It's been a while since I thought a New Yorker cartoon was funny.
In fact, I can't remember when that last happened.
I almost said, "It's been a while since a New Yorker cartoon was funny." But I have that superpower of stepping out of my own perceptions and realizing that I'm not the only person in the world. They still print them, after all. Young people might find them hysterical. They probably do. I sure hope so. Me, I just find them strange.
Once, New Yorker cartoons were great fun. I just pulled seven large format New Yorker cartoon collections off my shelf, looking for a certain cartoon I mentioned in the comments Thursday in my cri de coeur about the New York Times muffing its coverage of our gathering national disaster.
Flipping through the pages, I was immediately reminded just how fleeting humor can be. Lots of bosses chasing secretaries around desks. Not so funny anymore. All the Black people were jungle tribesmen or servants. Not so funny anymore. A reminder that we communicators have got to change with the times. I try to keep my frame of reference current, but sometimes it feels like I'm always rushing to keep up with some change I don't care for in the first place. Sometimes I envy those guys who just fold their arms and stop adapting. Staying on top of things is exhausting. There are so many ways to screw this up. But I have a professional interest not to let myself be stuck in the 1990s.
A couple rarities. "The Seventh New Yorker Cartoon Album" was published in 1935, 10 years after the magazine was founded. I can't find any information about it online, but my hunch is it's the first album and the "Seventh" is a joke, or an attempt at one anyway. Not to disparage that brand of chuckle — senior year of college, the humor magazine published its 50th anniversary issue, crafting a half century of clips to highlight, even though it wasn't four years old. We thought it a bravura performance at the time and maybe it was.
And "The Stag at Eve," a thin, softcover 1931 volume of mildly risque cartoons, mostly prurient, a few vaguely anti-Semitic, by top New Yorker artists, including several by William Steig. "Trouble with you, Baby, is you need awakening," says a pint-sized Steig lothario, leering at a female pal with a big ribbon in her hair as he arches toward her on a sofa.
My guess is an attempt to monetize cartoons that couldn't make it into the magazine — something New Yorker artists also did that in more recent years — see 2006's "The Rejection Collection: Cartoons You Never Saw, and Never Will See, in The New Yorker."
A couple rarities. "The Seventh New Yorker Cartoon Album" was published in 1935, 10 years after the magazine was founded. I can't find any information about it online, but my hunch is it's the first album and the "Seventh" is a joke, or an attempt at one anyway. Not to disparage that brand of chuckle — senior year of college, the humor magazine published its 50th anniversary issue, crafting a half century of clips to highlight, even though it wasn't four years old. We thought it a bravura performance at the time and maybe it was.
And "The Stag at Eve," a thin, softcover 1931 volume of mildly risque cartoons, mostly prurient, a few vaguely anti-Semitic, by top New Yorker artists, including several by William Steig. "Trouble with you, Baby, is you need awakening," says a pint-sized Steig lothario, leering at a female pal with a big ribbon in her hair as he arches toward her on a sofa.
My guess is an attempt to monetize cartoons that couldn't make it into the magazine — something New Yorker artists also did that in more recent years — see 2006's "The Rejection Collection: Cartoons You Never Saw, and Never Will See, in The New Yorker."
The title, "The Stag at Eve," is worth noting, a reference to the male deer that often pops up in the background of paintings of Adam and Eve, a reminder of the introduction of sin into paradise and the, umm, need for redemption through Christ. A sly reference to the off-color jokes within).
Oh, the cartoon. I was trying to capture the strange way the East Coast media is clinging to the rituals of a normal presidential election, even while covering the campaign of a liar, bully, fraud and traitor who very clearly will tear apart American democracy and impose a dictatorship if given the chance. And I thought of this cartoon. Odd, in my memory, the view of the boat was closer up, and I could see it in the style of Edwin Booth, a New Yorker cartoonist known for his daft, complicated eccentrics. But it wasn't.
It was drawn by Bruce Petty, and ran Nov. 28, 1959.
I did not learn that flipping through my stack of cartoon collections, of course, as pleasant an interlude as that was in the pre-dawn dimness of my office. But in three seconds searching online. The reality, once I finally tracked it down, wasn't as impressive as it had been in memory. That happens a lot.
Oh, the cartoon. I was trying to capture the strange way the East Coast media is clinging to the rituals of a normal presidential election, even while covering the campaign of a liar, bully, fraud and traitor who very clearly will tear apart American democracy and impose a dictatorship if given the chance. And I thought of this cartoon. Odd, in my memory, the view of the boat was closer up, and I could see it in the style of Edwin Booth, a New Yorker cartoonist known for his daft, complicated eccentrics. But it wasn't.
It was drawn by Bruce Petty, and ran Nov. 28, 1959.
I did not learn that flipping through my stack of cartoon collections, of course, as pleasant an interlude as that was in the pre-dawn dimness of my office. But in three seconds searching online. The reality, once I finally tracked it down, wasn't as impressive as it had been in memory. That happens a lot.
The Trib carries "Bliss" in its comic section, Monday through Saturday.
ReplyDeleteIn addition to this strip, Harry Bliss is a cartoonist for the New Yorker. I enjoy his work very much. More of it can be found here: https://store.harrybliss.com/. I hope you enjoy it, too.
I have a 2019 New Yorker cartoon framed in my office. It is a group of people standing by an elevator with the caption “A few of us are going out after work to pretend it’s not the end of the world, if you want to join us.” I loved that one in a “it’s funny because it’s true” sort of way. It was not only not dated, it was prescient.
ReplyDeleteI have never been able to enjoy comics, cartoons, or much of any type of comedy?
ReplyDeleteI try one of my best friends and my most recent wife Love the funnies, the New Yorker cartoons I just don't get it. Maybe it's the 20 years I spent addicted to cocaine
My favorite New Yorker cartoon was by Helen Hokinson: Two elderly ladies in evening gowns talking at a fancy dinner, and the one says to the other, "But why don't you become a Democrat and ENJOY politics?"
ReplyDeleteI don’t think many of their cartoons are funny, either, which made the Seinfeld episode mocking them so (ironically) funny. But for me there’s a terrific exception, Bob Mankoff’s famous one showing the business executive on the phone, looking at his desk calendar, and saying “No, Thursday’s out. How about never— is never good for you?” I loved this one, as my wife knew, and to surprise me for my birthday found a copy on line signed by Mankoff. It never arrived . She finally had to tell me. After much research I couldn’t find it on line or elsewhere, either. But now I really wanted it — what to do? So I called Mankoff himself, and he couldn’t be nicer. He gladly signed and sent a copy to me. I framed it and it’s on a wall in my office - - not far from my desk calendar. Mankoff’s memoir, interesting and funny, uses the same caption as its title.
ReplyDeleteI subscribe to the New Yorker for the articles. Maybe one in five of the cartoons lands with me.
ReplyDeleteSome New Yorker cartoons resonate with me, and some do not. Their cartoons do not illustrate jokes...they ARE the jokes. There was one about 40 years ago in which a guy in an armchair, surrounded by towering stacks of newspapers (the New York Times, natch) was saying to his wife: "But isn't it nice to know it's all there?" I was that guy for many years I actually have friends like that couple. Their house is a horror story.
ReplyDeleteAnother one showed a guy at a table that's covered with newspapers and magazines. He was clipping out articles and putting them into piles. He was a "Freelance Trendspotter." That was me. Would have been my dream job, especially if the spotted trends could be written about in a newspaper column. Maybe even a daily one. But then I wouldn't be a freelancer anymore, would I?
Have a few New Yorker cartoon collections. "The New Yorker Book of Cat Cartoons" (1990). "The Big New Yorker Book of Cats" (2013). Stories, poems, cartoons, and covers. It's a gem. A kitty lover's delight. My prize acquisition was "The New Yorker War Album," published in 1942. It was the very first "themed" album of the magazine’s cartoons. Peter Arno’s cover, from the issue of February 28, 1942, was selected as the album's cover.
Amazon was selling an original copy in 2016 for about a hundred bucks, so it's probably not such a rare find.. My friends, knowing what a WWII junkie I am, gifted me on my birthday. Three weeks later...9/11. Gotta wonder if there's a "New Yorker War on Terror Album." Highly unlikely. September 11, and the days and months and years that followed, have never really had much of a humorous side.
Heard someone reference the cartoon tagline just the other day and I looked it up because it struck a chord.
ReplyDeleteI used to frequent Daryl Cagle's cartoon website as newspaper cartoonists were being jettisoned, but do not since he hides the identity of a single cartoonist -- aka Rivers, a "witty conservative cartoonist". No other artist gets such a pass on his website, not even the foreign artists whose cartoons could endanger their livelihood or lives. Even with Rivers' announced retirement from the website has failed to reveal his identity.