Thursday, April 24, 2025

Coffee with the senator


     Sen. Dick Durbin announced Wednesday that he won't run for re-election. Of course he did. In an era when politicians leap to look out for themselves, first, last and always, clinging to power until it's pried away, Durbin is a man out-of-time, cleaving to the old standards of service to country before service to self. Who knows where we'd be today if Joe Biden had done the same in a timely fashion, although Durbin had the benefit of learning from Biden's bad example. I'll miss Sen. Durbin, for the good he did for our country, our state, and for how accessible he was — the kind of guy you could sit down with and share a cup of coffee.

OPENING SHOT

      Had a cup of java with my old pal Dick Durbin at a Madison Street coffee shop Thursday morning.
     "So you don't think Alito is so bad?" said Illinois' senior senator, alluding to a column I wrote suggesting that President Bush's current nominee to the Supreme Court wasn't the kind of towel-gnawing conservative crazy who would justify the Democrats kicking out the stops to block him. I assumed a filibuster was a flat-out political impossibility but Durbin — who is on the Judiciary Committee, and thus should know — disagrees.
     "I would have told you that last week," he said. "But after meeting with my colleagues, I'm not sure. We can't rule it out. I was surprised at the intensity of feeling."
     They are convinced that Alito will not only pitch Roe vs. Wade, but lead us into a world of excessive governmental power and reduced individual rights — a dark new Alito's America.
     Not that they got that across. A murderer's row of Democratic senatorial powerhouses, led by Ted Kennedy, had hours of choice TV time to tar Alito, and came off looking verbose and ineffective.
     "It wasn't an easy week, I'll tell you," Durbin said, with a laugh.
     To be fair, the Dems were in a bind -—anything resembling tough questioning would be seen as bullying a respected jurist, which doesn't poll well. So they were left speechifying and focusing on minutia.
     None of it added up to the impression that Alito was too conservative to serve.
     "We look back and say, 'What went wrong?' " said Durbin, who insists that the American people feel Bush won the election and therefore gets to pick his court nominee, but they didn't realize they would also be getting Alito's America.
     "Did he win the election saying he would appoint a justice to the Supreme Court to overturn Roe vs. Wade?" said Durbin. "This isn't what we bargained for."
     Durbin said Democratic senators will decide over the next several days whether they want to take the dramatic step of filibustering the nomination. It's still a long shot but, I'll tell you this: It would make great theater.

     — Originally published in the Sun-Times, Jan. 20, 2006

     Had breakfast the other morning with Sen. Dick Durbin and Dan Seals, the young Democrat who just might unseat Mark Kirk in the 10th Congressional District next week. We were discussing that age-old question of whether the current election really is the most mean-spirited in history or only feels that way. Conversation naturally moved to George Allen, the Virginia senator who, having pretty much dug his own political grave with his mouth, is desperately lashing out at his opponent, Jim Webb, by pointing shrilly to salty lines culled from Webb's war novels as if they were evidence of perversion. Durbin used a phrase I hadn't heard before.
     "George Allen is a spit tobacco senator," he said. "One of four in the Senate." Meaning that he dips and chews tobacco, a vile habit better left in the barn. But Allen doesn't leave it in the barn. Durbin entertainingly described a flight down to Guantanamo he and Allen shared on a military airplane, and the cringing revulsion the clean-cut, dignified and ramrod straight military hosts extended toward Allen, a drooling nicotine addict dribbling brown saliva into a plastic cup. That's a grosser image than anything in Webb's novels.
      — Originally published in the Sun-Times, Nov. 1, 2006

     For many years, my column took up a page and ended with a joke, often sent in by readers. Sen. Durbin shared what had to be a real occurrence

TODAY'S CHUCKLE ...

     Normally, you couldn't pry me off the couch on a Sunday afternoon. But this Sunday, Jan. 20, the first-ever 10th District Democratic Convention ... The public is invited, and the keynote address is by my old pal and regular reader, Sen. Dick Durbin who — completely unrelated to Sunday's convention — sent in this joke:
     The senior senator from Illinois was visiting an elementary school in Caseyville. Always eager to impart the importance of understanding our democratic system, the senator asked the children in a third-grade class whether anyone could name the vice president of the United States.
     There was a silence. Finally, a small voice from the back of the room ventured: "Judge Judy?"
     —Originally published in the Sun-Times, Jan. 18, 2008

27 comments:

  1. Wow. You sure got Alito wrong. Or, maybe he just finally felt emboldened to be the pos he turned out to be. I've already mentioned Durbin, but I wish him well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I’m a huge fan of Senator Durbin. In addition to all of the contributions he made to the country as senator, I have a personal reason as well. He cares strongly about the environment and thus agreed to read and then write a blurb for my book Of Prairie, Woods, and Water. He invited me to his office for a most memorable conversation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I would feel better heading into 2026 if we had a strong Chicago mayor to get out the Democratic vote (i.e. crack the whip!) in the Senate race. No such scenario would seem in the offing. Not with the current chap in place. Our best hope is for the Republicans to run another rube chucklehead like that clown who went up against Pritzker last time. Another yokel, please.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I live just outside of a small community in Southern Illinois. I served in the US military
      I graduated from the University of Illinois
      I work my family's farm

      I voted for Dick Durbin three times.
      I felt he was a better candidate
      I voted for Donald Trump this time. I felt he was the better candidate. But also I've grown tired of the direction our country was taking. I've also grown tired of being denigrated by people who would vote for a Democrat no matter what no matter who. The constant comments such as yours will not lead me to do the same. I will not revert to name calling. I am not a Republican I am an American we all are and we should be civil to one another. Your attitude serves no positive purpose



      I'm a yokel?

      Delete
    2. Bill, you must be kidding thinking that Trump would ever be a better candidate.

      Delete
    3. I won't blame Mr Steinberg if he refuses to post this comment. I am so angry I'm shaking. You sound absolutely defensive in your vote for this criminal who raped a woman. I voted for the best candidate, not a party affiliation. You deserve everything you have voted for.

      Delete
    4. Bill, I'm curious, given Mr. Trump's comments about the military and republican's continued crusade to slash veteran aid, why did you feel voting for a republican would be better for you?

      Delete
    5. I hear the "I'm denigrated so I backed a traitor" argument all the time. I would observe that Japanese-Americans left internment camps during World War II and volunteered to serve the country that had unjustly imprisoned them. As a Jew and a liberal, I am mocked continually by people such as the reader above. It would never permit me to support a Democratic version of DJT. And for the record, I love doing stories downstate, and will visit your family farm in a heartbeat.

      Delete
    6. My comment is not meant to address president Trump but that's all you hear I'm talking about myself who I am and what I've done defended this country invested in this country.
      And that makes you angry to think that a person could disagree with you about who they vote for and so you denigrate that individual what purpose does it serve does it make you feel better does it change anything?
      Is the most important thing to convince yourself that people who voted for Trump are stupid and useless?

      Delete
    7. I don't blame you for taking some offense at how Republicans, particularly the downstate variety, are often characterized. Fair enough. But then again, you voted for Donald Trump last November, and now you are lecturing Romberg that we are all Americans and should be "civil" to one another. You seem smart enough to recognize the hypocrisy, or at least the inconsistency, in that criticism.

      Delete
    8. I'll be 78 this summer, Bill. Third generation pinko. Lifelong Democrat...and I mean lifelong. . Grandparents were Bolsheviks and Socialists, eastern European immigrants. My parents were FDR-Truman-Stevenson Democrats. Went to the polls with my mother, at five. She did NOT like Ike.

      You voted for Trump in '24. What about '16 and 20? Just curious.
      Third time's the charm? Not so much...more like a train wreck this time around.

      Folks in Illinois are lucky. Ohio, to which I moved from Illinois 32 years ago, has two GOP clowns in the Senate. A scammy car dealer named Bernie Moreno, and the new replacement for the former head clown in the Ohio circus, Jethro D, Vance. He got kicked upstairs. He will prove to be even worse than his orange boss...when he time comes. Which it will.

      Spent half my life in Chicago...and most of the rest in Cleveland. Travel from the northern to the southern parts of either state, and it's easy to see why America tore itself apart in the 1860s.

      And my Magic 8-ball is telling me it's gonna happen again. If it does, you helped, in your own small way, to bring it on.

      It won't be pretty. Maybe you can hide out on the farm.

      Delete
    9. Maggie I did not vote for a Republican thinking it would be better for me. I thought it would be better for our country overall.
      Obviously so far that is highly questionable.

      Mr. Steinberg I did not say I voted for Trump as a reaction to having hurt feelings. And though your skill as a writer is outstanding your bias as a political commentator never able to see anything positive in what you refer to as the opposition , your vitriol and anti American attitude towards half the electorate precludes me from wanting to talk to you and I wasn't. I was interacting with another readers comment and suddenly I'm the type that mocks you. You don't know me or my type.

      I voted third party in 2016 and for Biden in 2020. He let me down. A common trait of many who've been president

      Delete
    10. Honestly Bill, I don't give a shit why you voted for Trump. And I'd have an easier time seeing "something positive" in guys like you if you didn't come up with utter bullshit like "vitriol and anti-American attitude toward half the electorate." Snowflake, you've delivered my country into the hands of its enemies, deeply hurt this nation, and caused incredible damage that might never be reversed. And you dare come around here, all weepy and pretending like you've been wronged. I know your type in my bones; it's common as dirt. And pathetic. Man up. Own the sin. You were duped, and now you're trying to defend it.

      Delete
    11. Bravo, Mr S...Bravo! Bravissimo!

      Delete
    12. An interesting exchange. Clearly, there's nothing more that needs to be said, but I seldom let that stop me. I would just like to point out to Bill that Romberg did not call *him* a yokel. He called Darren Bailey a yokel.

      Just wondering how "we should be civil to one another" applies to a candidate who repeatedly called Chicago a "hellhole." To me, dismissively alienating the largest concentration of voters in the state when you're trying to win a state-wide office would be an indication that one might indeed be a yokel.

      And this civility nonsense when uttered in support of the orange felon Bill thought was "the better candidate" is just beyond the pale. Nobody in public life, and I mean nobody, has been less "civil" than him.

      "I will not revert to name calling." Very noble. It would make more sense if you didn't support the politician who has done the most name-calling in the history of the presidency.

      One also wonders how Biden let Bill down. I hope it wasn't by restoring the economy to such an extent that The Economist magazine called it "the envy of the world" in October.

      Delete
    13. I have some sympathy for Bill. I will reply by name so y'all can roast me in future exchanges. I come from a family divided. So much so that I searched for literature that would help me understand. I found the book "The Divided Family in Civil War America" by Amy Murrell Taylor that I am working my way through. (not finished, yet!).
      I am proud to be a citizen of Illinois. As a birder, I travel across our fine state and have interacted with the locals along the way. I love Southern Illinois with the Big Muddy River, Carlyle Lake and Giant City State Park and I love Central Illinois with Emiquon, Chauttauqua and Midewin. I live in Cook County, outside of Chicago.
      I can speak with authority about split family loyalties as well as experienced voting differences across the state.
      In my family, the people who voted for Harris seemed to explain their vote as being cast for someone other than themselves (their children, a coworker, 'the future"). The people in my family who voted for Trump in 2024 had personal reasons - revenge and vindication by proxy, expectations of enhanced personal wealth, even "entertainment". One of my nephews explained he couldnt stand to hear Kamala Harris's laugh, so he voted for Trump, instead.
      I sincerely hope that those who voted for Trump are experiencing some 'reward' for having done so. Would hate to think they were hoodwinked into voting, only to have the man they elected throw them under the bus. With all that is going on, I truly want the "average Joe" voter to feel vindicated and rewarded for their vote.
      Regardless of motive, I forgive whomever now regrets their vote.
      The issue ahead of us is "how to move forward".
      My nephew (the one who couldnt stand Kamala's laugh) has now been assessed a penalty for late fees on his student loans. Will my sister (his mother) bail him out? That remains to be seen. Through it all, my nephew appears to be entertained by all the chaos wrought by the current administration. This satisfies him at some level, as if "they" had it coming to them. (who is "they"? Does he mean "us"?) .
      I also have a cousin who has become insufferable with her religiosity and superiority. She and I attended Sunday School together and prayed to the same God, yet we have divergent views regarding what Christianity represents. This is not unusual when it comes to religion, and I accept that. Yet my cousin seems to look for, even stage, reasons for her to feel disrespected or disparaged. Its as if her life's purpose is to be a martyr for the cause. This attitude gets old very quickly, especially when I am NOT looking to do battle with her!
      I do NOT bad-mouth my relatives or judge them as inferior to me. I want very much to improve my relationships with my own kin. I hope that is possible down the road, when Trump-mania has subsided.
      To you, Bill, I thank you for posting your name rather than hiding behind "anonymous. I respect your voicing of your dissenting opinion. Though I do not see the persecution or attack you say you have experienced here, I will not discredit your feelings. I hope you find peace. And I hope you have rea

      Delete
  4. I like the senator’s joke

    ReplyDelete
  5. Durbin is a good and decent man who understands the concept of democracy and works for all Americans. Oh, for an alternate universe where he was the president.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Since January, I have struggled greatly with my Senator Durbin Support.

    During Mr. Trumps first 30 days in office, I believe I called the senators offices every business day. And while i only talked to a staff member once or twice, I felt that he had the best interests of the American People, Illinois, and the United States of America in mind.

    Senator Durbin's handling of the government funding and shutdown was the first time I ever questioned his leadership.

    I won't pretend to suggest there was a right or a wrong in the funding fiasco. But i do believe Senator Durbin handled the optics and conversation around it wrong.

    It is clear Republicans do not care about governing. They don't believe in the truth or compromise. They do not believe in opacity. I implored Senator Durbin to explain his positions, his options, and the Democrats plan. I tried to get him to release an opposing options and funding bills. Make them public and force the hand of the the GOP. Sadly, he and Mr. Schumer kept things quite, dark, and shameful.

    In a world where it is becoming even more important to be open, honest, clear, and frank, the old guard of democrats are just too stuck in the belief that there are still good Republicans. The truth is, there are none. not a single one. Their silence publicly proves it. Their actions are undeniable. And Senator Durbin has been unable to really fight the way he needs to. I don't want his taint his legacy, but the times, they are a chaingin and the democrats are mostly not changing to meet the times.

    Democrats create decent policy and seem to have most American's best interests in mind. They fight to keep the government open and functioning even when it hurts them, their constituents, and their future bills. They just suck at messaging.
    There are things i will miss about Senator Durbin, hopefully the torch will be carried on by someone who was better than he was, as we should all strive to be better than the giants who came before.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. An excellent response. I agree completely.

      Delete
    2. Thanks, Maggie. That means quite a lot to me. I appreciate it!

      Delete
    3. Double B, from my experience with the Senator’s office and 2025 actions I could have written your exact post. Thank you for putting my doubts in your writing.

      Delete
    4. Thanks, Susan M. I'm glad to know it wasn't (and isn't) just me.

      Delete
  7. We will sorely miss Sen Durbin -- I don't need to agree with all of his decisions (ack, that vote for the budget!?!) to be grateful for his championship of reliable NIH funding (including for Alzheimer's/dementia research), of those DACA kids, his work on the Judiciary Committee and so much more. I admire his willingness to step aside while still physically and mentally sharp, and with time for contenders to step forward and make their case as a worthy successor

    ReplyDelete
  8. We will miss Senator Durbin. At this moment, there are folks in IL who have no idea how much they will miss Senator Durbin. Illinois has benefited from his advocacy and influence in Washington for so long, his leadership has been taken for granted. Still, I agree that its time to pass the torch. I just wish the timing wasn't so lousy.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Even the most rabid Trump cultists among my acquaintances said they voted for Durbin when he ran last time because they considered him intelligent and effective as a lawmaker.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I've always voted for Dick Durbin, and I agree that he has been a fine senator and good human being, but as I emailed him during the budget crisis, if he sided with Schumer, I would not vote for him again. His fund raising is in the toilet ($43K), and that has to be one of the reasons why he is not running again. I bet he received many emails like mine. The one thing Durbin was consistently right about was his decent and honorable support for Palestinian relief. The leading contenders to replace him all seem to be curiously silent AIPAC recipients.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.