Saturday, June 29, 2024

This is the Hour of Lead

 
Emily Dickinson

    The first thing I did after the debate was check an Emily Dickinson poem that came to mind.
    Strange, I know. 
    Not the one about hope being the thing with feathers. Honestly, I felt no hope. "Trump won," I told my wife, before she fled the room, unable to watch the fiasco.
     I believed that. And yet when it was finally over, I felt ... oddly light. And not just because I no longer had to witness two elderly men flailing at one another, nor the current president gazing at the floor, as if in shame, letting the hateful maunderings of Cheetolini go unanswered. 
     There was a line I was looking for.
     "After great pain, a formal feeling comes—" begin Poem #341 — Dickinson gave titles to only a very few of her poems, written mostly for herself, folded into little bundles and wrapped in thread. The poem continues:

      The Nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs—
      The stiff Heart questions was it He, that bore,
      And Yesterday, or Centuries before?

     Not that I would describe what seeing Biden's awful show of age and infirmity as "great pain." That's overly-dramatic. Shock, and horror. How could it be a surprise? The Republicans have been saying as much for months. Who could imagine they'd be right? That something they said wasn't a lie. What else have been they saying that is true? Is Trump really a super-genius? He certainly shone, by comparison, at least in speaking ability. The toxic lies and hate, not so much. Then again, I turned the sound off for a while, unable to hear more.

          The Feet, mechanical go round—
          Of Ground, or Air, or Ought—
          A Wooden way
          Regardless grown,
          A Quartz contentment, like a stone—

     I was surprised how peaceful I felt. Not light-hearted, not happy. But not dismal and doomstruck either. A certain calm focus — "a formal feeling" is close — the kind of quiet clarity in an emergency situation, where you see what's unfolding in slow motion and know exactly what you have to do. "A Quartz contentment" almost nails it too.   
This is the Hour of Lead—
Remembered, if outlived,
As Freezing persons, recollect the Snow—
First—Chill—then Stupor—then the letting go—
   Does that explain the serenity?  The drown reflex? The way peace supposedly settles on those who stop thrashing and sink to the bottom? Or a person freezing to death? Had Biden thrown away his worsening chance between 8 p.m. and 8:03 p.m. CST, and now all that's left is the mechanical go round, as Trump lurches toward his return to the White House, and the nation slides into extremism and repression? Have the marshals of doom seized the nation, one at each elbow, to escort us to our richly earned punishment? Was the fate sealed in 180 seconds of live television, the dice thrown, the ball settling into the roulette wheel cup and croupier chance sniggers and scrapes our life's savings off the table?
    Maybe. But you know what? I don't care. Because I don't plan to surrender. Not until the last second of the clock plays out and then after the game ends. Once the shock wears off. I plan to oppose Trump with every fiber of my being, and if that means backing a decent man who had a bad night, so be it. Biden seemed to recover himself Friday, and gave a good speech in North Carolina. Counter-intuitive things happen. Maybe Biden's near political death experience will  mobilize support in a way it never would before, that for each person who doesn't vote because his face was slack and confused, two more will head to the polls because the alternative is still so much worse. You could put Joe Biden in a wood chipper and what spewed out the other side wouldn't be pretty, but it wouldn't be a liar, bully, fraud and traitor either.  If they dragged Joe Biden's corpse to campaign events and stood it up behind a podium and Kamala Harris worked his lips while giving a speech out of the corner of her mouth, a real life "Weekend at Bernie's," I'd still vote for Biden. He might be raspy, but he isn't Vladimir Putin's catspaw.
     A couple hours after the debate, my wife and I walked our dog through the lovely little downtown park in Northbrook. Another beautiful summer night. I wasn't angry or upset or scared. I felt focused. The Hour of Lead had already passed, and now I was responding to the crisis, in the zone. The tide of battle turned, for the moment. It sure looked like a rout. And some have already throw down their muskets and bolted for the trees. Yet others are still in the field, standing firm, ready to take what's coming. 
      When I'm low, I often turn to my hero, Samuel Johnson, the great English lexicographer. He was a man beset with problems — gouty, with faulty eyesight, hard of hearing, scrofulous, ugly, alcoholic, depressed. And yet possessed with an iron will. Facing his final illness, he said something worth remembering. "I will be conquered," Johnson vowed. "I will not capitulate." That sounds like a plan.


 

29 comments:

  1. I had not yet made any political contributions. Yesterday I did ... to Biden-Harris. They have my vote.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Scrofulous is a terrific and underused choice. My compliments. Did you ever publish your work on him? John Howell

    ReplyDelete
  3. quick correction? 'I will NOT be conquered?'

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, he means it in the sense of "I will have to be conquered" or "you will have to defeat me." "I will not be conquered. I will not capitulate" is merely repetitive. To start, "I will be conquered" is a challenge, meaning: You will have to defeat me because I won't surrender.

      Delete
    2. I get it now. sorry!!!

      Delete
  4. Thank you very much for this, Neil. It's greatly needed and appreciated. I will share it widely, especially that Samuel Johnson line.

    Thank you, Lynne for donating. I'm unemployed and can't write checks but hope those who can will. I've been meaning for some time to research which organizations are highly regarded as doing effective and strategic voter registration and get-out-the-vote work. This weekend I will do that, then decide whether I will write postcards, do phone banking, or canvass in Wisconsin, join a group and get on it. I'd like to hear recommendations from others of their plans too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My kid sister has done postcards in the Twin Cities, and has also done that for local candidates who support the LGBTQ community (her daughter is gay). She recommends it highly. But I don't want to work from home. I worked on the campaigns in 2008, 2012, and 2016, and if you're not with like-minded people, in an office, it's not much fun.

      Phone banking sucks...got tired of being called a Commie and a baby-killer and a ni**er-lover. Banging on doors is only for the young and the fit. My wife and I were canvass captains eight years ago...we sent OTHER folks out to bang on those doors. And on Election Night, we cried.

      Delete
    2. Check out Move On or Indivisible.

      Delete
    3. Thanks Lynn and Grizz. I was employed on several campaigns when I was young (presidential, gubernatorial, and a senate one) so know the drill and doubt much has changed in 30+ years. Not sure I have the stamina to do door-knocking anymore; know a little about Indivisible's postcard thing, and will look at MoveOn. I'll figure something out. And then lean on friends to do the same.

      Delete
  5. I agree.
    This debate generated more hype than the Ali-Fraiser fight. However, politics and policy are not determined by debate. And a debate isn't the WWE; winner-take-all.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In 1976 at the age of 18 I cast my first presidential ballot for the democrat candidate. I have voted for democrats my entire life all but once in 2000, believing we are the party of justice and decency. maybe I was naive maybe I was overly optimistic . Our candidate didn't always win but our country chugged along and my life has been good. I was proud to be an American and think we have a great nation that has accomplish many positive things throughout history.

    Somehow we got through the first trump presidency without devolving into chaos. I am not confident we would get through another. I honestly hope he becomes incapacitated somehow before the election. But instead it seems clear Biden is headed down that path at an accelerated pace.

    I implore all people of goodwill to demand he step down so that we might avoid the looming catastrophe on the horizon. I will vote democrat no matter the candidate. But couldn't we have a vibrant , capable option ? I fear too many will stay home or vote third party if he remains in place. Yes the republicans were right about Joe . Will his stubborn refusal to step down be met the same way my family accepted my uncle eating thanksgiving dinner without a shirt on? It was his house after all . He died before Christmas . Its only going to get worse going forward.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Project 2025 tells us exactly what TFG and MAGA Republicans have planned.

      Delete
  7. Thank you for this rousing nd inspiring declaration!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Replace Biden is to capitulate.

    Don’t do it, Democrats!

    John

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This lifelong Democrat and third-generation pinko agrees, totally. Mr. S has apparently gone from calling for Joe's resignation, immediately after watching the Great Debacle, to saying he'd vote for Joe's steenkeeng corpse before he voted for the Orange Ogre. Probably because he realizes, along with most other rational Democrats, that it's too late to change drivers at this point in the road trip.

      It's gonna be Joe vs. the Orange Guy. Or throw your vote away (again) on some nobody (which is really a vote for Orangy Boy). Or sit on the couch...which means you automatically forfeit your right to bitch about the outcome of this life-and death contest.

      Okay, so the car hit a pothole the other night. So what? Big f'king deal. Shit happens. I'm not jumping out of Joe's convertible because of one big bump in the road. I'm still in it for the long haul. Still ridin' with Biden...and that will only end if they take away his keys. Been in the passenger seat since 2014. If he hadn't lost his son, he'd be finishing his second term right now, and we wouldn't be up to our eyeballs in orange poo. Me love you long time, Joe!

      Delete
  9. How the greatest country in the world gets stuck with these 2 guys as our only real choices for president is unbelievable. Imagine what the next 4 years could be like with a young, talented, energetic, intelligent, goal oriented candidate. Despite the divisions I believe the right person could begin a fresh path forward that all sides could rally behind.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Yes, a similar reaction in our household. But also the same bounce back. What a shame that the NY Times (and other media) gave in to panic. They want the honest stumbler to leave the race, not the pathological lying wannabe dictator.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the NYT and others want the wannabe to be defeated. Joe does not inspire the young. trump will likely match his vote total from 2020. Joe will fall far short of repeating or surpassing his . a recipe for disaster.

      Delete
  11. I think Biden was over prepped with facts and he was met with a fire hose of lies

    The press and the media have played a role in putting us where we are now. This shouldn’t even be a contest at this point. Yes his base will be with him no matter what but they can’t carry the election. Trump has been criticized rightly for his remark at Charlottesville—good people on both sides. That is what the press and media have been trying to do. Treat the two men as equals. They have influence just as polls do.

    I think everyone needs to calm down. Yes it was bad. So we move on, having learned a lesson. Biden has suffered many tragedies and disappointments in his life. He always soldiers on and he will this time too

    I would vote for a corpse before I would vote for Trump. Trump is a liar, a rapist, and a convicted felon, showing signs of dementia. Biden is only old,and he has been called the most consequential president in more that 50 years

    ReplyDelete
  12. Most elections are contested in the middle, luring the fence sitters to one side or the other. Thursday night, millions of undecideds and uneducated saw an obviously feeble Joe Biden, and a pathological liar on their televisions. Whether he was ill or just sundowning, Biden's deficiencies were clearly evident. But the casual viewers might not have realized the extent of Herr Drumpfs mendacity. Biden recovering on the afternoon news could not unring the bell that tolled so ominously on Thursday night. Joe Biden probably lost a good chunk of votes, hopefully they will just stay away in November and not pull for The Cowardly Liar. Otherwise, the Dems need to recruit new voters in numbers similar to 2020, at least in the swing states. I am not convinced it can be done, unless the other side commits an equivalent gaffe. Either way, I'm with Neil and Samuel Johnson. At the very least, We can try to educate the young about the freedoms won in our youth and why they should fight the erosion under Drumpf and his merry band of assholes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. The base picks the candidate, the independent, center right, center left people decide who wins the election. Biden was already losing support from multiple demographics. We’ll see when the polls come out in a few days how bad the damage is.

      I think Obama and Bill Clinton need to sit down with Joe and convince him to step aside and choose another candidate to give his delegates to. I don’t think it’s Harris. Amy Klobuchar and Gretchen Whitmer would have a better chance of beating Trump than Biden. They would be able to bring in the youth and independent/undecided vote, which they need to win.

      Delete
  13. While I appreciate the defiance and positive outlook expressed in this post, I'm afraid I find the situation too depressing to contemplate much.

    I couldn't bring myself to watch the debate -- I've been disconcerted enough seeing Biden's performance in a couple of much less taxing settings. But I'm quite disturbed to hear and read the reports that have followed.

    Speaking last night with folks who did watch, I found out that they are desperate for a third way and have all but "bolted for the trees" with regard to the president. FME asks "couldn't we have a vibrant, capable option?" I wonder how many have shifted completely to that way of thinking now. We HAD vibrant, capable options in 2020. None seemed to have what it took to do better than Biden. Could one of them have won, as he did, and perhaps be better positioned for reelection now? We'll never know. Is Pritzker or Whitmer or Newsom the answer right now? I wish I knew, but I just don't see how such a change would take place, or that it would necessarily be beneficial.

    Granted, Biden often seems less than "vibrant." But he has been and remains (at this point, anyway) capable. His day-to-day performance is more important to me than his ability to joust with a lying, criminal carnival barker on live TV. He's done a very good job and has an effective administration. So, I haven't "thrown down my musket," and gave an impassioned plea to my friends that going for an independent candidate is just not an option, given the sad history of how independents managed to torpedo the Democratic candidate in 2000, 2016 and other years.

    I'm mildly encouraged to recall that Obama underperformed surprisingly in his first debate against Romney, and there was a lot of doom and gloom about it for a while. That worked out all right. Still, I'm not exactly sure that I'm "ready to take what's coming" this time.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Please Wikipedia "Gish gallop"

    ReplyDelete
  15. This will be a wild ride. I have no idea how it's going to go. Except that the political parties are changing. To what, who knows. Both of them have failed their job - to select viable candidates. In 2016, Trump was the most divisive candidate ever who ran against one of the most disliked (unwarranted or not).
    Any average Democratic candidate would have beat him in 2020. Thank God Biden flipped Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania (with bonus of Georgia and Arizona).
    Thanks for sharing Johnson's plan.

    ReplyDelete
  16. We will not be conquered. Not by Fascists. Not by theocrats. Not by a lying sack of orange

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you -- this both made me feel better and energized. Once again I will write postcards and send letters urging people to vote.

    ReplyDelete
  18. "Dig in boys for an extended stay..." - Billy Bragg (first lines in "Everywhere")

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.