I got absorbed in the story, wondering where it was going, chuckling at the wry and gently irreverent take on one's faith that only comes from the faithful. The tale finally revealing that it was really about family, specifically the often flawed but long remembered holiday gatherings that we attended reluctantly in many instances. Thanks for a short but thorough detachment from, paraphrasing Thompson, the meat hook realities of this foul year of our lord twenty and twenty-six.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I believe in God but do not practice religion.
    You do not believe in God but practice religion

    Very interesting

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor. Please try to post under a name of some sort, so that other readers can differentiate between commenters.