![]() |
Photo by Ashlee Rezin |
My father built a chalkboard for us kids. Which I would have forgotten long ago, but for one moment: Nov. 5, 1968, when the presidential race results coming in on our Zenith black and white television clashed with our bedtime.
My sister wrote: "Who won the election?" on the chalkboard and then put Richard Nixon's and Hubert Humphrey's name below them, and a box beside each name.
The idea was, my parents, up late, would learn the outcome and make an X in the proper box and we, waking up early, we would see it and be immediately informed of the news.
A child's eagerness: tell me now. How does the story end?
Be careful what you wish for.
Nixon won in 1968. And Donald Trump was re-elected Tuesday.
The stakes could not have been higher — the former and future president's politics of bigotry, grievance and vengeance, shredding democratic norms in a toxic dreamworld of his own fabrication, or Kamala Harris adhering to big tent Democratic aspirations and respecting the time-honored habits of democracy.
The coin has been flipped. And it has come up Trump. Now the question is: what kind of country are we going to be? That's easy. We already have our answer. We will be Trump's country. Again.
The stakes could not have been higher — the former and future president's politics of bigotry, grievance and vengeance, shredding democratic norms in a toxic dreamworld of his own fabrication, or Kamala Harris adhering to big tent Democratic aspirations and respecting the time-honored habits of democracy.
The coin has been flipped. And it has come up Trump. Now the question is: what kind of country are we going to be? That's easy. We already have our answer. We will be Trump's country. Again.
What does that mean? Will he start the deportions on Day One? He said he would. He also said he'd build a wall and Mexico would pay for it. He says a lot of things. This might seem a strange moment for optimism — the last coin in your pocket when all your other money is gone. But what else is there? Despair? Embrace ruin? If we are ruined, then we were ruined already and this is the diagnosis, the undeniable lump on the CAT scan. If we are sick, then maybe we can get better Just not yet.
I would never be so glib as to say it doesn't matter. Though it might be comforting — or terrifying — to look around and ask instead: what kind of country are we now? A country that would re-elect Donald Trump, obviously. That chooses a 34-time twice-impeached felon over a prosecutor who is also a woman of color.
I would never be so glib as to say it doesn't matter. Though it might be comforting — or terrifying — to look around and ask instead: what kind of country are we now? A country that would re-elect Donald Trump, obviously. That chooses a 34-time twice-impeached felon over a prosecutor who is also a woman of color.
"Better I should know," as Sarah McLachlan sings. We can feel anguish over where he will take us. Or that he will be starting from right here, with all the conflict and animosity raging today. We did get through four years of Trump before with our basic country intact, though I hesitate to imagine what another four years will do.
I know of an organization that teaches you must reach rock bottom before things get better. I had hoped that the first Trump administration was the nadir. Obviously not. The bottom is still ahead of us. Oh goody. There are hells below this one, and the United States just bought a ticket there.
Here's a reassuring thought: we aren't going anywhere we haven't already been. This is a struggle that did not begin with Trump —as I've said for years, he is not a cause but a symptom — and will not end now. I remember, in 2016, looking at the election map, seeing the divide between the blue in the north and the red in the south and thinking: "It's the Mason-Dixon line. We're still fighting the Civil War."
Think about it. The institution of slavery was the central cause of that conflict. To be able to treat people as slaves you had to deny their humanity, and consider them chattel, property you can buy or sell.
Look at the top Republicans issues — immigration, reproductive choice, trans rights. They're still busy identifying classes of people whose dignity and integrity can be snatched away.
Here's a reassuring thought: we aren't going anywhere we haven't already been. This is a struggle that did not begin with Trump —as I've said for years, he is not a cause but a symptom — and will not end now. I remember, in 2016, looking at the election map, seeing the divide between the blue in the north and the red in the south and thinking: "It's the Mason-Dixon line. We're still fighting the Civil War."
Think about it. The institution of slavery was the central cause of that conflict. To be able to treat people as slaves you had to deny their humanity, and consider them chattel, property you can buy or sell.
Look at the top Republicans issues — immigration, reproductive choice, trans rights. They're still busy identifying classes of people whose dignity and integrity can be snatched away.
We survived four years of a Civil War — our bloodiest war ever.
‘This horror, this nightmare abomination!" Harriet Beecher Stowe wrote of slavery in 1852. "Can it be in my own country!” Words that have taken on unexpected currency. We survived that. We'll survive this. Somehow. Maybe. Maybe we didn't survive. Maybe we're already dead, and just don't know it. Or rather we do. Now. Some of us do. We're finding out.
The United States has been at an impasse for eight years. Neither four years of a Trump presidency, from 2017 to 2021, ending in the insurrection at the Capitol Jan. 6, nor four years of the Joe Biden's administration that followed, has tilted the playing field in one direction or the other. The election wasn't even close. It looks like Trump will sweep all seven battleground states.Myself, I feel a certain calm. Say what you will about Donald Trump, for a congenital liar, he can be very frank, especially over the past few weeks. Very direct about who he is and what he stands for. You can't say anyone was deceived who didn't want to be deceived.
Maybe "calm" is the wrong word. When my wife asked me this morning how I was, I answered, "Numb." The implications will take a while to sink in. For now, I'm holding onto the numbness. It feels ... like nothing. Which given the circumstances, I appreciate.
Kamala Harris — like Biden, originally an unexceptional party hack — rose to the occasion. She did. I find myself indulging in sports metaphor: she left it all on the field. Since her boss flamed out on national television in June — had Biden stepped aside when he should have, maybe this nightmare might have been avoided — she ramped up quickly and campaigned forcefully. It just wasn't quickly or forcefully enough.
The choice was clear. And stark. Half the country wants a liar, bully, fraud and traitor. On the bright side, he stopped talking about the election being rigged.
The choice was clear. And stark. Half the country wants a liar, bully, fraud and traitor. On the bright side, he stopped talking about the election being rigged.
On Monday, my mother called.
"Are you moving to Canada if Trump wins?" she asked. "Because we'll go with you."
"No mom, I'm staying right here," I replied. "It's still my country."
Flight is a pipe dream. Would-be strongmen are on the rise the world over; Canada has its own proto-Trump waiting in the wings, Pierre Poilievre. You can't run from trouble. It finds you.
Besides, people seldom leave. The closest I actually encountered was a former state rep who told me that she and her husband had bought a condo in Portugal to sit out Trump 2.0. I made a face.
"I plan to be on the last train out," I said. "Not the first."
Cowardice knows no party. How much can you love America if you turn tail and run when the going gets rough?
"Are you moving to Canada if Trump wins?" she asked. "Because we'll go with you."
"No mom, I'm staying right here," I replied. "It's still my country."
Flight is a pipe dream. Would-be strongmen are on the rise the world over; Canada has its own proto-Trump waiting in the wings, Pierre Poilievre. You can't run from trouble. It finds you.
Besides, people seldom leave. The closest I actually encountered was a former state rep who told me that she and her husband had bought a condo in Portugal to sit out Trump 2.0. I made a face.
"I plan to be on the last train out," I said. "Not the first."
Cowardice knows no party. How much can you love America if you turn tail and run when the going gets rough?
The biopsy results are in: The cancer is back...and this time, it's probably terminal.
ReplyDeleteThe unimaginable is now our reality. As in total control of House, Senate, White House, Supreme Court, many lower courts, and soon to be, essential government agencies. As in a cold, dark winter lasting four years and beyond. What to do? Oppose how exactly?Beyond (fiercely) loving family and friends, I await strategies going forward. Color me despondent.
ReplyDeleteI'm sad to say I don't love America so much right now.
ReplyDeleteHe's going to put that crackpot lunatic RFK Jr in charge of all health policy. The death rate will skyrocket now & if there's a new pandemic, we're doomed.
ReplyDeleteActually we're doomed anyway! with a demented & deranged morn & traitor in charge.
At least until Vance uses the 25th Amendment to get rid of him, because he is demented & deranged!
We are now Germany 1933!
Then the doom will be even worse!
I tend to think that Trump has been stringing RFK Jr along, and that he’ll cut him loose now that he doesn’t need him for anything. But then, I’ve been wrong before.
DeleteCoey
Unbelievable!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the calm and determined view of this, Neil. It has shades of hope in it, makes me feel a little better. A little.
ReplyDeleteI have lost all hope
ReplyDeleteAgreed, I just can't believe that over half of all voters are this goddam stupid!
DeleteEvery time I find myself caught in naivety its because I over-estimated the good in people. And here I am, again. I am aghast that my fellow citizens chose to exercise their vote in (what I consider to be) the greatest democracy in the world, for this. I am appalled at whom we chose to speak for us, and to represent us internationally. And I am depressed to think of the damage yet to be done by the likes of Elon Musk, Steve Bannon, RFK, Jr, Stephen Miller, etc. I clearly didn't want to believe that this is who we are.
ReplyDeleteCan you really love America? Even without Trump and those who put him where he is, our country has a very disturbing history.
ReplyDeleteYes we've done some wonderful things that have benefited all the world but we also have the blood on our hands in the way we've treated anyone who isn't white.
This may be the best place for me to live but love this counrtry? No.
I really liked everything you wrote but was puzzled by your last line.
I think it means what it says. I will always love America, for the promise it represents. We might have tolerated slavery, but we invented liberty. France was a monarchy when the American Revolution broke out. We forget how imbedded sexism is: we gave slaves the right to vote 55 years before we extended it to women. And now we're pulling those rights back. For now. Hope might be the last coin in your pocket when all your money is spent, but I'm holding onto it.
DeleteWe legally gave the former slaves the right to vote, but the former slave states denied them that right until the late 1960s!
DeleteYour comments are appreciated this morning, Neil! Yes, racism, sexixm, xenophobia, etc. silently and shamefully reared their ugly heads and won out! Working as an Election Judge yesterday I saw it in the eyes of the older men who stated that they came to vote for only one office, but hoped they would be cancelled out by the hopeful young women who also came to vote. We must regroup and continue to stand up for rights and responsibilities. It feels like we are regressing to the 1950s, at least as far as this majority is concerned. Courage to stand up for ourselves and others continues to be necessary to maintain our democracy!
ReplyDeleteI don’t think we can put all the blame for this debacle on racist old white men. It was a virtual tie between voters over 65. That should have put Harris over the top. Historically, older Americans help the Republicans.
DeleteThe data shows that young men handed Trump the victory. It’s shocking, I don’t understand it. The only thing I can think of is that getting shot and convicted turned Trump into some kind of folk hero in the eyes of many young males. America has always glamorized outlaws. Now we got one for President.
Not regressing to the 1950s, but the 1850s!
DeleteI will be in that last train with you.
ReplyDeleteI am appalled and crushed by the election results. Sadly, I am not particularly shocked. Apparently, that really is who we are, at least enough of us. Racism, misogyny, xenophobia, hatred, love of authoritarianism and patriarchy .. these are the attributes we seek in a leader. All things come to an end and so it is for the American Experiment. The country will survive but in a form unrecognizable to the Founders and the best of us. We chose a raging lunatic over an exquisitely competent women. So be it. I am glad to be old.
ReplyDeleteAs a poor, former working class, female senior citizen I have just been kicked from a 2nd class citizen to 3rd class. Give it a year & my citizenship will be downgraded further.
Delete"There are hells below this one, and the United States just bought a ticket there." Well said, Neil. A thoughtful column today, when we need thoughtfulness most.
ReplyDeleteYes, the numb nuts thank you for your sobering comments and voice of wisdom and clarity when we need it most. Thanks Neil.
ReplyDeleteI came to the realization late last night, that Vice President Harris never had a chance to win. As any educated person knows, the abused always blames themselves and despite what they said, many of the people who said they would vote opposite their spouses, never did so... "they would have known it was me if she won."
ReplyDeleteThree things worth noting. First, last night, somewhere between 11:00 and 12:00, when the conversation was entering the "where people get their news" Jonathan Capehart mention how when he went/goes on MSNBC he doesn't even look at Fox News ratings, because it is so far beyond the reach of any other organizations reach, he always compared it to how he did against CNN. I think that speaks volumes about what people are hearing. People hear YouTube, Fox News, and Joe Rogan. Whether they speak truth or lies, the masses take that information as gospel, and that's the way the country goes. Until democrats can learn how to talk like and talk to the 'merican people, nothing will change.
Second, Democrats constantly like to believe in the good. at the very least, half of this country is not "good." they are the deplorable. They are the trash. they are all that is wrong with humanity. They are also gullible, being conned, and below the average in every sense of the word: life span, education, health, finances, religion. George Carlin pointed it out his whole life. We laughed at its truth but ignored its ugliness. The left sees good, the right sees power. and their followers are too dumb to realize they won't see any of it.
And lastly, as a Jew, your penultimate line strikes both hope and fear into my heart. We have always thought we'd be able to catch the last trains out, and many times we were right... it just wasn't the train we thought it was.
How long before Trump, Musk, Vance, and Kennedy tell us, "this work will set you free."
Indeed
DeleteRepublican commoners cling to the belief they will be welcomed into the penthouse. Democrats commoners know they never will.
DeleteOnly one third of people are below average. One third are average and one third above average. Trump's popular vote victory means some segment of the average and likely some segment of the above average voted for him. His victory cannot be chalked up completely to the "stupidity" of the people who voted for him.
DeleteHell, all of the below average people didn't vote for him. Some of those people voted for Democrats and have been for generations. There's some other reason for his victory My theory is people got sick of listening to Democrats. Tell them how to behave. Will the Democrats aren't in charge anymore
After those of my two closest friends, yours was the voice I most wanted to hear this morning, Neil. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteI am 70 years old. I am tired of fighting. But I am not ready to buy the train ticket. I don't want to leave my friends and family. I am white and middle class, so if I keep my head down I should be safe. But I despair for my country and my fellow citizens who are not safe.
ReplyDeleteDuring Trump's first term I read The Plague by Albert Camus. It helped me cope. It's about a town in Algeria going through an epidemic, from the point of view of a doctor working there. A common interpretation is that it's a metaphor for the Nazi occupation of France, which Camus lived through. The basic message I took from it is that you just have to get up in the morning and do your work. However little it matters in the scheme of things. Resilience is just a habit, a routine.
ReplyDeleteI remind myself of a Bertrand Russell quote: "The world is a higgledy-piggledy place, containing things pleasant and things unpleasant in haphazard sequence." In other words, shit's going to happen sometimes.
I also take solace in that Chinese farmer parable. One thing leads to another and some of those will be bad leading to good and vice versa. We can't tell which ones will be which, all we can do is get up in the morning and do whatever it is we do.
Amen
DeleteFor almost 14 years I have volunteered at the local state penitentiary with a couple of different (non-religious) programs, dedicated to helping teach anti-violence skills and bringing as much hope and compassion as possible to a place which often determinedly tried to beat down / out any shred of either. This morning, after a long hot shower and much caffeine, I realized I'm just going to have to keep on doing the same thing here. What else is there?
ReplyDeleteThanks for your thoughtful and healing piece today. Gives one some perspective.
ReplyDeleteI’m just going to say thank you.
ReplyDeleteRacism, greed and ignorance, with a misogyny garnish, made a powerful cocktail, intoxicating the American voters yesterday. In 2016 Keith Olbermann listed 176 reasons disqualifying Drumpf. It wasn't enough. 8 years and one failed coup later the voters chose him again, despite behavior so egregious it wouldn't be tolerated in their own families, much less the Oval Office. Neil, the organization you mentioned teaches self help which seems useless in our current situation. The Founders gave us self government, at least by some of us, and through the years we inched closer to a true democracy. We almost made it. I'm not hearing any McLachlan today, just Chicago's "Lowdown". "Feelin' pretty bad.....country I was brought up in fell apart and died."
ReplyDeleteI look everyday to your insights -- and am glad of them. Here's mine, today, from John Lewis: "Do not get lost in a sea of despair. Be hopeful, be optimistic. Our struggle is not the struggle of a day, a week, a month, or a year, it is the struggle of a lifetime. Never, ever be afraid to make some noise and get in good trouble, necessary trouble."
ReplyDeleteHe sets a high bar - one I'm unlikely to meet -- but one to aim toward
I am bereft—sickened and saddened! I fear for my children and grandchildren.
ReplyDeleteMy son lives in the UK and posted the statements below on his Facebook page. I thought these were appropriate for what occurred yesterday:
In 1939 Germany they could say afterwards that they didn’t know.
In 2024 America, afterwards all they can say is “we didn’t care”.
He also posted this:
The irony that the US election day is also bonfire night in the UK isn’t lost on me.
“Remember, remember, the 5th of November,
Gunpowder, treason and plot.
I see no reason
Why gunpowder treason
Should ever be forgot.”
The problem is that you never know which train will be the last.
ReplyDeleteSo much for my seemingly carefree attitude about perseverance, recovery and Stoic personal philosophy.
ReplyDeleteGuess I just have to double down and actually live that life.
I mean, I felt I was, but now the shit's really real.
And what makes us think there will be another election in 4 years or even 2. I wouldn’t bet on it
ReplyDeleteIn the 1980's, when I lived in a German city in Bavaria, I would look at older people walking in the city center and imagine which of them, a few decades earlier, had participated in the Nazi's violent persecution of vulnerable minorities in their midst. Today, walking around the American city I live in now, I wondered which 50% of the people in my view voted to throw our democracy away for a sinister, fascist thug. The horror was familiar.
ReplyDeleteHow much of the government does Elon Musk already own through government contracts? (It's a hell of a lot!) And Trump is going to appoint him to be in charge of those departments and more?
ReplyDeleteEgypt and Rome: 500 years.
ReplyDeleteEngland, Russia, Spain: 400 years.
France: 300 years.
Untied Snakes: 250 years.
Persia: 220 years.
Russia: 70 years.
Japan: 50 years.
Germany: 12 years.
So we were smack dab in the middle.
Not a bad run, as empires go.
But all empires eventually end.
It was fun while it lasted.
China's turn now.
Reading this late, procrastinated my email this morning for some reason. Avoiding depression, I suppose. Finally came out of the darkness to read, and this is exactly what I needed. Get past the numbness and fuck yeah - it’s put up or shut up time. Don’t give in and let him live in your head, he’s actually good at that - like a tumor. So let’s live our lives and continue to advocate in whatever little way we can.
ReplyDeleteJust remember from history where that last train may be going
ReplyDeleteNumb is the accurate word. After crying for a month in 2016, I woke up thinking, oy and yuck, but no tears. This was the long game played out before our eyes. (How much champagne and caviar did Putin enjoy yesterday) Will America's funeral be televised?
ReplyDeleteIt feels really over this time. Lots of people are going to get hurt and it's going to be horrific to witness.
Neil, thank you for sticking your neck out for us every day. It's been mighty helpful. Please stay safe.
I think the bottom line is in our 2-party system there is little room for the middle. I yearned for another choice. Kamala was capable but could not attract passion. We were left with a sad choice between 2 candidates, Trump won more of the independents. The Democrats moved too far left and Republicans too far right. Spend, spend, spend…something free for everyone to garner their vote.
ReplyDelete