Sunday, June 8, 2025

Circuses and more circuses

 


     Do adults really claw at each other the way man-babies Donald Trump and Elon Musk were carrying on this past week?
     Trump claims to value loyalty, yet hits his straying best bro with both barrels at the first criticism ("What are you saying, Neil, that Donald Trump is a hypocrite?!?! Bwa, hahahaha.")     
     No restraint, God knows no kindness or humor. It's all zero or one, friend or foe, kiss or kill. 
     How petty. I've trained myself to meet scorn with silence. What's the point? Why would you, for instance, call someone "an idiot?" Because if you truly felt that way, you'd be trying to score a point against, well, an idiot. Where's the honor in that?
    Then again, thinking things through is not a value in TrumpWorld.
    Occasionally I will reply to a particularly venomous remark with "The scorn of traitors is praise to a patriot." But even as I do it, I'm aware I'm wasting my time. The eagle does not chase flies.
   And those are strangers. Fallen friends ... well, first, I tend to like everyone I've ever liked, and when a friend does me wrong, I might upbraid them, privately. But then I try to make amends. Pour oil on the waters. There is a joy in that — another reason Trump and his camp, while continually jubilant, in the manner of bullies, are never joyful.
     Or as I sometimes put it:
     "Save feuds for 7th grade."
     If that doesn't work, let them go. Put them on the train to Siberia, emotionally. And even then I always leave the door open. I remember cutting through Grand Central Station in New York City and bumping into a former editor I was once close to. We had parted on bad terms — he messed up something in one of my books through carelessness and neglect. I'd chastised him about it, and he, rather than being sorry, merely harrumphed off. That was it. Over. Done.     
     In the train station, I was instantly excited to see him — My old friend! Had we not gone to baseball games together, at Yankee Stadium and Wrigley Field? Had he not stayed at my apartment, and we shot pool and drank bourbon? Exchanging confidences about how he'd conquer publishing while I pursued the will-o-wisp of literature. 
     His cool reaction surprised me. Oh, right, we aren't friends anymore. Just people who used to be friends. I didn't call him names — though I cherished people who did. "He's just an asshole," a mutual colleague explained, meaning: He can't be fixed. I try to accept that.
     Sniping would be useless. As arresting a spectacle as the richest man in the world and the most mendacious locked in a catfight. A shitshow, two apes flinging feces at each other. 
      I couldn't take much joy in it. Musk has too much money to truly fail. And Trump, a serial fraud, will simply sell the United States to someone else, maybe even at a greater bargain than Musk got — access to the length and. breadth of our government for $288 million, less than $1 per citizen whose lives and information were placed into his greedy little hands.
     Or more likely, a series of someones. We are seeing, boldly, in broad daylight and without shame, the largest explosion of corruption ever seen in this country. So enormous a shift that even the concepts of graft, bribery, simony, and self-dealing have been suspended, for Republicans anyway. The concepts no longer exist, except as more meaningless slurs to hurl at enemies, and of course the justification for their own crimes. Trump could sell the Statue of Liberty to Qatar and half the country would sing the sheikdom's praise for letting us keep it.    
     Sure, a popular vote in November, 2026 could sweep this away. But by then the machinery of fascism will be well in place, assuming it isn't already firmly situated now. Not just in law enforcement, the military the media, Congress and the courts,, but in the public mind. They believe what they are told.    
     Here is an unedited email I received Friday from reader Tony Z. It wasn't a mass mailing, but sent to me individually. Try to read it to the end:
     Democrats Sacrifice American Citizens Lives for Criminal Illegal Aliens! Democrats Sacrifice Homeless American Veterans to give Free Five Star Hotel Rooms to Criminal Illegal Aliens! While Homeless Veterans who Fought for this Country live on the streets! Democrats Sacrifice Girls and Women by Allowing Men to compete in Girls and Women’s Sports! Democrats Sacrifice Children by Not only Allowing but Promoting Child Mutilation! Democrats Sacrifice Innocent Babies by Not only Allowing but Promoting the Slaughtering of Innocent Babies Any Reason Any Time! Democrats Sacrifice American Lives by Hiring DEI Pilots, Doctors,etc. Democrats are on the Wrong Side of Every Issue!
      That's the altar on which American democracy will be sacrificed. Ignorant sheep, their walnut brains jammed with rote Fox News talking points. As easy, and roughly accurate as it is to blame Trump, never forget he is a symptom, not a cause. Trump triumphs because he gives the people what they want: a circus. Remember my hero Juvenal's line about the secret to winning the hearts of the masses: panem et circenses "bread and circuses." 
     Perhaps we should read that famous phrase in context, in Juvenal's 10th Satire:
... Already long ago, from when we sold our vote to no man. The People have abdicated our duties; for the People who once upon a time handed out military command, high civil office, legions — everything, now restrains itself and anxiously hopes for just two things: bread and circuses.

    Now that I read that again, I realize we are in some ways worse than ancient Romans. They had a reasonable expectation that their government would give them bread. Here, we settle for circenses et circenses — circuses and circuses.


 


17 comments:

  1. Well, Tony Z. when Biden and Obama were presidents I slept well, not expecting children would be handcuffed and hauled off by cowards wearing masks. Citizens weren't tear gassed and flash bombed for protesting. I know, I'm wasting my time. You are no longer reachable. Look around you, Tony Z. Is this the America you wish for? I'll save the cuss words for my blog.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So there was an article in The Guardian recently that perfectly captured our sorry state of affairs here in the former United States of America. It seems we are experiencing hypernormalization; the juxtaposition of the dysfunctional and the mundane. Governing systems and institutions are broken and for reasons including lack of effective leadership and an inability to imagine how to disrupt the status quo, we carry on with our lives as normal. Give or take a heavy load of fear, dread, denial and dissociation. Fun times.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It happened here, abd they said it couldn't. Wrong-o. Trying to determine the point that toppled us over the tip. Was it the confirmation of Clarence Thomas, Newt Gingrich, Citizens United?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those and more.

      And it's not as though the danger had never existed. Dcades ago, the late Sydney J. Harris opined on the issue, seeing that the US was in far more danger from, as he phrased it, the bund rather than the cell.

      Archibald Macleish as well, when in a brilliant Atlantic piece titled "The Conquest of America" he diagnosed our setting ourselves up as the automatic counter-Russia, seeing that when an external antagonist was removed/diminished, we'd turn on each other.

      Walt Kelley, though, had it best, when, draped across a Saigon bar, his "We have met the enemy and they is us!" was first uttered - as outlined in John Laurence's The Cat From Hue.

      Delete
  4. Ok, I'll be your editor. "no longer not exist" sentence? Because you care about right and true. Unlike the Right.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. See, this is the problem with ignoring anonymous remarks — this unknown person flagged a typo, which I immediately fixed. Not posting it would obscure my debt to readers to help me look like a better writer than I actually am.

      Delete
  5. There's enough cognitive dissonance here for generations of scholars--if we're lucky--to unpact, but the one that most often makes me shake my head in the insistence that government and the military were full of "DEI hires" who need to be fired or scrapped from the history books, but meanwhile, he's hiring a literal 22 year old to be in charge of national security, a FEMA head who didn't know we have a hurricane season, etc, etc, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You are right about not arguing with an idiot or even calling an idiot, well, an idiot. But sometimes you just gotta do what you gotta do. Or explode.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Trump is not America, although his sway over the government and media is extremely terrifying. Barely 50 % of actual voters voted for him - and there are serious questions about the legitimacy of those numbers. Trump does not gave a mandate - at least 30% of Americans did not bother to vote. Trump's actual percentage is closer to a third of Americans - still far too much for any sane nation - and dropping. Yet here we are, a new horror every day, fascism rising like a flooded basement, and few plumbers in sight. So much for majority rule...doesnt matter if the majority is silent.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I didn't enjoy the snipe fight either. Another predictable distraction from Trump's massive corruption. I'm not sure that he's a hypocrite, he's doing what he said he would. Any sentient person knew he would rob the place blind. I was holding on to a small hope that he'd grab as much as he could and leave the rest intact. But he's a burglar who trashes the place, to insult and intimidate, while taking the loot.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Why the mass capitalizations? All caps, all the time.
    Are they all really as stupid as Felonious? Apparently so.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Note to commenters whose remarks are not being posted: When one group supports democracy, and another is in the process of tearing down democracy to install a lawless totalitarian dictatorship, that is not a "disagreement." Those rolling like puppies at the feet of a liar, bully, fraud and traitor are not offering contrary opinions. They're dupes in thrall to a fraud. If you don't like that perspective, you are welcome to avail yourselves to Fox News, NewsMax, and the other sources of all their opinions and worldview. If you don't like my peaches, don't shake my tree.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for filtering out the garbage. I'll bet a lot of the comments make Tony Z's sound like a thoughtful perspective! Good point on what Musk got for his $288 million.

      Delete
  11. But it feels so good to call the fools names.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Driving home on what should be a beautiful day except for being trapped in a face mask thanks to virus after virus spreading through our community, in a car where the windows must remain up because of wildfire smoke and air pollution, reckless and hotdog drivers all around me disregarding public and personal safety. Just like the national political stage.
    Home. Our windows remain closed while our neighbors ignore AQ warnings like they ignore NOOA cautions of another anticipated damaging storm ... Their "nothing's going to happen" or "hope it will miss us", faux concern if it wreaks havoc to a city or county away as long as it doesn't interfere with their plans.
    I guess gramps was right. Life is political.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor. Only comments using a name of some sort will be considered.