Tuesday, January 7, 2025

"A sense of closeness and carefree happiness"



     Monday's column on media maven Robert Feder — the man who urged me to join Twitter a decade and a half ago — getting tossed off Facebook drew a lot of response. One anonymous comment stood out:
     "Having noticed Facebook's sharp decline over the last few years, I think they're just making sure actual human-created content doesn't get in the way of the AI-generated pink slime that clutters the platform now."
      I've noticed that myself. We are always being told how AI is getting better and better. But most of what I read from it is near gibberish, like the above, recently plucked off Facebook. 
     I can't be sure it was produced by AI — it could, I suppose, been written by someone in some unimaginable basement boiler room in Mumbai, grabbing historical photos and slapping blocks of words under them.
     But it has the wordy obliviousness of AI. The suggestion that the photo "exudes a nostalgic allure" not only uses four words where one would do ("nostalgic") but it almost entirely wrong. That description might make sense to a machine or harried sweatshop habitue. But the photo is obviously a piece of 1920s cheesecake. Which becomes clear, if it isn't already, when you consider the woman's bare arms, stockinged leg and — most significantly — the man's right hand planted on her ass.
      Yes, I realize that pooh-poohing AI has become the go-to move for me, and I imagine I'll be doing it until the day the Sun-Times quietly lets me go and substitutes an AI-generated version of my column, dubbed "Ne*l Ste*nberg" or some other barely legal expropriation.
     Kidding. They'd never go to the effort. 
When I'm gone, the newshole will just close around me, like the surface of a pond after a stone has been thrown in, as if I were never there. 

28 comments:

  1. Great last line. Probably applies to most of us - I know it does to me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gotta luv the high heeled shoes:-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Not only that. She's wearing a pair of high heeled shoes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm pretty sure they'll replace you with Nail Stainberg. I mean... for god's sake he's got two AIs in his name!

    ReplyDelete
  5. id say they just went or are about to take a roll in the hay.
    I agree the captioning/ narrative sounds like ai. sadly so many humans , myself included write so poorly its hard to tell what's ai.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Neil, you make such a lasting impression every day with not only your writing, but the topics and insights you share. Would you ever consider a monthly breakfast meeting in a public restaurant for you and your readers to get together over breakfast for conversation and a sense of community? I would be happy to volunteer to organize such an ongoing event.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sounds fun, though I imagine it would just be the two of us. See what you could do — maybe at Georgie V's? They do a good omelet.

      Delete
    2. If I were still living in Chicago, I'd be there. Do they do Western omelets?

      Delete
    3. The Blossom Cafe in Norridge. Easy access for everyone!

      Delete
    4. Biscuits and gravy?

      Delete
    5. I'd certainly try to come. Georgie V looks good. (Is the "V" pronounced "sank"?)

      Delete
    6. By last count, it would be 4 (Dianne, you, Rick and pgw). Make that 5. I wouldn't want to miss a moment of the "insights" you would divulge. Too bad Grizz can't be there, I'd like to hear what he as to say when you finish. Most of all, I hope Mrs. S. will also come to keep everyone in line. She would probably be the only sane person at the table. I'm submitting my RSVP in advance, hoping Dianne makes this happen.

      Delete
    7. That would be a hard "no" on the Mrs. She likes her privacy.

      Delete
    8. Well Neil, you just supported my argument about sanity. You are so lucky to have her as a guard rail against all of us crazies who follow you EGD. :-)

      Delete
    9. This is not to downplay the suggestion of a restaurant get-together, which I'm sure many would enjoy. A simpler additonal or alternative idea, however, might be a reprise of the EGD party that you held way back in the early days of the blog. Perhaps it was the first anniversary, or on the occasion of some milestone number of hits achieved -- I don't remember exactly.

      Anyway, IIRC, you just said "I'll be around at 7:00 p.m." or whatever, and I think anybody who wanted to just showed up on the website and exchanged comments (unrelated to a post) in the regular fashion, but in real time.

      Not nearly as personal, obviously, but it certainly made it easy for folks far and wide to participate, if they cared to. It was fun and I kinda wondered why you never did it again, since it seemed to be relatively successful. Just thought I'd mention it.

      Delete
    10. If this breakfast is going to come about, I would love to attend also. I've thought about suggesting something similar for some time, and am very happy that someone has now floated the idea in public.

      Delete
  7. "AI-generated pink slime" indeed. People keep sharing terrible AI stories and photos about the U.P. Glad you're here for now at least.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yeah, they aren’t trying to sell bicycles.
    Is that a Lou’s Za? Looks amazing,

    ReplyDelete
  9. The thing that jumps out to me as absolutely ridiculous is the high heels. I don't know anyone who could ride a bicycle in high heels. I learned a harsh lesson when I was a child and rode my bike barefoot. Did it for a long time...until...one day I was pedaling fast & off slipped my foot & into the front spokes my Big toe went. Next stop: Emergency Room!

    ReplyDelete
  10. AI text is characterized by excessive wordiness and over-long descriptions that are used in order to persuade you to participate. Especially at trolling and phishing sites that are only out to scam you.

    And yet, countless people will wade through all that verbiage, and respond to all that befuddling bamboozlement, as though they were answering a human being.

    This is the mantra for AI-generated text, sometimes attributed to W.C. Fields:
    If you can't blow them away with your brilliance, then baffle them with your bullshit.

    ReplyDelete
  11. A stronger argument against the Sun-Times canning Neil Steinberg and substituting some AI generated Steinbergish columns might be the legal force (3 lawyers in the immediate family) instantly available to entangle the paper in tiresome and expensive litigation. But Mike Royko's family could be a different story, especially given the popularity of Sun-Times' reruns of Royko's old columns. Ah, what a dubious future we can expect from the techno creations sure to inundate our social and antisocial media.

    john

    ReplyDelete
  12. The process of elimination tells me the hero picture is of Burt's pizza. I don't recognize it, and I'm sure I've been to everyplace deep dish pizza joint except Burt's. It does look amazing, and I'd bet it's as good as it looks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Burt's it is. Ne plus ultra. The photo is a non-sequitur — I couldn't think of what else ot use.

      Delete
  13. I would love to attend the breakfast. I've always enjoyed your columns, books, and now EGD.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.