Friday, March 10, 2017

As American as baseball, mom, apple pie and Jews

     It's the last Monday in February and 20 teenage boys are waiting in a gym in Deerfield. It could be any high school gym anywhere, except for the big silver mezuzah on the cinderblock doorway, an Israeli flag next to the American flag, and the banner reading "Rochelle Zell Jewish High School."
     Paul Chanan gathers the boys in a circle and begins the traditional start-of-practice pep talk.
     "Today represents the first day of what will be a real long journey to reach some very lofty goals," says Chanan, an options-trader-turned-teacher. "Coach Zouber and myself are incredibly proud to lead this team of great guys, of great competitors and of great community. This is going to be a joy for us, and we are honored to be your coaches. But we are going to ask a lot of you. ... We are going to ask that you give us everything that you have. ... We are going to absolutely 100 percent demand 100 percent from you, all the time. We are going to compete with great hustle. With maximum intensity. With aggressive style of play and with an unyielding passion for the game of baseball and for your team."
     "Yes coach!" the boys reply.
     Not realizing that Rochelle Zell is a new school — founded in 2001 — whose students range across the spectrum of faith, I went to practice expecting a scene out of Chaim Potok's The Chosen — earlocks and fringes flying as guys round the bases, outfielders punching their gloves and razzing the hitter in Yiddish.
     In Potok's novel, baseball is pushed by teachers because "it was an unquestioned mark of one's Americanism and to be counted a loyal American had become increasingly important."
     Rochelle Zell's team was started four years ago — not by teachers, but by a pair of freshmen, Jon Silvers and his best friend, Adam Gilman, both now 17 and co-captains.

     To continue reading, click here


  1. A wonderful article and we wish them well.

  2. Reminds me of my basketball team at Mt. Carmel Seminary in Niagara Falls that one of the priests there shocked me by describing as the raggedy ass cadets.


  3. How incredibly sad that safety concerns make the school want to keep their game location private.

    1. That had to be a joke, right?

      Please tell me that was a joke.

    2. Oh dear God. What have things come to in this country, that a bunch of young boys who just want to play baseball have to hide like criminals?

      I used to give Donald Trump the benefit of the doubt regarding anti-Semitism, based on the faith of his son-in-law and daughter. No more.

      He made that human garbage pile Steve Bannon his top advisor. Bannon, whose sewage sump of a website is the festering place for those Pepe-the-Frog, alt-right, let's-Photoshop-Jewish-journalists-into-Auschwitz-uniforms-ha-ha-ha blights on humanity who are turning out to be a key constituency.

      By now it doesn't matter if Trump is personally anti-Semitic or just so morally bereft that he values loyalty, even loyalty to putrid bigots, above all else. I curse the memory of Ronald Reagan because, with his "welfare queens" and "strapping young bucks buying T-bones with food stamps," he normalized bigotry. Trump is taking it one step further: He's normalizing bigoted violence.

      At this point it's anyone's guess as to which aspect of Trump's legacy will prove to be the most enduringly toxic. But enabling violence against Jews and other marginal groups is a strong candidate.

  4. Interesting piece on Bannon in todays NYT. He seems to view himself as a modern Thomas Cromwell. He also has ties to conservative Catholics who want to turn the theological clock back a few centuries.

    Today's NYT also has a nice, coherent takedown of the GOP health bill.



Comments are moderated, and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.