For the offended

▼

What is this?

▼

Friday, November 20, 2026

'Saturday Night Live' sketch touches raw caregiver nerve



     Did you see “Sister,” the Saturday Night Live sketch? If not, give yourself a cookie for not spending your life on the internet. Because “Sister” owned all forms of social media this week, as every person traded it with every other person. You should watch it right now:
     If you can’t, the sketch — its actual name is “Elder Care Product” — is a parody of pharmaceutical commercials.
     “Dad, did you take your meds today?” says comic John Mulaney, laying a concerned hand on a white haired gent’s shoulder.
     “Uh, I ... ah, well don’t quite remember,” the confused coot sputters. Mulaney looks earnestly into the camera.
    “My dad means the world to me,” he intones. “So when I noticed him start to slow down, I knew I needed to get him the best care possible. ... I didn’t know where to turn. That’s when I heard about ... ‘Sister.’ ”
     Big laugh from the audience. He continues:
     “‘Sister’ is a live-in, 24-hour elder care provider that is completely free — and also your sister. Now I don’t have to worry about dad getting the care and attention he needs because I can get back to my life and the stuff I like to do.”
     The sketch touches a raw nerve of American life. Up to 50 million Americans are unpaid caregivers for relatives, and two-thirds of those are women.
      Shucking obligations to your aged parents is an American folk ailment. I know a woman who went bankrupt and had to sell her home to support her ailing parents while her siblings refused to help.
     I immediately messaged a link to the sketch to a friend, whose relationship with her brothers was shattered because of how they ignored their parents.
     “You saw this?” I wrote.

To continue reading, click here.

18 comments:

  1. My sister was the caregiver for our mother for nine years, with the help of a paid assistant and a visiting nurse. Of course, the fact that Sis and I were no longer close, and that she lived seven miles from Mumsy and I was 800 miles away, had a lot to do with our situation.

    Saw my mother about every three months. In the spring and the fall, we drove from Ohio to Minnesota. In the summer and the winter, I flew there alone. My mother's heart finally gave out in 2012. She was 92.

    We have long phone conversations every few months, but I haven't seen my only sibling in person for 14 years. My mother begged me not to become distant or estranged from Sis, and I assured her, more than once, that it wouldn't happen. But I knew better.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Did you ever relieve her for an extended period of time? You very well may have, but the idea never seems to occur to many a long-distance sibling.

      Delete
    2. That's what the hired help was for. Even my sister wasn't there every day.
      She went there about once a week, to deliver groceries and meds
      And she would whine about how hard it was. Seven miles each way. Ugh.

      My niece was between 15 and 24 during those years. She mostly snarked and criticized and patronized her eighty-something grandmother. She finished high school, got her BS, worked in a biology lab for a year, then shuffled off to Berkeley to earn two advanced degrees. Help and caregiving were beneath an academic, doncha know.

      Haven't seen her, or spoken to her, either. Fifteen years now.
      At 79, a pair of cousins are the only folks I'm still in touch with. Sad.
      A close-knit family we were not.

      Delete
  2. I haven't shared it with my brothers because it caused such an immediate stir, I assumed they'd happen upon it. (One brother does as much as he's able, given that he lives a bit of distance away and works shift work; the other brother could do far more but ... doesn't. He just does his thing and any help, mostly cutting the grass [on a riding mower], slots into his schedule.)

    I saw a stat yesterday that women who are caregivers forego, on average, about $120,000 in earnings and lost Social Security income. Neat!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sadly, the last line of that sketch goes by so fast as to usually be missed -- "Offer void if sister has a good therapist."
    It took me a year and a half of therapy after my mother passed to finally recognize how much the toll of being her primary caregiver for 6 years took on me financially, professionally, and psychologically. My siblings are blissfully unaware. But of course the inheritance was split evenly among all of us.
    One comment on the sketch read: "This is going to f* up a lot of Thanksgivings and I am there for it!"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ooh way to put a point on it. The inheritance.
      I read a study recently that people over 65 have 179 trillion dollars in combined wealth.

      My mom had a not insignificant estate. I offered to live with her but not in her home. Mine. A ranch style. She wanted no part of that after living alone for some 40 years.

      My sister and I looked at assisted living facilities. Nice ones. Nope.

      My sister lived with her for 2 years I came on the weekends and we employed respite care .until finally she gave in and moved to a facility . She loved it. So many new friends and activities.

      She passed 3 years ago and my sister , a saint thanks me all the time for helping get our family. Through this difficult time.

      Money really helps. I offered her part of my share she refused. Love and kindness is the most important thing.

      Delete
  4. I confess: I was the brother.

    When our mother developed dementia, my sister moved back home, giving up a rent-subsidized apartment on the Upper East Side of New York, to care for her and our autistic brother.

    Here are my rationalizations: It would have been nearly impossible for me to watch them while holding down a full-time job, even had I been willing to move in. My sister can't work due to illness. Even with the rent subsidy and a monthly stipend from me, sis struggled to survive in NYC. At least she got a free place to live. Plus, both mom and brother are now gone, and she has the house all to herself.

    Nonetheless, I would have been lost without her, and we both know it. I've been extra-generous on her birthdays and Christmases, but the only real way to repay her will be to be there for her when SHE needs it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Every family has different dynamics and circumstances, so the way this song plays out has many variations of the same theme. What i see that's different in your case, Bitter Scribe, is you were aware of it at the time, acknowledged it and have made an attempt to express gratitude and appreciation. That goes a long way for the sib stuck in the 'sister' role, especially while its all unfolding.

      Delete
    2. What resonates for me in this skit is the unnecessary undermining of the "sister" by the dumping sibling, which makes life harder for the 'sister' / "confirmed bitch'. My youngest sib fled the state when our dad was officially diagnosed with dementia, but called to validate his misery and suggest things would be better if she only lived closer. I was forced to strip our dad of independence and choice repeatedly, the worst was forcing him to have his driving evaluated by experts, which resulted in surrendering his license. I was never forgiven for that. And of course hiring live-in help was also cause for being dis-owned/ disinherited. All while the guilt-ridden sib (but not so guilt-ridden to come help) phoned it in and bonded with dad over how controlling and over-reactive I was being. Sib needed to believe dad was more functional than he actually was to assuage guilt, and perhaps also to experience being our dad's 'favored" child.
      ONE time, I requested 'coverage' for a weekend so I could travel with my husband to his business meeting. I arranged it months in advance. When the time came, actually traveling to IL was deemed unnecessary by sib. I expressed my doubt and disappointment but left anyway. When my plane landed and I turned off airplane mode on my phone and it exploded with text messages from Dad's caregiver. My dad's phone broke within an hour of me leaving town and sib was not responding to caregiver's calls.
      After my dad died, we didn't speak for over a year. Things are better now, but it took years of reparation.

      Delete
  5. I am so, so sad about how this SNL sketch is so true to life.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anthony Trollope touched on this subject in the delightful (yes, really) novel Miss Mackenzie, in which the heroine spends her youth taking care of her father, then polishes off another 8 or 9 years nursing her older brother, then barraged by fortune seekers, falls in love with her first cousin. I understand Trollope first described Miss Mackenzie as an "unattractive old maid," but fell in love with her himself before he finished the book in 1865.


    ReplyDelete
  7. Different scenario: being an only child and thinking for years about what the future holds, and how you are going to deal with it on your own. Feeling responsible for your mom having grandchildren, for having nice holidays, birthdays. And now, even though I have two girls, circumstances have left just one of them pretty much feeling that same responsibility towards me. And may I just say the way older people are treated in this country sucks. I get antenna tv, which is all old shows. And you are bombarded with ads about how it's time to put mom in a home. And the guy who knew he was in trouble when he left the stove on! And the women who can hardly leave home because of their incontinence. And let's not forget the oldster who could no longer satisfy his wife until he ordered his little blue pills. It's a wonder if anyone leaves this earth with an ounce of dignity or a dime left in their pocket.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Society is broken, in many ways.

    I blame reagan... well nixon resigning and preventing republicans for holding him accountable, but reagan stuck the knife in and twisted it.

    Reagan forced the second parent in middle class households to go to work just simply to maintain the status quo. republicans and reagan forced us to double our income just to maintain the lifestyles that we had grown accustom to for the past quarter to half a century.

    Before reagan, it wasn't as dificult because you had "free" live in help. Yes that's a disgusting way to put it for those homemakers, but its the dirty honest truth.

    The skit was brilliant because it took the blinders off and made people realize everyone is in the same boat... despite what the media tells us.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think this sketch has been given WAY too much thought. The only thing I could think of as I watched it was the Ann Landers adage: “No one can take advantage of you unless you give them permission”.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not sure you aren't perhaps giving the situation too little thought. Here's the situation: mom needs care. You are willing to give it; your sibling isn't. You can refuse to help, since your sibling isn't. Then mom suffers. Or you can do it, while your sibling coasts. Where does your permission come in? How do you force someone else to be a caregiver? You can't.

      Delete
    2. There are also laws to protect vulnerable elders. Immediate relatives can be charged with neglect or worse if something bad happens to the parent while the kids are still working out their obligations vs. entitlements. If dad's doctor tells the family that dad is no longer safe living alone, and a month later dad is found lost and wandering the streets at midnight, it doesn't matter whether you gave permission to be contacted after hours or not. Or which sibling should be on call that night. When the police call, you respond. As others have pointed out, the health system is broken,, and the SNL skit has effectively demonstrated the ways it fails the elderly and their families.

      Delete
    3. The whole setup for the sketch is that the sister is being conscripted into the caregiver role by a selfish, opportunistic sibling (male, of course) who doesn’t want to do any lifting, take on any expenses or make any hard decisions about assisted living alternatives. It goes on to imply that she quits her job, breaks her lease and moves hundreds of miles back home, undertakings that would presumably involve considerable inconvenience and consequences. That’s how her “permission” comes into it. She should be telling her brother, “Then we’ll spit the cost of a home caregiver, or else we start looking at nursing homes”. The writers cleverly hedge this by throwing in that mumbo jumbo about her brain being warped by “years of internalized sexism”, as if she’s not even a sentient human being. Why do you think they include that rapid fire disclaimer at the end about the offer being void if she hires a therapist? Because the therapist would tell her to quit letting her siblings walk all over her.
      Of course, it’s possible that Sister is pleased as punch at being called on to help out, and simply accepts that her brother is a useless clod, so her permission really isn’t an issue. But then, there wouldn’t be any “sketch”, would there?

      Delete
    4. Gosh BO, I wouldn't dream of arguing with you. "She should be telling her brother" again assumes that would work. It wouldn't. When someone completely misses the point, no amount of underlining it helps. Thanks for reading.

      Delete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.