Saturday, July 26, 2025

Demolished house


      The house was small. And white. On Catherine Street, two blocks from my own. With black shutters that never closed once — decorative. Grasping, along with the coach lights, toward some whiff of colonial splendor that almost seems a joke when you think about it. A symbolic white handkerchief of elegance in a neighborhood where people build gigantic faux farmhouses. Where some build enormous homes, live in them a bit, then, decide these estates just aren't big enough, buy the lot next door and double the size of their already huge house into some kind of super huge house.     
     I've thought of knocking on the door and demanding a tour — "What do you do with all that room?" A bad idea, at houses where I've literally never seen a person outside, coming or going. Not in years.
     But that wouldn't go over well. Not my place, literally or figuratively, not as a local dog walker and humble senior citizen, newly enrolled in Medicare. With a half price Metra pass freshly installed in my wallet, awaiting its first use. 
     The chain link fence went up weeks ago,. Maybe months. Then last week, the Caterpillar excavator arrived, signalling the brink of doom for the old home. I tried to imagine the years of life unfolding there, the new couples arriving, the babies squirming, the children running around. The gradual deprecations of time, ignored as always. Or as Mary Oliver writes:
We did not hear, beneath our lives,
The old walls falling out of true,
Foundations shifting in the dark.
When seedlings blossomed in the eaves,
When branches scratched upon the door
And rain came splashing through the halls,
We made our minor, brief repairs,
And sang upon the crumbling stairs
And danced upon the sodden floors.  
     A vague and haunting image of happy life when it is past. Though honestly, I failed completely, conjuring up the lives unfolding here. Hard to imagine the life of someone you know, a person standing in front of you. Hard enough to remember your own, sometimes. Doing so from the architecture of a house about to be torn down is impossible. At least for me.
     The house is ... what? 1930s? That would be my guess, but I'm not knowledgable about such things and invite correction.  Colonial revival was a style throughout much of the 20th century — some 40 percent of American homes built in the 1920s reflected it. 
     I didn't dwell on the house being pulled down, which couldn't take an hour. There's enough cause for melancholy in my own life without channeling anybody else's. Two days later, when I passed again, the house was rubble, the bricks already palleted up — old bricks are a hot commodity. Apparently, we just can't make them like we used to. Something about the minerals in the clay. Or maybe we could, but don't bother. The current not-quite-so-nice bricks are good enough.
      Someday soon my wife and I will stroll by this empty lot, and she'll say, "I don't remember what was there." And at least now I'll say, "I have a picture, if you're really interested."
    The Oliver poem ends this way:
For years we lived at peace, until
The rooms themselves began to blend
With time, and empty one by one,
At which we knew, with muted hearts,
That nothing further could be done,
And so rose up, and went away,
Inheritors of breath and love,
Bound to that final black estate
No child can mend or trade away.



27 comments:

  1. I think it is very unhealthy to obsess on “not enough”. I truly believe that the sign of a rich man is not he who has the most, but rather he who needs the least.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Of course you are exactly right. Knowing you “have enough” is important. “Doing enough” might be more important.

      Delete
    2. There was that yuppie snark in the Eighties: "He who dies with the most toys wins." What do they actually win? A life full of toys...but that life is over. They're still dead.

      Delete
  2. My Aunt died a year ago and she had lived in the house her father, my grandfather built. I was small by today’s expectations, solid in its construction. It was bought by a developer to be torn down and one of the demolition workers there when it was happening when I told him it was 100 years old and my aunt lived there all her life. He said “lots of memories in that house but that’s that”. I have thought about his words a lot and had first been shocked at the indifference but as time wore on I appreciate them. It is the memories. I took lots of pictures of the inside and have them as memory enhancers for later.

    ReplyDelete
  3. That's sad. I wish permitting were more strict, preventing god-awful, hulking houses being built alongside the "normal" homes in a community. What do they need with all that space, indeed? I've long said I want to see a "House Hunters"-type show but with a real estate agent who's also a psychologist. "I want a big house with a huge foyer so people are impressed when they come over!" "OK, but *why do you want that?" Let's find out what they're masking with all that square footage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those "hulking houses" have been replacing the postwar ranches in Skokie for years. It's jarring to come back to my old stomping grounds and see those monstrosities. The same thing happened in Linden Hills, the lakeside Minneapolis neighborhood where my kid sister has lived for forty years. Many of the houses being replaced were originally summer cottages near a streetcar line, when the area was still an early 20th-century summer resort.

      But then they even started tearing down and replacing the classic Craftsman houses from the 1920s,. My sister lives in one. Masterpieces built by skilled woodworkers, and designed to last a century. Which they have.Those gems with their overhanging eaves:, the earth-toned stucco exteriors, the lovely front porches, and especially the handcrafted details...the nooks, the fireplaces, the window seats. And so much more.

      I have NEVER understood why people...especially younger families, need all that SPACE. The huge square footage, the high ceilings, the atriums, the foyers. What the hell for? True, some are pack rats, who acquire so much "stuff" that they keep the storage-unit industry alive and thriving

      .But so many more are minimalists, and those houses feel half-empty...or more like art galleries or museums. I've heard people bitch about having "only" 3,000 square feet. Our two-bedroom bungalow has less than 900 sf...and it works fine for us, and has for decades. Plus our museum of 20th-century pop culture...all those collectibles. To each his zone, I suppose. But it makes me wonder.

      Then there are the whole industries that urge you to replace your "dated" kitchen and bathroom. Why? If it's good enough to cook in, or to shower and shave and poop in, why is it suddenly unfashionable? If everything works, why replace it? So guests won't snicker and mock you? Shut up and take your whiz. And eat the dinner we made you in that tiny kitchen..

      The house Mister S is mourning for appears to be a pre-WWII bungalow...very similar to mine, which was built in 1941. My Cleveland neighborhood has whole blocks of them. They, too, were built by master craftsmen and master carpenters. The window trim, the built-in bookcases next to the fireplace, twin built-in china cabinets, the old paneled doors with glass doorknobs, archways, stucco ceilings. Keep your farshtunkener McMansion.

      Delete
  4. The McMansion style home you describe fits my brother and sister in laws house exactly. Big home on a active road. Four people live there. Looks immaculate. I drive by it on occasion and have never seen anyone outside.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Heartbreaking

    ReplyDelete
  6. I occasionally drive by my childhood home on Cambridge Lane in Lincolnshire. A surprising number of the original 1957 ranch homes built by Roger Ladd survive in 2025. (They were NOT terribly well constructed.) Ladd got it right when he chose to build around old growth trees and not simply clear away the lots. His twisty-turny streets fit the terrain. Dude was a smart cat. McMansions in Lincolnshire today? Oh yes, certainly. My old house has several monster neighbors. A fella I knew vaguely in grammar school in the 1960s has owned our old home since 1996. His childhood nick name was, in fact, Banana Head. I appreciate old Banana Head's efforts at preservation. The property is well kept up. So kudos Banana Head! And I was yet again heartened to note a new-build over on Wiltshire Drive that is sanely sized and gorgeous. Next door to the old Foss place. Kinda Mid Century Modern in style and fits the lot perfectly. There is hope.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have never heard that Mary Oliver poem, I think it’s perfect for your article today Mr. S. Tell me, how do you match up poems with your articles so well, what is your method or do you have them all in your grey cells at your disposal?
    You might not see anyone coming or going, but my husband and I sit every night out on our patio in the back yard and eat dinner and listen to the cicadas and watch the birds.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad to be the person to draw your attention to it, then. I was familiar with the poem from "Out of the Wreck I Rise," the book using literature as a guide to recovery. Originally, I wrote today's post first, and was looking for a phrase to use as a title: I thought the poem might contain some succinct thought that would work as a title. It actually didn't, but I thought the message itself might add a bit more meat to my own reflections.

      Delete
  8. I lived in Northbrook, by Westcott. We eventually modestly added a story to our ranch and then - the whole neighborhood exploded into mansions on their respective acres of land as elders move or passed on.
    Our old house still stands and sells, as we conceived it. But there are few people around in the neighborhood to be seen. Back when the kids were growing up, we knew and loved everyone. What do we live for anymore? I used to love living there and then, the older folks died and part of me went with ‘em I guess.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "What do we live for anymore?" That is the question, isn't it? I feel blessed to have a job, for now, and kids who want to see us, sometimes. Back when the blog first started, I printed up a poster whose slogan was: "The World Never Becomes Dull — We Do." I think that's something to bear in mind. The meaning is always out there. The trick is finding it.

      Delete
  9. Breaks my heart to see beautiful mid-century modern ranches in my Arlington Heights neighborhood torn down and huge, now dark gray/black colored two-story boxes put up in their place. Changes the whole look and feel of the block and the neighborhood.

    ReplyDelete
  10. So disturbing to me to see the saltbox homes torn down for two story mid modern colonial whatever with a tree car garage. Where are the folks who make your pizza, who do your dry cleaning, who work at the grocery store, who make your bacon and eggs going to live?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They all live in Highwood, just over the Northbrook border. What's been going up there is apartment buildings.

      Delete
  11. The house I grew up in is typical Chicago bungalow-still there and looks much the same. The house my Dad and family grew up in is in Lincoln Park -it was not that "Lincoln Park" but an Irish and Italian first generation 3 flat-still there a few years ago.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The house I grew up in was already old when we moved there in 1946 (I was one year old). A big old farmhouse, with a barn, on the outskirts of town. My first memory is of the barn going up in spectacular flames when I was three or four. There was a grand Italian marble fireplace and an orchard of apple and cherry trees. In 1961 my parents sold the house and we moved to a much nicer part of town. The house was turned into a plumbing shop and the orchard ripped out to put in a parking lot (shades of Joni Mitchell). I always wondered what happened to that fireplace and the surrounding real wood paneling. Even now, I can't bear the thought. I'm sure the house is gone, but the memories remain.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Got an oddball question for you / your readers…We’d lived briefly in a 100+ year old farmhouse in Libertyville. Had a resident ghost, if you believe in that type of thing. Went back a few years ago to watch it get torn down, to be replaced by a shiny faux farmhouse. Since then, I’ve wondered — did the ghosts get hauled away with all the rubble, or do they hang around and make themselves at home among all the new belongings? I’d like to drop by sometime and ask the new owners, but my wife insists they’d likely call the police and sic the dog on me. Whaddya think — would it be too weird, or should I inquire for the good of science and mankind?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Go for it! Prefix it with "I know this sounds a little weird, but I used to live in the house that was on this lot..."

      Delete
  14. I think they packed up and left. . The new house would be foreign to them.

    ReplyDelete
  15. In 1979, before we were married, my husband and I were looking for a home to purchase that was within our price range. We were lucky enough to find a small cottage in an unincorporated part of Glen Ellyn. It was on half an acre and butted up to the prairie path. The property was overgrown with random trees, weeds, bushes and basic overgrowth.... but it was beautiful! A little cottage in the woods.
    There were thirty-five homes in our little unincorporated area. Over the years, we had gotten to know our neighbors and their kids. It was a great neighborhood and everyone knew and looked out for each other's kids. Many block parties were held.
    We eventually added an additional seven-hundred square feet to our original seven-hundred square feet. It was a nice size for our small family.
    We are now the old folks in the neighborhood, having lived here for forty-six years. There was once a ten acre parcel owned by artists, that had been sold in recent years. The property now has million dollar homes on it. The two houses down the street have been purchased by builders and are now incorporated into Glen Ellyn. Five new houses will be built on these lots that once held two. A cute little bungalow across the street has been torn down and will be replaced by yet another parking lot for the private country club nearby. We tried to fight it, but, well, money seemed to win the day and it was approved by the zoning board.
    We still enjoy our little sanctuary of property, but we know in time, this will change as well. It's sad, but we were lucky.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for sharing the Mary Oliver poem.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Neil, this is a very nice column. The Mary Oliver poetry gives it the Neil Steinberg "more than just a column" touch that I appreciate. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Sending another Mary Oliver so the little white house can have a farewell spokesperson. https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mqr/2017/08/from-the-archive-on-losing-a-house-by-mary-oliver/ Thank you for your gentle postings this week. They help.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I miss the character of old houses. New construction feels sterile by comparison, regardless of size.
    A friend of mine lives in an older home in LaGrange. I was amazed to learn that her local library keeps account of all the houses in town. She was able to research her home and learn when permits were issued, and for what purpose, see all the sales details when the home changed hands, and even view photos of her house in earlier times. I have no idea how many libraries do this, but i love the idea.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I fish lakes in Southwest Michigan. These lakes have always been ringed with small cottages that were within the means of middle class people, They are disappearing now, torn down and replaced by mansions of the wealthy elite. Some are big enough to comfortably house 30 people but they are vacant most of the year because they are just “Summer houses”, whose owners only visit a few weekends a year.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor. Comments that are not submitted under a name of some sort run the risk of being deleted without being read.