Sunday, October 29, 2017

Rise of printing sparked Luther's Reformation 500 years ago



     There is no evidence that an Augustine monk named Martin Luther, unhappy with a popular fundraising tool of the Catholic Church, actually nailed his list of complaints — the famous "95 Theses" — to the door of the All Saints' Church at Wittenburg exactly 500 years ago. He never claimed to have done so, and the story wasn't circulated until after his death.
     We do know that he distributed them in a letter dated Oct. 31, 1517, to the archbishop, listing his 95 criticisms about the enthusiasm with which the church was selling indulgences.
     An indulgence was a piece of paper that, for instance, shortened the time that had to be spent in purgatory. The church had been vigorously selling them to raise money to rebuild the St. Peter's Basilica in Rome.
     This bothered Luther a lot, not because he was so liberal, but because he was so pious. He prayed, he fasted, he flagellated himself. Luther was getting to heaven the hard way, and it galled him that a rich man could just loosen his purse strings, dig out a few coins, and cut in line.
     "The treasures of indulgences are nets that are now used to fish for the wealth of people," reads thesis No. 66.
Indulgence issued by Pope Sixtus IV
      You can see an actual indulgence — from Pope Sixtus IV, raising money for an expedition against the Turks — on display at the Newberry Library in a fascinating exhibit, "Religious Change and Print: 1450-1700," that runs through Dec. 27.
     The show connects the beginning of the Reformation to the rise of printing, beginning with a leaf from the Gutenberg Bible. The publication of a Bible using moveable type, we tend to forget, was itself a radical act, moving the Holy Scriptures from hand-copied, vastly expensive work owned by churches, into mass-produced, less-expensive reading material that could eventually find its way into the hands of regular people, who could then fancy themselves free to not only read it, but to analyze and dispute what was within. Soon those people were printing books of their own, plus pamphlets and broadsheets. Printing and heresy went hand-in-hand.
     "They're very closely connected," said David Spadafora, president of the Newberry. "Print right away becomes a very important medium for people like Luther to get their views out to a wider public than could possibly otherwise have received them."

To continue reading, click here.

16 comments:

  1. Great stuff, Neil.

    If he Lord God Almighty has half the sick sense of humor that I think He does, He will take one of those little splinter groups that are always flaking off from the Mormon Church--The True Fundamentalist Church of the Prophet Billy Bob or whatever--and designate that as the One True Church, consigning all others to hell. That would be worth watching.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In an attempt to give definition to the abstract concept of God, man created religion; over and over and over again. Our vainglorious insistence that our understanding of God is superior to another's, is a dangerous path. We've fought wars over fanciful notions. The humor in all of this is that we mean well.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your column reminded me about something I wonder every time I hear fervent Catholics like Newt Gingrich shriek about sharia law: what if the traditionally anti-Catholic KKK were to start making the case that American Catholics prioritize Vatican law over US law? It wouldn’t be difficult to point to the church’s sexual abuse cover up as evidence.
    Of course, that would be an irresponsible twisting of facts that would vilify millions unjustly . . .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kennedy first Catholic president. Prevoiusly, the idea of a Catholic president was tainted by the belief that a Catholic president would first serve the Pope, forcing his religious beliefs into the Constitution and onto the Natiom.

      Delete
  4. 3 cheers for Luther, Calvin, Wesley, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Excellent piece, Neil. Hope to make it to the Newberry to see this exhibit while it's there.

    "Once he started questioning Church authority, Luther was surprised and aghast to find people started questioning *him*." ... "Luther really wanted to put Bibles in people’s hands, on the other hand, he came to realize they were doing interpretation much more individualistically than even he felt comfortable with."

    Yeah, once you open the floodgates, there's no telling what flotsam and jetsam might start making its way through...

    Off-topic: I realize that the S-T needs to make money, but the Rauner ad attached to this column that started auto-playing audio of folks extolling Mike Madigan's benefits to *other* states, was extra annoying. And isn't going to be changing this voter's opinion of the governor who doesn't govern one bit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. Attention, Governor: We don't give a flying suck what the governors of neighboring hick states think about Mike Madigan, or anyone or anything else.

      Delete
  6. My favorite part of this story is when Henry VIII of England wrote a book attacking Luther's theology in 1521 titled "Defense of the Seven Sacraments" for which Pope Leo X gave him the title "Defender of the Faith". Later, after Henry was excommunicated for breaking with the Church to start his own in order to divorce his wife and marry Anne Boleyn, this title was rescinded, but English monarchs still retain the title to this day though they're not Catholics.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Which reminds me of what someone said of Queen Elizabeth I: that she was a papist at heart; she just wanted to be Pope herself.

      John

      Delete
  7. Printing did certainly have something to do with the Reformation, but credit is also given to the humanistic movement, instigated in Italy by a new interest in classical literature. Luther could be called a humanist, and was the most vigorous in attacking the Papacy, but others like Erasmus, Melanchthon and Zwingli were also prominent actors.

    Luther was, indeed, a fervent anti-Semite, but I don't think that carried over into modern Lutheranism in Germany. I have been told that, at least until the Third Reich, Lutheran Berlin was more tolerant than Catholic Vienna. And Hitler was a Catholic.

    Tom

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hitler was raised as a Catholic. I think it's safe to say that it didn't take very well.

      Delete
  8. There you go again Neil. Every time I want to take a long piss all over this blog and never read again you write a balanced thoughtful and informative article. I know you suffer terribly from Trump Derangement Syndrome but it seems you're in remission for the weekend. Watch a little Fox say a few prayers(like people take stuff for Herpes outbreaks) and you can avoid flare-ups and write great media like Luther's 500th!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You forget, MF, that given the bullshit you've written previously, praise from you carries very little weight. If you think it might do you some good someday, by all means keep reading, maintaining a manful silence if you possibly can. But don't do me any favors.

      Delete
    2. There is only one person who suffers from Trump Derangement Syndrome, and his name is Donald Trump.

      Delete
  9. Wow -- I did graduate work at the U of C's Divinity School and worked at a Lutheran-owned college for 8 years -- one that has been preparing for the 500th anniversary of the 95 theses for years -- and I never knew the "nailing them to a door" bit might not have occurred. I've read the account in a number of works/heard it in courses -- never heard it might have been an embellishment after the fact. Thanks for the lesson!

    ReplyDelete