Monday, April 28, 2025

Banging on the library door

   
The Richelieu Reading Room of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, or French National Library, in Paris.

     They're taking my Chicago Public Library card away?!?
     Were you to evaluate the range of bad news in last Tuesday's Sun-Times, from the death of a courageous, liberal pope to the prospect of an impoverished city of Chicago laying off employees, you might not choose Shannon Tyler's story on page 15: "E-cards to be discontinued by library."
     Then again, you are not a library geek, like me, who takes his libraries very seriously.
     The CPL and I go waaay back — heck, I was involved in the decision-making process that selected the building for the Harold Washington Library Center. (OK, OK, the public was invited to vote on a variety of design options. I voted and my favorite won — I liked the elaborate frou-frou at the corners and didn't know they made patrons go through a maze to get into the place.)
     Then again, libraries tend to make you jump through hoops. But I'm always up to the task. From the British Library in London to the New York Public Library to the Library of Congress in Washington, I've gotten in, received library cards, roamed the subterranean stacks, consulted books and, in general, reveled in their bookish splendor.
     The British Library gave me a card good for five years. The Newberry Library not only gave me a card but a shelf to put my checked-out books on. And now the best Chicago can do for non-residents is issue a chit good for 90 days, non-renewable?
     Have you ever researched a topic? Ninety days is a start. Ninety days is clearing your throat. I've stepped over a book on the floor for 90 days before cracking the cover. These things take time.
     I use the CPL website continually, simply because it's the easiest way to search historic newspapers — the Chicago Defender, the Chicago Inter Ocean. Have you ever read the Inter Ocean? Its reporters were so sharp, I want to disinter their bodies and shake their clawed hands. Even the Tribune archive — in fact, I consult the Trib from decades past far more than I read today's Tribune.
     And you want to take that away? Just because I live in Northbrook? You monsters!
     I phoned the library. What, I wondered, have I ever done to you to deserve this? Being besieged by suburbanites trying to consult the Chicago Examiner online, are you?
     "We have such a demand," said Patrick Molloy, director of government and public affairs for the library. "Not so much from the suburban people, as we have people from all over the country and even internationally, creating online cards, checking out ebooks — they've got 15 things on hold — and people are waiting a really long time to get ebooks."

To continue reading, click here.

32 comments:

  1. What the flood? That's nuts. Maybe you could use the Skokie Library, Mr. S. It's superb. And I'm not just saying that because I grew up using it, going all the way back to when it was still housed in a former post office, in the Fifties.

    For one thing, it is HUGE. Among the largest libraries in the State of Illinois. And they do...or at least used to...allow residents of nearby suburbs to check out books--and other materials.

    While living in Evanston, between 1975 and 1992, I used the Skokie facility as much as I used Evanston's. Maybe more. For starters, Skokie's library is much bigger. A very long aisle (with six-foot shelves on either side) of books on WWII. Which I devoured for a couple of decades, starting at 14, and barely made a dent in. Best WWII collection I have ever encountered, by far, in any of the six states I've lived in.

    Chicago's residency restriction works both ways, Mr. S. So Chicago doesn't want suburbanites using their library? Well, at least one suburb has felt the same way about city dwellers. Had no problems in Skokie as an Evanstonian. But when I moved to Rogers Park and Wrigleyville, between 1985 and 1990, duplicity soon became a necessity. What to do, what to do?

    Desperate times, desperate measures. An outdated utility bill, with an Evanston address? Hey, that's the ticket! Until a mailed overdue notice was returned. The Skokians were pissed at my chicanery. Reinstatement would require new documentation, and a yearly user fee.

    Moved to Ohio. Showed off the Skokie Library to my bookish wife, on a return visit.
    She was astonished by its size and scope. "What a lucky kid you were," she said.

    Yes. I most certainly was. Yes. Oh, yes...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't been to Skokie Library in several years, do they still have those atrocious uncomfortable bizarre leather chairs?
      At least Wilmette got rid of the even worse Wassily chairs it had! Those were actually torture devices!

      Delete
    2. You mean the curved black ones with the chrome frames?
      Originally purchased for their grand opening...in 1960.

      Haven't been to that library for at least a decade, probably more.
      Scene of one of the more notorious episodes of my teen years.

      Got drunk--at 14. Went to the library with friends, on a busy Saturday.
      Tossed my cookies, all over, and was taken into custody by Skokie PD.
      They baby-sat me for a few hours. Father wouldn't talk to me for 3 weeks.

      Delete
    3. Exactly those, whoever bought them should have been fired instantly!

      Delete
    4. Grizz, you are a bad boy.

      Delete
    5. No, I was just a pampered suburban punk. The kind who vandalized holiday displays because he was Jewish and felt left-out at Christmastime. I had what are now labeled "unresolved issues." Sixty-plus years have turned adolescent angst into amusing anecdotes.

      Delete
  2. Thanks for the tribute to libraries and the fabulous photo of Bibliotheque Nationale de France. I would love to see the Library of Congress, the New York Public Library, the British Library and others.

    ReplyDelete

  3. Perhaps CPL might consider any Illinoisan qualified to get a library card.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sure, if Northbrook extends the same courtesy

      Delete
  4. This one is Franklin level good, and it goes way beyond writing books. "Someone once asked me the trick to writing books, and I came up with what I thought was an honest answer: You start writing a book and then never stop."

    ReplyDelete
  5. perhaps you could pay to use the library if you dont live here. I was at the Garfield park conservatory yesterday and last week . chicago residents dont pay. and get a plus one.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have fond memories of the main library when it was on Michigan Avenue. All the way back to the 1950s, doing research on a high school paper. The staff eventually let me have a table back in the stacks. And the ywould come by and pick up call slips from me and bring the books to me. The subject "truth." I finally decided it was a matter of opinion, with an arrogance only a high school kid could muster.

    But also I remember the glorious fiction reading room (now Preston Bradley Hall), and the main reading room, where there was a system for notifying you when they had your books, I can't remember how it worked.

    Oddly, I can't find any good photos of that room, and particularly, not the circulation desk.

    Tempis Fugit and so does memory.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Did research at the main library for high school journalism classes in 1965. I think there were numbers that lit up, on the wall behind the circulation desk.

      Delete
  7. At least now my CPL card will be good forever, as long as I live in the city, no more having to update the info every couple of years when I check something out!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I moved to CA and maintained a rental in Chicago; last time I was in town I made sure to renew my card for online access since there are some things CPL has that I don't have out here. I absolutely can not argue with this decision since I no longer directly pay the taxes that support the library. I've been a theiving mooch.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You’re paying real estate taxes through your rent. I absolve you.

      Delete
  9. As Anonymous from CA points out, how many of the ~6million suburbanites should be allowed to use Chicago's tax-supported library for free? All of them? Should there be any limits on borrowing/reserving, or should open access perhaps only be for those who prove their bibliophile cred, like Neil? How many other of Chicago's tax-supported services should suburbanites be able to use, like police, fire, schools, etc.? I wonder how Grizz 65 would feel if 1.5 million Chicagoans started using Skokie's library for all the items that have long waiting lists at CPL. Why do police departments and schools get to place limits on who they serve based on geography but libraries cannot? Thoughts for my morning.....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. maybe those who live , work, own a business or property in Chicago would qualify for perks like library cards

      Delete
    2. As a visiting suburbanite, I would certainly hope (and expect) service from the cops, the firefighters, and the EMTs. They are not concerned with anyone's place of residence when they find themselves in trouble.

      Suppose I'm driving through a sketchy city neighborhood and I get shot, and my car hits a building and begins to burn. They are not going to ask for my ID, and then say: "He's from Skokie. [Forget] this [Hebrew]" They would not let me die, or fry, or bleed out.

      So equating first responders with libraries, and saying that they "get to place limits on who they serve, based on geography [as in residency]"' is both absurd and preposterous.

      If I'm a suburban victim in Chicago, they will be there for me when I need them. Same thing for a city resident who happens to be in Skokie or in Evanston...or anywhere else. Jeeze...

      Delete
    3. There's a lot of "absurb and preposterous" going around today. Make sure to read the letter I'm posting tomorrow. I want to keep my library card; you'd think I'd killed their children.

      Delete
  10. As a Chicago tax paying resident I cannot understand residents of a lovely suburb with a lovely library whining about lack of access to CPL. I had no idea it was so easy for non-residents to use the system. It simply is not fair. The wait time for popular material is eternity. Perhaps pay for a CPL library card? CPL certainly could use the money. I too love libraries and have fond memories of the main library (now Cultural Center) as well as the South Shore Branch that I used extensively growing up in Chicago.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Of course you can't. The same way, one assumes, you can't understand Iowans who are robbed here expecting police service, or Indianans expecting to use our roads. I'd be happy to pay for a library card — which I could argue I do by patronizing Chicago restaurants and businesses.

      Delete
    2. I agree with anon @11:36. State schools have residency requirements. School districts have residency requirements. Even park districts have residency requirements (rates) for pools and such.

      Delete
    3. Agree with anon and 11:36 and 12:55

      emergency services not the same or a good comparison

      Delete
  11. There was a similar brouhaha some years ago in Champaign County where the “big city” restricted access to the outlying towns. Lincoln Trail Library Systems said, “You can’t do that and remain in our system” or something similar. With all your research experience, I’m sure you can find it if you are so included but here’s a start https://www.smilepolitely.com/splog/lincoln_trail_to_cham-_library_no_you_didnt/

    Ultimately, this seems like a philosophical stance (albeit with practical implications) which speaks to identity. What sort of library do we want to be? On the one hand, it seems reasonable to treat heavy users differently than those who wander in once a year. On the other, it seems like the heavy users are the ones who keep the place relevant.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Coincidentally, I’m in the midst of reading the excellent The Library Book by Susan Orlean. It tells the story of a 1986 fire at the Los Angeles Public Library, and also goes into the history of libraries, librarians, book burnings, and other related topics. Highly recommend.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Read it years ago, but it was...and is...unforgettable.

      Delete
  13. Illinois libraries don't have an inter-library loan system?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They do, but that is under attack by the orange menace as well

      Delete
  14. Have several librarians and library workers in my family. Two visiting this week from SC and MI are curling my garter belt with stories of increasing anti-library legislation being proposed and adopted. Well, Trump did say he likes the poorly educated.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This one has me scratching my head. I own a home in unincorporated Du Page County where we spend much of the year. We are registered and have borrowing privledges at a half dozen libraries--Wheaton, Winfield, West Chicago, Batavia, St. Charles and Elburn. I keep my library card updated at each and am permitted to check out anything I like for up to three weeks. There are no charges. They are public libraries with (apparently) reciprocal lending agreements? No fuss, no muss. I don't understand all the hoo-ha with the Chicago system and why it has caused such upset here. I'm missing something. I know.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.