Wednesday, September 21, 2016

Why do people have babies and drive cars?




     Why do people insist on having babies? When they know that many of them will end up as criminals? One percent of American adults are currently in prison. That means one out of every hundred newborns cooing in a bassinet can be expected to end up rotting in a bathroom-sized cell. And if you consider those who commit crimes but aren’t arrested, the one-in-100 failure rate for babies is even worse.
     And yet we keep having them. Why?
     The answer is easy. The babies are ours. We want them. So we ignore the considerable percentage who will go into the ditch, preferring to focus on the handful who will become baseball players or Nobel Prize winners or presidents.
     To suggest otherwise would seem demented. The certainty of future criminals is not an argument against babies, any more than the certainty of accidents is an argument to set highway speed limits at 15 mph. We accept — or would, if we thought about it, which we don’t — that not every child grows up into a contributing member of society, just as we accept that 30,000 people are going to die in 2017 on the roads. It’s a price we’re willing to pay for babies and driving.
     But not for immigrants. The Republican Party, led by Donald Trump, wants to roll back immigration, both Hispanics and Muslims — and I don’t think I am misstating their argument here — because: a) criminals are to be found among Hispanic immigrants; and b) terrorists are to be found among Muslim immigrants.

     That argument is not even an argument, for them. It is a deciding truth, almost a conditional formula. If criminals are to be found among Mexican immigrants, then we should build a big wall and block them. If terrorists blame Islam for their acts, then we should bar and harass all Muslims.
     "If I had a bowl of skittles and I told you just three would kill you. Would you take a handful?" read a poorly capitalized and punctuated graphic re-tweeted Monday by Donald Trump Jr. "That's our Syrian refugee problem."
     Imagine if it had been a picture of 100 babies. "If I told you just three would kill you . . ." Imagine 100 car trips. "If I told you just three would kill you . . ." Doesn't work, does it? Skittles can stand in for Syrian refugees because, to Trump, neither are people.
     It's such a simple truth that I've never seen it stated before. So here goes.
     So what? So what that some Hispanic immigrants are criminals? The fact—and I realize we have entered the post-fact world, but work with me—is they are criminals at a lower rate than those of us already here and scorning them; they have to be, because one speeding ticket can send them back over the border. To bring up criminality is to hypocritically condemn them for something they do better than citizens do. Then again, hypocrisy is what we embraced when we spurned reason.
     So what that some terrorists who commit acts of violence blame Islam? The percentage of the 1.6 billion Muslims is minuscule, and I would circle back to that 1 percent of American adults who are felons.
     Republicans don't accept the above two statements because they apply different standards to those they fear than they apply to themselves. Babies get a pass while immigrants don't because the GOP loathes immigrants, anyway, and criminality of a few is the fig leaf they hide their shame behind now that saying, "I hate these people and don't want them in my country," has fallen from favor.
     We certainly have an immigrant problem. We allowed 11 million Hispanic immigrants to live in legal limbo when they should have been on the road to citizenship long ago. And we have a refugee problem: America cowardly turned its back on thousands of desperate Syrians who would have become fine Americans, as would their children after them, had we only allowed it. Only we were too afraid.

10 comments:

  1. agree completely with your premise. but if we want to get the facts straight, many police departments, chicagos for sure do not enforce immigration laws. http://directives.chicagopolice.org/lt2015/data/a7a57b42-12ab41ab-48212-ab41-c1f5b5ad5c097076.html?ownapi=1 so being pulled over for a ticket will not get you deported. though sadly it could get you shot, but i digress.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Perhaps you should not be so dismissive of Trump's scheme to bar immigration from counties that sponsor terrorism. I might be a way to keep all those Saudi princes from coming over and buying up pricey Manhattan real estate.

    Tom Evans

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I await the day when one of the princes saunters down from his million-dollar digs and blows up Washington Square.

      John

      Delete
  3. Fantastic article. You casually note that we are in a post fact world. It is true and it is frightening. If words have no meaning then life has no meaning. Thank you to the political right for eliminating meaning from the sentient experience.

    Speaking of frightening - one out of a hundred adults is in prison? Something has gone very wrong here.

    ReplyDelete
  4. If drumpf should win (please, no), you, as a journalist, might not be allowed to posit many of your theories. While he claims Hillary will dump the 2nd amendment (which the president cannot do), he would like to void the 1st. We are, indeed, living in frightening times when a large segment of our society thinks such a heinous man should be the most powerful man in the country.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Skittles business isn't the first time Donald Jr. put his foot in his mouth. Perhaps he is destined to be the Billy Carter (or Roger Clinton) of the Trump administration. On the other hand, one presumes the padrone knows how to put a damper on him him, like Melania, if he gets too embarrassing.

    TE

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're assuming Trump, Sr., has the capacity to be embarrassed.

      Delete
  6. With Dump Jr's writing style or his dad's vocabulary, it makes me wonder how many people they paid to write their research papers for them in college.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This sets me thinking about my friends who never had babies and can't see the use of them. You can hardly believe they are ex-babies themselves.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for your comment, which will be published at the discretion of the proprietor.