| "Hear the other side" |
Judges matter.
We've been reminded of that ever since Congress abandoned its role as a check on executive power, as the occasional court ruling slows the president's continual efforts to break the law, sometimes resisted even by his hand-picked minions on the U.S. Supreme Court who sometimes favor the Constitution over obedience to the whims of their sponsor.
Typically, Supreme Court justices issue the most important judicial opinions. But no voice on the high bench resonated louder than that of Richard Posner, who died last Tuesday. And while he wrote eloquently on thousands of cases in more than a third of a century on the Chicago-based 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, one decision in particular affected the lives of millions of Americans: Baskin v. Bogin.
Penny Bogin was the clerk for Boone County, Indiana, a state that in 2014 still refused to recognize gay marriages performed in the 27 other states where it was legal.
A U.S. District Court ruled the Indiana law violated the Constitution's guarantee of equal protection.
The matter, combined with a similar case in Wisconsin, seemed headed for the Supreme Court. But first the case had to stop at the 7th Circuit, where Posner cut it off at the pass.
Haters rarely care about the people they hurt beyond their intended targets. Posner quickly drilled down to who Indiana's law truly harmed the most, writing:
"Formally these cases are about discrimination against the small homosexual minority in the United States. But at a deeper level, as we shall see, they are about the welfare of American children."
Posner had a genius for plain language:
"Indiana’s government thinks that straight couples tend to be sexually irresponsible, producing unwanted children by the carload, and so must be pressured (in the form of governmental encouragement of marriage through a combination of sticks and carrots) to marry, but that gay couples, unable as they are to produce children wanted or unwanted, are model parents — model citizens really — so have no need for marriage. Heterosexuals get drunk and pregnant, producing unwanted children; their reward is to be allowed to marry. Homosexual couples do not produce unwanted children; their reward is to be denied the right to marry. Go figure."
To continue reading, click here.






