Saturday, March 30, 2024

Jews on Scooters

El Chonon and Mendel, right, on the hunt.

      Suburban street life has a bad reputation. Or rather, no reputation at all. Generic houses along curving nondescript streets. Astroturf lawns. Block after block of empty sidewalk, devoid of humanity, art, interest.
     No paleta carts. No street musicians. No knots of kids hanging out on stoops. Hardly any stoops at all.
     Even my own section of the leafy suburban paradise of Northbrook, close to the train station, the library, the Village Hall, downtown, public garden and soccer field can, particularly early in the morning, feel lonely, even forlorn. Where is everybody?
     Other times, life is to be found here. I routinely happen upon fellow dog walkers.  Conversation ensues. Banners hang from light poles. In the winter, the trees are decked with lights, in the summer, hanging baskets of flowers. There are festivals, parades, lemonade stands. I can stand in my backyard and hear trains and shouts from hockey games. Not to forget exotic fauna: owls, hawks, even a stray fox or coyote. 
     Plus the occasional religious zealot. Friday afternoon I was giving Kitty her afternoon stroll by the Civic Foundation — which regularly draws crowds of business people, Rotarians and recovering alcoholics, arriving for their 10 a.m. Sunday meeting — when I spotted the above pair of Hasidim on scooters. Their black hats; the white strands of their tzitzits dangling out from below their jackets.
     I had the presence of mind to instantly whip out my iPhone and snap some shots. Usually I'd be reluctant — the polite thing is to ask permission first. But as these young men are in the business of accosting strangers for their own religious purposes — in their worldview, getting Jews to do their duty hurries along the time of the messiah (assuming he wasn't just here, in the form of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Menachem Mendel Schneerson, but I've addressed that previously). Turnabout is fair play. I fired away, then asked them if they mind me taking their photos. They didn't seem to. Or at least didn't say so.
     I mentioned that I had been friendly with the late Rabbi Daniel Moscowitz, who headed the Lubavitch movement in Illinois, and know one of his sons, Rabbi Meir. They nodded vaguely — kids of any faith seem fairly oblivious of the world they've sprung up in.
     I've written before about the cheder boys who'd come to the newspaper to hunt for Jewish men to prod into donning on prayer boxes, as required in Deuteronomy 6:6-9: "And these words that I command you today shall be on your heart. You shall teach them diligently to your children, and shall talk of them when you sit in your house, and when you walk by the way, and when you lie down, and when you rise up. And you shall bind them upon thy hand and they shall be for frontlets between your eyes. You shall write them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates."
     That last line, by the way, is why most Jewish homes have mezuzahs — little decorative boxes containing key prayers. Even Jews who don't observe much of their religion manage to put up a mezuzah, and why not? It's a comforting ritual, to touch the little lozenge as you come and go.
    The lads — Elchonon and Mendel, both 15, the pride of the Yeshivas Ohr Eliyahu Lubavitch Mesivta of Chicago on Morse — asked me if I wanted to pray. How could I refuse, given my documentation of their arrival? I said I was game. Elchonon (he said it means "the land" though Prof. Google translate it as "God has graced") handed me a black yarmulke, and instructed me to roll up my left sleeve so it could be wrapped in a leather strap. I took off my fleece to facilitate that. Mendel looked on — usually, with these pairs, there's the alpha boy and the beta boy, the doer and the watcher.  I set down Kitty's leash, stepped on it to keep her from bolting after a bunny or squirrel — more street life — and expressed a concern that the dog might be tref, or unkosher. Dogs do not figure largely in Ultra-Orthodox Judaism. But they didn't seem to mind Kitty, which I took, like the scooters, as a sign of uncharacteristic liberality.
     I must be getting thick-skinned in my old age, but I cared not a whit what any passing Northbrookites might think to see me putting on phylacteries in the street. I repeated the half-remembered prayers after Elchonon's prompting.
     Truth is, over the past years, I've soured a bit on the Lubavitch, as the New York Times documented how their East Coast schools fail miserably when it came to non-Talmudic subjects like science and math. A shonda fur die goyim. Religion should expand a person's scope, not clap him in blinders. And the Ultra-Orthodox have been cheerleaders for right wing nationalism, at home and in Israel. Not the spirit of Adonai as I understand it. What good is Judaism if it's just another brand of oppression?
      That said, the home team has been suffering enough lately, as the hostility being firehosed toward Israel for defending itself splashes Jews in general, many of whom were pretty down on the country before, for picking a Trumpish criminal and self-dealing stooge like Benjamin Netanyahu to lead it. If I had to choose which is a more pressing priority, crushing Hamas or tossing Netanyahu into the dustbin of history, I'd say both are important, though maybe not in that order. 
    Anyway, Elchonon — sounds almost Spanish, doesn't it? El Chonon! — handed me a little brochure analyzing this week's parsha — the portion of the Torah read in synagogue. Regarding burnt offerings in the Temple 3,000 years before the latest group who showed up and announced the land is theirs and the Jews should quietly die where they stand or go live someplace else, far, far, away. In your dreams...
     He asked where I lived, and I pointed toward my house, already worrying about weekly visits — I suppose I could just tell him to scram, though that seems unkind. The news being what it is, we Jews need to hang together or eventually, to paraphrase Ben Franklin, we'll run the risk of hanging separately. It's happened before.

26 comments:

  1. The older ones often accost me on the stairs at the Rogers Park Metra station & ask "Are you a Jew?"
    And my answer is always the same "Only Nazis ask that question!"
    It never seems to get through to them!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Clark, you win the Comments section today.

      Often we become that which we despise the most...

      Delete
    2. Clark, it usually works like this--even in East Rogers Park:

      If someone asks: "Are you Jewish?"...then you're both in the same tribe.
      If someone asks: "Are you a Jew?"...then they aren't one. Be on guard.
      If someone asks: "You Jew?"...then you'd better start running like hell.

      Delete
  2. Its not just kids that can be oblivious to the world around them. While I absolutely love this piece, I woke up sure that we are on the eve of the holiest day on the christian calendar . Yes more than Christmas . While I am not a practicing religious zealot I was surprised to find you getting all jewy on us this weekend Neil . Especially , you know, with the part many believe Jews played in the death of christ lol. I heard they snuck up on him in a bunny costume

    Stood on the street and prayed? Good on you! And as far as sticking together I'm right there with y'all .

    Hope to bump into you one day and maybe we can pray together .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So you were ... umm ... expecting some Christian content ... in deference to the holiday? Obviously you aren't paying attention.

      Delete
    2. Well no! Not Christian content for sure. Just well. I'm never sure what to expect with you. That's why I read every god. Damn day. You know I threw an lol in there and clearly joking reference to the Easter Bunny. I'm just trying to get through the day man.
      I'm definitely paying attention but not taking things too seriously. Maybe you should try that

      Delete
    3. Why not? I address Christian matters all the time. Taking things seriously — or at least trying to understand them, even when they're rambling and borderline trash-worthy, is kinda what I'm trying to do here.

      Delete
  3. I went to high school in a European nation which referred to itself as a "poor country" at the time though it is now one of the world's richest. The Mormon missionaries were delighted to find we came from Mormonland. My father told them they could visit as long as they didn't talk religion (we were typical "frozen chosen"). They were delightful and grateful. Secular Europe is hardship duty.

    ReplyDelete
  4. As difficult as it may be to proselitize, I give credit to these two young men and to you for obliging them. Whenever someone shows up at my door preaching about salvation, I don't answer. If literature is left behind, it goes in the recycling bin. Religion, whatever your beliefs are, is a private matter. Just like political yard signs, your literature and signs are not going to make any difference in how I pray and/or vote.

    Judy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Whenever those folks show up at my door, I just point to the mezuzah on the doorpost and tell them not to waste their time...or mine. I'm trying to be both funny and snarky, but the joke is lost on most of them. Quite a few of them don't even know what I'm pointing to.

      If I'm in an especially bad mood, I tell them it's there to keep pests away, and that it's obviously not working, and now I'll have to return it. That one, they understand.

      Delete
  5. I'm tempted to tell you to "Lighten up, Francis", Neil.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for starting my day with a smile. Enjoyed the vivid picture you created of praying with Jews on scooters.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Those boychicks can get away with that in your leafy shtetl, as well as in Skokie, Highland Park, etc. Probably scooted OUT OF TOWN in many others. As I understand it the Lubavitch are the hippies of the Orthodox groups; surely they are the least offensive.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In my experience, the more complicated the religion, the further it is from the truth. That is because all faiths, and every word of their holy books, came from the minds of men. The creator has moved on and could care less what we wear or the words we recite. I hope his/her/its' parting advice would have been "be nice", but that is just another dream. Better that Neil's new friends would be learning about the real world, especially since Jewish scholars have found evidence that David's Kingdom was more a tribe and that there is no evidence of an Exodus from Egypt. It's no surprise, as today a walk through any bookstore would mean passing by a host of prevarications. I knew a former Catholic priest, now married, who invited the neighborhood Jehovahs into his home. When he parried every distortion they spewed and welcomed their leader the following week, it was agreed that he would no longer be bothered by the Witnesses. Joe, like Neil, was nice to the overly indoctrinated strangers, and perhaps planted seeds that would sprout in time. If only that would work in the Magaverse.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You could start your own religion, JP, with "Be nice" as the only doctrine. That's so uncomplicated that it might not be far from "the truth." Of course, you probably already practice that, and others can as well, with no need for any other components of a religion...

      Delete
    2. When I used to answer the door when the JWs rang the bell, I was always really nasty to them. The had the really annoying habit of doing that before 8AM of Saturdays.
      So I used to say stuff like go get a blood transfusion & then run something up a flagpole & salute. They actually didn't get it.
      Once I said "I'm awaiting for the return of our great lord satan" & the man just said to me "OK".
      But seriously, we have Johnnie Carson to thank for them not showing up really early on Saturdays anymore, he made a standing joke of that for weeks at a time.
      BTW, the JWs as a religion are really rich, because several years ago they sold the HQ in Brooklyn for big bucks, which was two huge old multi-story printing plants & moved to Upstate New York. They then got their members to give free labor to build the new HQ, as an act of love, so they didn't pay for labor for most of it!

      Delete
    3. Sounds good, Jakash. But...I was flattering myself the other day, imagining that I might reply to the question, "Do you believe in God?" with "No, but I believe in Good." Which is pretty much like the "Be nice" doctrine you mention. Unfortunately, even an innocuous belief such as "Good" or "Be nice" can be subject to complications and zealotry. I'm thinking of the Dickens characters who are obsessed with African charity while ignoring the needs of their neighbors.

      john

      Delete
    4. We got some of those "I Believe In Good" stickers in the mail. Cut off the ends. Now they proclaim: "I Believe In Goo"...take that any way you like. Use your imagination.

      Delete
    5. And I thought I had invented the original statement. If you shorten it further, to "I believe in go" it might look even more enigmatic, perhaps Zen like. My new motto.

      john

      Delete
    6. Evidently, there's nothing new under the sun, John. I've referred before to you being the "patron saint" of this blog; whatever motto you settle on is fine by me.

      Gotta say, though, that while I'm a little rusty on my Dickens, the "characters who are obsessed with African charity while ignoring the needs of their neighbors" are not actually being nice or good, overall, are they? They're ignoring the core concept in favor of "complications and zealotry."

      Delete
  9. I read the linked post from 2016 back then. Having also read almost all the thousands of *other* EGD posts since Day 1, however, I'm almost as surprised as I was then that you'd participate in this ritual. But the rationale offered there, "Altruism, mostly" is a generous one and clearly still carries the day.

    "I must be getting thick-skinned in my old age, but I cared not a whit what any passing Northbrookites might think to see me putting on phylacteries in the street." "Old age" doesn't seem to be the determining factor. 8 years ago, when you were as young as a spring bunny, you wrote: "It must also freak out passersby — I have a glass wall in the office. I like the thought of people walking by and seeing Steinberg lost in some arcane religious act with three black-hatted attendants."

    "...the New York Times documented how their East Coast schools fail miserably when it came to non-Talmudic subjects like science and math." That is also kinda surprising, given the focus on education that seems to be important to many who are Jewish. I always thought that most Catholic schools were *too* good at educating their students, in a sense. They were fine at teaching science and math, in my experience. So good that the knowledge of those subjects led many of the students to question the religious component of their instruction and become either lapsed Catholics or atheists.

    Not a very generous comment from me for Easter weekend, I'm afraid. However, it may offer perspective with regard to the reported lack of excellence in non-Talmudic subjects in the Lubavitch schools.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Catholic schools could expel their problems easier than public schools. They could also threaten the students with dangerous weapons, nuns with hardwood pointers strong as a cue stick and high school priests with their fists. Parents supported these policies, possibly leading to a slightly more motivated student body and thus a better educated group of graduates. Catholics lapse because the childish bible stories don't endure maturity, which leads to questioning other tenets of the faith. The Golden Rule endures because it makes sense, Jesus is quoted in Matthew that loving god and your neighbor is enough, so when you lose the fear of god, all that is left is your fellow man.

      Delete
    2. In my reply to you, JP, I was trying to support "Be nice" as a concept. So much for that idea.

      I don't quite know why my mild comment about Catholic schools prompted this response, but it seems kinda like an argument one hears against school vouchers. I am far from being a proponent of school vouchers.

      I was referring to my experience, which involved a school where I don't recall a student being expelled. Nor was I the victim of nasty nuns, nor punchy priests. Obviously, the things you refer to are cliches, and not without basis. But a lot of Catholic schools did and do feature dedicated, hard-working, underpaid teachers doing a good, largely thankless job overall.

      As I noted, yes, lots of Catholics question their faith and many leave it behind. You state that "bible stories don't endure maturity." In lots of cases, that is the case. If the whole issue were as simple as that, however, neither Judaism nor Christianity would have lasted beyond a generation. As it is, they've endured for millennia, with loads of adherents who are much more mature than I am. Getting back to "be nice," you make a valid point about the Golden Rule being sensible, whatever else one may believe.

      Delete
    3. Jakash, my reply was my take on why a Catholic education could be superior. I let my personal experience at two particular institutions negatively slant the response. I agree that many Parochial school teachers are dedicated teachers and underpaid compared to Cook County public schools. My cousin, first, once removed, was a wonderful person, and also her contemporaries. Unfortunately I couldn't meet the entrance requirements for Immaculata. You are definitely right about the staying power of religion. My guess is it offers comfort of some sort. I can't convince myself that any religion is close to a true story about our existence. I understand why they exist but don't understand why people cling to them when reason and reality points in a different direction. To buy into the concept of God, just in case, is less likely than believing in the story of Noah and the earth totally submerged.

      Delete
    4. Thanks for that reply, JP. I'm pretty conflicted about the whole subject, so my comments can be inconsistent. "I can't convince myself that any religion is close to a true story about our existence." Most of the time, that's how I feel, as well, but my upbringing and many more-or-less religious friends and family members keep me from being as conclusive or settled about it as I'd probably otherwise be.

      Delete
  10. The girls in that sect are probably not even allowed to go on the scooters.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.