Something special, exclusively for EGD readers. Typically, I run a few paragraphs of my Sun-Times column then link to the paper — they pay for it, they deserve the clicks. But today I'm running the entire thing, because the version in the newspaper was ... how to say this tactfully? ... watered down, out of concern for their 501(c)3 status. Click here for the paper's version, for those inclined to compare. But you're braver than I, who couldn't bring myself to read the final version. I turned in this:
Donald Trump has taken to calling Kamala Harris "Kamabla" in his social media posts.
Which at first glance seems minor, one of those tiny things that flies by unchallenged in the endless media whirlwind. Trump is such a gushing geyser of lies, errors, insults and malice that to focus on any one bit seems naive, almost pointless. By the time you've remarked on it, it's already out-of-date, replaced with a dozen more of the same, or worse.
Trump is fond of tagging childish nicknames on his opponents. But "Kamabla" resonates more, at least with me. Mangling someone's name is a classic racist go-to move. The "What kinda funny name is THAT?" grin is implied. I get "Bergstein" and "Steingold" and "Goldstein" and a dozen variants, all signs that that I'm about to read the thoughts — to stretch the term — of some sneering anti-Semite who feels compelled to weigh in on today's topic.
Or not read them.Why bother? Racism, remember, is a form of ignorance —you're not perceiving the world as it is, but through the crazy kaleidoscope lens of your own obsessive fears. Who cares what dumb haters think? And the funny thing is, egotism is such an intrinsic part of being a bigot, the thought they're disregarded as beneath contempt doesn't occur to them. I have people gibbering in my Spam folder, ignored, for years.
But the Republican presidential candidate cannot be dismissed so easily. Even though none of this is news. Ever since he came down that brass escalator in the garish lobby of Trump Tower on June 16, 2015 and started slurring Mexicans as criminals and rapists, he's been the pied piper for the lowest sub-hell of the American psyche: racism, sexism, xenophobia, nationalism, religious bigotry.
Nearly a decade. No wonder we're all loopy. No wonder Joe Biden bowing out of the race brought an explosion of joy, optimism and energy. Hope dawned. Maybe we can finally break the spell.
This has been a particularly exuberant week, since Harris announced her running mate is Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz.
Walz wasn't on my radar. My personal favorite was secretary of transportation Pete Buttigieg, the sharpest razor wit in politics. The prospect of watching him vivisect Trump and Vance for the next three months was delicious to contemplate.
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro was my second choice. He's also a guy who can deliver a verbal broadside, and could be expected to win his own battleground state. Plus he's Jewish — as with Sandy Koufax, you like to see your guy on the mound, striking 'em out.
Both men had drawbacks. Buttigieg is gay, so picking him would churn the Republican waters — not that they wouldn't churn anyway — plus give pause to some Democrats who harbor anti-gay bias. Sure, it would be cool to have a gay vice-president — a sign that maybe our country isn't really a nest of hidebound religious loons who live their lives in a sex panic frenzy. But prejudice isn't something people gladly admit to pollsters, and you'd hate to bet our democracy on just how progressive people are in their secret hearts, then wake up Nov. 6 and find out you were wrong.
Shapiro being Jewish, while catnip to Jews, would have been a drawback last year, but since Oct. 7 has become an anchor, as the outrage of Palestinians — and their undergraduate allies —over the Israel-Hamas War tends to drift from Israelis to Zionists to Jews in general. And Shapiro is no random member of the Tribe, but as governor shut down campus protest in a way that Palestinian activists didn't like.
“Somebody like Shapiro would be an absolute disaster since he essentially has made it seem as if the Palestinians don’t have any rights to freedom or self-determination or anything,” said Hatem Abudayyeh, national chair of the U.S. Palestinian Community Network, while Harris was still pondering her choice.
Some Jews chose to register displeasure at Shapiro being passed over. Me, I understand that the goal here is to win, and if Harris-Walz has a slightly better chance at victory than Harris-Shapiro, then Harris-Walz it is. Would you rather lose with your guy, or win with somebody else? We can work at perfecting American society afterward.
That's called strategic thinking. The idea that people unhappy with some current administration policy are going to withhold their support, or back the guy who would be much, much worse, is cutting off your nose to spite your face. Maybe Jews are unduly attached to our often considerable noses. But doing that just isn't smart.
Which at first glance seems minor, one of those tiny things that flies by unchallenged in the endless media whirlwind. Trump is such a gushing geyser of lies, errors, insults and malice that to focus on any one bit seems naive, almost pointless. By the time you've remarked on it, it's already out-of-date, replaced with a dozen more of the same, or worse.
Trump is fond of tagging childish nicknames on his opponents. But "Kamabla" resonates more, at least with me. Mangling someone's name is a classic racist go-to move. The "What kinda funny name is THAT?" grin is implied. I get "Bergstein" and "Steingold" and "Goldstein" and a dozen variants, all signs that that I'm about to read the thoughts — to stretch the term — of some sneering anti-Semite who feels compelled to weigh in on today's topic.
Or not read them.Why bother? Racism, remember, is a form of ignorance —you're not perceiving the world as it is, but through the crazy kaleidoscope lens of your own obsessive fears. Who cares what dumb haters think? And the funny thing is, egotism is such an intrinsic part of being a bigot, the thought they're disregarded as beneath contempt doesn't occur to them. I have people gibbering in my Spam folder, ignored, for years.
But the Republican presidential candidate cannot be dismissed so easily. Even though none of this is news. Ever since he came down that brass escalator in the garish lobby of Trump Tower on June 16, 2015 and started slurring Mexicans as criminals and rapists, he's been the pied piper for the lowest sub-hell of the American psyche: racism, sexism, xenophobia, nationalism, religious bigotry.
Nearly a decade. No wonder we're all loopy. No wonder Joe Biden bowing out of the race brought an explosion of joy, optimism and energy. Hope dawned. Maybe we can finally break the spell.
This has been a particularly exuberant week, since Harris announced her running mate is Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz.
Walz wasn't on my radar. My personal favorite was secretary of transportation Pete Buttigieg, the sharpest razor wit in politics. The prospect of watching him vivisect Trump and Vance for the next three months was delicious to contemplate.
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro was my second choice. He's also a guy who can deliver a verbal broadside, and could be expected to win his own battleground state. Plus he's Jewish — as with Sandy Koufax, you like to see your guy on the mound, striking 'em out.
Both men had drawbacks. Buttigieg is gay, so picking him would churn the Republican waters — not that they wouldn't churn anyway — plus give pause to some Democrats who harbor anti-gay bias. Sure, it would be cool to have a gay vice-president — a sign that maybe our country isn't really a nest of hidebound religious loons who live their lives in a sex panic frenzy. But prejudice isn't something people gladly admit to pollsters, and you'd hate to bet our democracy on just how progressive people are in their secret hearts, then wake up Nov. 6 and find out you were wrong.
Shapiro being Jewish, while catnip to Jews, would have been a drawback last year, but since Oct. 7 has become an anchor, as the outrage of Palestinians — and their undergraduate allies —over the Israel-Hamas War tends to drift from Israelis to Zionists to Jews in general. And Shapiro is no random member of the Tribe, but as governor shut down campus protest in a way that Palestinian activists didn't like.
“Somebody like Shapiro would be an absolute disaster since he essentially has made it seem as if the Palestinians don’t have any rights to freedom or self-determination or anything,” said Hatem Abudayyeh, national chair of the U.S. Palestinian Community Network, while Harris was still pondering her choice.
Some Jews chose to register displeasure at Shapiro being passed over. Me, I understand that the goal here is to win, and if Harris-Walz has a slightly better chance at victory than Harris-Shapiro, then Harris-Walz it is. Would you rather lose with your guy, or win with somebody else? We can work at perfecting American society afterward.
That's called strategic thinking. The idea that people unhappy with some current administration policy are going to withhold their support, or back the guy who would be much, much worse, is cutting off your nose to spite your face. Maybe Jews are unduly attached to our often considerable noses. But doing that just isn't smart.
Excellent!
ReplyDeleteSpot on!! Thank you Neil!
ReplyDelete"Hatem", an appropriate name for a Jew hating Arab!
ReplyDeleteNice catch, dude. Hatem while ya got 'em! Although, as fellow members of the Tribe (no...not THAT Tribe...not the one from Cleveland), we both know it's "Ha-TEM." Or at least, one of us did.
Delete👍
ReplyDeleteLove your adjectives!
ReplyDeleteThank you X 100
ReplyDeleteIt's sad that this is where we are now...the bottom line we have to win this and I believe we will. That there are now GOP groups supporting K and T gives me great hope, even tho they are doing it for their own political benefit. Enough already!
ReplyDeleteExactly
ReplyDeleteI've said many times, regarding elections, that there is no room for wish-fulfillment or fantasy.
ReplyDeleteLose and "the other guys" are making and implementing policy.
The object of the game is to win.
Exactly right Neil! That the Sun-Times needs to water down the danger our country is in because of the rantings of that narcissistic Nimrod is why do many don't seem to recognize it.
ReplyDeleteAnd of course now the media .. Media ... is all in a blather "investigating" the ridiculous and spurious accusations of stolen valor against Walz. Desperation to find anything negative about the man.
ReplyDeleteWhat did I miss? Three days without power (twisters in NE Ahia) will do that.
DeleteStolen valor? Like pretending to be a combat vet, or what? My wife's first husband was such a masterful (and compulsive) liar that he managed to fool even Vietnam vets into buying his stories about being a Green Beret. My wife's ex never served a day. .
Why do I often think your blog articulates my thoughts exactly, if only I were bright and clever enough to be aware of them consciously? Who thought there was anything about Walz or Walz-Shapiro left unsaid these last few days? BRAVO!
ReplyDeleteI am also a big Pete B. fan. He is always the smartest person in the room (not that that’s always a political advantage). But his highest elective office so far is mayor of a medium sized city. Hopefully he will figure his way into a couple of terms in the Senate, and then I think he’s prime candidate material.
ReplyDeleteThen? In 2036? That's a long time to wait, and to waste the talents of a guy like Pete. Mr. Tangerine Man was never the mayor of anywhere, or elected to any office, or even served a single a day in uniform (Military school doesn't mean jack, Jack).
DeleteButtigieg has more brains and talent in his tushy than the Orange Guy has in his whole body. I like him. And I can spell his name without looking it up.
I’m personally relieved that Josh wasn’t selected. We already have enough overt anti-semitism in this country. And Tim Walz is really energizing the young, progressive activists to get their generation out to vote! Apathy was our biggest hurdle and that is basically gone now! #LFG
ReplyDeleteApathy is not gone. It's a big part of the problem. Every election we need to get out the vote and get out and vote. Not think that that problem is basically gone. Mail-in ballots will be arriving soon sometime in the middle of September from what I understand. So if you want one there might still be time to get one a very important election
DeleteI read both versions and could find two. Maybe three sentences that were changed. Why I could only dream? Do they have lawyers as copy editors now? It just seems so ridiculous what it is like. Kids recently graduated from school that are doing this work jeopardizing they're not-for-profit status. I have looked around to see how many organizations have actually lost it because of political activity. Very very rare. Very rare. Almost never happens. I'm sorry for you Neil that you have to deal with this crap in your golden years
DeleteLet the chumps at the Sun Times know this "watering down" that you speak of will not get them my clicks. Or my money.
ReplyDelete(Always happy to see your column on page 2 of the Sun-Times.)
ReplyDeleteStrategic thinking indeed.
Love this and your elegance with your artistic word arrangements that dance off the page — the pied piper for the lowest sub-hell of the American psyche:
ReplyDeleteThis was excellent. Also I want to say that I wish there was a way to Like comments on EGDD. Many times others have the perfect comment and I’d like to show my agreement or support.
ReplyDeleteMr. S posts links to EGD on Farcebook, every goddamn day. You can like comments there, if you're so inclined. But it also means being on Fakebook.
DeletePerfect summary! Thanks-makes my day.
ReplyDeletePerfect-makes my day-sorry I often mess up this part.
ReplyDeleteThe demeaning name-calling has always reminded me of a schoolyard bully, but may also serve to cover his speech/ articulation deficiencies, which are worsening. We've come a long way from covfefe. Now Trump bloviates nonsense and claims to mangle word deliberately because it riles the opposition. He engages in a verbal form of legerdemain, thereby 'controlling' the focus of attention and the conversation.
ReplyDeleteIn most cases, it would be better to not react, or point out the growing evidence of his cognitive decline, then redirect back to whatever he's trying to deflect away from.
But I agree with you that this particular name-mangling is racist, and should be challenged as such. When I heard it, my first association was to the song "kumbaya" , an old spiritual sung by slaves, and it made me angry.
I look forward to reading your perspective on the election throughout the coming months, in the paper and on this blog. Thank you.
Why has the mainstream media been so reluctant to call out the sheer lunacy of Trump? Is it too much to ask for that Peter Finch Network/Will Truman Newsroom/Aaron Sorkin West Wing moment of lucid honesty about Trump, in real time and out loud and on purpose? Why is Trump treated like some minor irritant like an uncle with bad table manners or an old farting dog, embarrassing but good for a chuckle? The man is evil, venal, lazy, greedy, selfish, vain, and ignorant. Yet despite constantly showing everyone how horrible he is; despite the indictments, trials, and convictions; despite January 6 and all of his treasonous and fascist acts, the media still politely sticks microphones into his face, knowing exactly how bad he is, and gives him a platform. Ignore him, exile him and end his hold over the Republic party and his pitiful misguided, brainwashed followers. We have work to do and lives to lead.
ReplyDelete