Photo by Jessica Koscielniak |
As a rule, you're not supposed to draw attention to what isn't in the newspaper. The idea is, you've got everything right here, in your hands. All the news you need to know today, plus a horoscope, comics and tomorrow's weather. Anything that isn't here doesn't matter.
But the key rule about newspapers is: There is no rule that can't be scrapped as circumstances dictate. Sometimes the stylebook gets set aside. Sometimes the loss is too big to ignore. When iconic movie reviewer Roger Ebert died in 2013, we didn't go back to running reviews that were bare synopses under jokey pseudonyms like Mae Tinee.
We honored the man, recognized the loss, then moved forward, as best we could. The 35 staffers — including 23 in the Sun-Times newsroom — who took the Chicago Public Media buyout and are mostly leaving Friday are too important for the paper to cough into its fist and hope you don't notice. First, because they made a sacrifice, saving $4.2 million a year in costs to help the newspaper survive. That's news, and our job is to report the news. Second, you will notice. Their loss will be felt.
I'm feeling it now. For me, it's personal, starting with John O'Neill, who has been the primary editor on this column. He's saved me from a thousand gaffes and probably a few career-ending misfires. He's my friend, as is his wife, Suzanne McBride, who often edits this on Sundays. I've been to their house, and they to mine. They were at my younger son's wedding, and I know their children, Jack and Grace.
Richard Roeper is the biggest name to go. He is a star in his own right, holding his own with Ebert after he replaced Gene Siskel on his TV show in 2000. The author of seven books, Richard is a fearsome poker player and — what mattered to me most — a really good writer. We were good friends in our salad days — he was at my wedding — before I disappeared into marriage and parenthood, two snares that Richard neatly sidestepped.
I will miss another friend in Rick Telander, who was the king at Sports Illustrated when the paper snagged him. He played football for Northwestern, and when he was drafted by Kansas City, Rick and a buddy drove straight north until they hit Lake Superior, where he bought 30 acres of land. Eight autumns have been highlighted with visits to his compound, to breathe the crisp air, smoke cigars, eat big steaks and plunge from the sauna into the gelid cold lake. He let me hang around even though I sometimes admit that I don't follow sports. While he played one-on-one with Michael Jordan, I once almost asked Jordan his name, because to me he was just another player in the Bulls locker room. Yet somehow Rick and I got along.
Rick Morrissey is another vital sports columnist who is going, plus Bears beat writer Mark Potash and White Sox writer Daryl Van Schouwen. When I heard Annie Costabile is leaving too, I went looking for a text she sent me years ago. I had written something rounding up Chicago sports, and at the last minute cut out the Sky, for space — "how could I?" she demanded. She cared deeply about what she did — a defining characteristic of people who work at the Sun-Times, and was sincerely indignant, as befits someone who changed the way Chicagoans view the WNBA and women's sports.
We lost most of our editorial board, and the future of editorials at the paper is uncertain. Lorraine Forte headed the board, running a staff not half as large as what was required to do the same job at the Tribune. Tom Frisbie left —soft-spoken, he edited my work when I joined the Sun-Times school guide as a freelancer in 1984, his quiet calm a counterpoint to my frantic, gerbil-on-a-wheel ambition. Back when we did endorsements, every trustee from every small town from Addison to Zion traipsed through the editorial board room, a process that was saved from devolving into pure confusion by the organizational skill and good cheer of Marlen Garcia.
Our features department was mostly Miriam Di Nunzio and Darel Jevens, who edited Roeper and whose clever headlines for Dear Abby have been seen by millions of readers. With them leaving (although we are grateful Di Nunzio has agreed to stick around for a few months), I don't know who's going to try to step into their shoes, but I'm sure glad it won't be me. They did yeoman's work.
Every election night about 5 p.m. the staff would gather in the newsroom to hammer out a game plan. We were looking at a long seven hours hours of pinballing around the city until drinks at the Billy Goat, and we all took our marching orders from Scott Fornek, decked out in the election night sweater vest he wore for luck. He had joined the Sun-Times when the Chicago Daily News folded in 1978, and carried that special cachet that Daily News alumni enjoyed, having worked at the same paper as Carl Sandburg and Ben Hecht.
To continue reading, click here.
There was a time when Ideals and honor were paramount in this country. No more. Ironically the Sun Times and the destroyer of those ideals intersect on a piece of real estate. Thank you for a beautiful column that celebrates the ideals at risk.
ReplyDeleteWhat a beautiful column, Neil. And a great tribute to your colleagues, both former and current. A fitting and touching valedictory.
ReplyDeleteDevastating. Heartbreaking. In a sane world, journalism together with other arts and things like education and healthcare would be recognized as crucial, integral components of a thriving society and would be supported by taxes. But ours is not a thriving society and our world is not sane.
ReplyDeleteSo far, at least we haven't lost Lynn Sweet.
ReplyDeleteNeil, I am very sorry for the loss of your friends and colleagues.
ReplyDeleteI am sorry for us readers, who will lose them too.
I wish we lived in a world where the true artists and opinions were rewarded as they are deserved and not by the songs of the coin box.
I will try my best to help make the change good and keep the world on the right path, small as my efforts may be.
Lovely column.
ReplyDeleteI still miss Robert Feder, Dave Hoekstra and Mark Brown.
ReplyDeleteditto
Deletedouble ditto
DeleteThe Suntimes has been part of my life since the 1959 white Sox now age 75 I wish to keep it that way
ReplyDeleteYour next tome might be, “How I Saved a Newspaper.”
ReplyDelete(“How I Saved the News Business” would be more accurate, if audacious.)
All of your colleagues will be greatly missed.
~ (Other) Jeffrey S.
I'm a sports fan though not as much as I once was. When I was a kid we rooted for the players times changed and eventually we rooted for the laundry.
ReplyDeleteI read the Sun times I always have once upon a Time the Daily News as well worked on a paper truck for a couple years during high School and at a news stand.
Over the years people have come and gone from the Sun times but I guess I am still a fan of the letterhead.
About 10 or 12 years ago I discovered your work in a copy of Granta where they disclosed that you were a newspaper columnist in my hometown. I was still buying the paper at that point or reading one on the lunchroom table that had been left behind, especially on Sunday. Loved the Sunday paper. Haven't bought a paper in a long time.
It's certainly not the fault of any of the people that work or worked at the Sun times that newspapers aren't as popular as they once were. It's the readers, we've abandoned you. People just don't read the newspaper in a physical form or online.
On the days that your column appears in the paper and I have to click here to read the rest of the story there are headlines below your column that rarely interests me. I'm not sure why this has happened but I just don't have the interest and young people seemingly wouldn't be caught dead on the train reading the paper they're all looking at their phone and they're not generally reading the news.
I recommended your work to my kids and to their friends just read Neil Steinberg I tell them he does great work I send them a link occasionally and it never results in a conversation about what you recently wrote. The times they have changed and not for the better as far as I can tell when some stupid dance on tiktok is more important than a supreme Court decision you got to figure we're in trouble.
I'm glad that you're continuing to ply your trade. I recently stopped building furniture it's hard work and at my age I just can't do it anymore. I'm glad you can. What you do is important and still makes a difference thank you Mr Steinberg
Is that a photo of the bulldog edition atop today's blog?
ReplyDeleteThat aside, upon hearing of all of the departures I decided that the paper would be so thin that it wouldn't be worth the two bucks on it every day. (No subscription for me; my morning exercise for decades has been to go to a newsstand, or news box, and now either CVS or the Jewel's for my paper). My dad was an avid reader of the Sun, my mom preferred the Times. When the papers merged, I became a Sun-Times reader.
I've seen many writers come and go -- Edgar Munzel, Jack Griffin, Bill Gleason in sports; financial writer Edwin Darby; Zay Smith. And when M.W. Newman came over when the Daily News folded, I was as giddy as a high school senior on prom night, because I could still read his poetic sentences. Oh yes, I loved reading Paige Smoron (later Wiser)!
I miss all of them, most of all Tom Fitzpatrick and Roger Simon. But after they left talented writers took their places. That's why I've been a devoted Sun-Times readers all my very long life.
And so I believed buying the paper wouldn't be worth it anymore, until I read your blog post this morning. I remembered that I was still reader during the Murdoch regime, always thinking everything will get better. It did.
I am not sure of that now. I doubt all the dearly departed will be replaced; I suspect none will.
But I can't stop buying the paper. And I mean the print edition; I need print like I need air, water, and my daily bread. (Is there still a late sports final? Haven't been able to find one in months).
So I'm in it until the end, mine or yours, mine being the likelier of the two.
"If ever could I leave you ... no never could I leave you at all."
Future generations may not recognize the irony inherent in “The Jewel’s”
DeleteThirty-six years in the city and the suburbs. Never heard anybody end it with an "s"...not nobody, not no how. Not even once. Must be a South Side thing.
DeleteAmen
DeleteReading the column was like listening to the eulogy at the funeral of a loved one.
ReplyDeleteBingo. As one who has written and delivered several of them, I thought of a eulogy immediately. At the funeral for the Sun-Times. It sounds like the paper is now on life support. I hope I am mistaken about its shakiness. At this point, I am wondering how long it will survive. Print journalism itself appears to be on a ventilator, and sinking very fast.
DeleteHope Mr. S, and all the EGD readers, will pardon my ignorance, but how does a buyout actually work? Like a winning lottery ticket? Do you get a lump sum? Or payouts for a fixed period? Do you get several years worth of earnings, or a take-it-or leave it amount? Is the Sun-Times for sale again? Am asking these questions in all seriousness, because I was never in a position to be offered a buyout. Not even close, in four decades of employment.
My experience was usually a get-the-hell-out. In one of two ways...either a kick-out---or a bug-out. As in..."I can't take this crap anymore. I'm done here, and I'm walking." Sometimes, it was the only way to keep one's sanity and self-respect intact. Turning 65 meant all that was behind me. Free at last, free at last. Geezerhood does have its benefits.
The final obit that Mr. S writes may turn out to be the one for his employer, and for his lengthy career. His longevity as a columnist exceeds both Royko and Greene. Which is nothing to sneeze at. Hoping it lasts a bit longer. Forty and out. A nice round number.
"Several years worth of earnings?" Grizz, Grizz, Grizz ... my 38 years earned me six months pay, I believe in a lump sum. But if they laid me off, I got four, and I figured locking in an extra two months wasn't worth throwing my career away for.
DeleteSorry to hear that, Mr. S. And sorry I didn't know any better. I'm just an out of touch old fart whose last paycheck was deposited when Obama was in office. The first time around.
DeleteTold your sad tale to my wife, Mr. S, and she replied:
Delete"That wasn't a buyout he was offered...it was more like a buy-off!"
My wife is the Bright One around here. Thought you might appreciate that.
There were at least 6 of us Librarians (that I can remember the names of) in the library along with 4 or 5 clerks (who were actually more like para-professionals. May have been one more Librarian....
ReplyDeleteThere's one whose name I still clearly remember. Think you know who I mean.
DeleteHad a crush on her in the worst way. Made such an ass of myself that it was like sitting on a copy machine.
Even went out with her for a little while. She had lived in Boston and Paris, and I wanted to impress her...and to show off my city. So we went down to Hyde Park for jazz. Ended up at the Cove Lounge, on E. 55th.
It's a dive bar now, but it was a jazz bar in '77. Live music, and maybe the best jazz jukebox in the city. She was somewhat impressed. And she must have liked Chicago, because she remained at the Sun-Times for a long time.
This column gave me a lump in my throat. I’ve been reading the print Sun Times daily since I was 10, 62 years ago. And as long as there is a print edition I’ll be a subscriber. This is important work, both publishing it and reading it.
ReplyDeleteExactly.
ReplyDeletejohn
Absolutely poetic column and thank you for staying with us.
ReplyDeleteAll week I've been dreading your column, but this is such a beautiful tribute to all the journalist we, as readers, have been privileged to be enlightened, amused, challenged, angered & engaged with. I breathe a HUGE sigh of relief that we will have your column to push our buttons & poke the bear, to make us better humans.
ReplyDeleteTo have that I will pay any price to read you and the other stalwarts in my morning print paper! Bravo Everyone !
Fine words.
ReplyDeleteOn Richard Roeper, Neil rightly noted that he is a really good writer. I only realized that the last several years--I think he had gotten better over the years. Now when I read a Roeper review I often stop to marvel at the words I just read. His superb writing ability lifts him above most film critics in the business.
ReplyDelete