Saturday, September 27, 2025

Flashback 2011: Enjoy a local bookstore while you can

Book Bin's old location on Church Street, 2016.

     "Moonstruck" is one of my favorite movies, despite a prominent role played by Nicholas Cage. It's so well-written, with many memorable lines that prove useful in regular life. "Your life is going down the toilet," alas, has been deployed more than once.
     And a useful edict that I considered just last week, while modulating my tone about the Charlie Kirk candlelight vigil — "Don't shit where you live." 
    With that in mind, I've never posted the pair of 2011 columns about my beloved local bookstore, "The Book Bin." Mainly because the second, which I'll post Sunday, caused the then owner to give me a stink eye whenever I walked in, making me feel even more unwelcome than I ordinarily do most places anyway.
     If you don't remember the 2011 columns, you can read this and try to imagine what sparked a firestorm of controversy and recrimination. You can wonder, but you won't hit on it because, to quote a truism not in "Moonstruck," you never see the bullet that hits you.

     Most books are published on Tuesdays, the day when what few bookstores remain put them out on sale, one of those quaint traditions of publishing about to vanish along with the stores themselves.
     Jackie Collins’ 27th novel, Goddess of Vengeance, was one of the books published last Tuesday, and on Wednesday, Dillon Perlow stopped by the Book Bin in my leafy suburban paradise of Northbrook to pick up the copy the store had tucked away for her.
     “A girl has to have a little light reading,” explained the Glenview woman. She also bought Linwood Barclay’s The Accident on the advice of Nancy Usiak, a Book Bin saleslady.
     As the two books were being rung up, the women talked about what they were reading.
     “I just finished Language of Flowers,” Perlow said.
     “I read Story of a Beautiful Girl,” Usiak replied. “I found it more impactful.”
     “I just loved that one,” Perlow agreed.
     An average day in the life of a small independent bookstore, one with a children’s section with toys in the back, a faux fireplace with comfortable chairs in the front, a store that has been in business for 40 years.
     Meanwhile, in the city, a better-known bookstore, Borders, was marking its 40th birthday, coincidentally, by going out of business. The last day of its last downtown Chicago location, on State Street, was Wednesday.
     “STORE CLOSING — EVERYTHING MUST GO — 90% OFF” read the stark red and yellow signs in the windows of Borders. Inside, the shelves were mostly stripped. The remaining books weren’t worth the match needed to burn them: Leadership and Crisis by Bobby Jindal. Sydney Omarr’s Astrological Guide for You in 2010 and How To Revive Capitalism and Put America Back on Top by Matthew Bishop and Michael Green.
     Bargain hunters milled around — there was always a crowd at Borders; it was, for those of us so inclined, the place to go, to stroll after dinner and, maybe, pick up a book.
     Obviously not an experience people valued enough, as consumers learned to prefer the undeniable Christmas morning joy of receiving another smiley face Amazon box.
     Borders was founded in 1971 in Ann Arbor, Mich., by brothers Tom and Louis Borders. Their chain steadily expanded until, at its peak, it had more than 500 stores.
      The Book Bin was founded in 1971 by Janis Irvine and her husband Lex.
     Irvine said someone approached her about opening a second store in the late 1970s, but she turned him down — with two stores, she reasoned, she’d always be in the back room, working, and wouldn’t be out front talking with customers about books, the part she loves.
     She has no joy seeing the giant crumble.
     “It really is not satisfying,” she said. “To see any bookstore close breaks my heart.”
     And Borders once was really something.
     “You had to take an examination [in literature] before you could become a salesperson at Borders,” she said. “They were terrific.”
     Large or small, each bookstore that closes, Irvine said, means one less place “where people can go in and exchange ideas and talk about books.”
     Perhaps the most incredible thing about the Book Bin is, though small, it is staffed by four saleswomen, plus a high school clerk.
     “We never sit around reading,” Irvine said, and indeed, as frequently as I stop by, the stock always seems to have changed — Wednesday the new Jackie Kennedy interview book was published, and three copies were already prominently displayed.
     Make no mistake. Books as tangible objects are doomed. In 2011, for the first time, sales of e-books surpassed sales of adult hardback books — Amazon delivers more e-books than paper books. That’ll never change.
     People like to save money, and to do so will ditch human interaction: first telephone operators, then gas station attendants, then bank tellers and now bookstore clerks.
     I try to focus on the advantages. As a guy who once lugged around bricks of Remembrance of Things Past, I appreciate the new technology. But oh those drawbacks: I never would have read Alfred Lansing’s gripping adventure Endurance if a young Adam Brent hadn’t pressed it upon me in his father’s bookstore on Michigan Avenue. Stuart Brent’s is long gone, as is Adam’s shop on Washington Street. Someday they’ll all be gone.
     But not yet. The Book Bin, for one, remains, at 1151 Church St., and on Thursday, it celebrates its 40th birthday from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m. Everything in the store during those hours will be an Amazon-like 40 percent off. There will also be wine and hors d’oeuvres — try getting someone to squirt that into a Kindle along with your e-book.
                — Originally published in the Sun-Times, Sept. 18, 2011

11 comments:

  1. Since Jeff Bezos became the Great Satan (or at least since it became clear to me that he was), I've bought all my books at the Book Bin. It's possible to order online. The BB will then notify me when my books are in, and I can simply swing by and pick them up. Not only that, but no book from the BB has ever been damaged, with a torn or bent cover. I can't say the same about Amazon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. there is no such thing as satan here on earth or anywhere else. the same fellow citizens that are responsible for trump being president made Bezos a billionaire.

      Americans dont seem all that great as it turns out. we just think we are.

      Delete
  2. There is always joy in venturing into a local book store, and I never leave without buying something (exhibit A is the stack of books next to the couch, waiting on a book shelf or on my bedtable), whether it is from my fabulous local Book Cellar (Lincoln Square) or a randomly run-across place as we travel. I am delighted that your 2011 prediction of the end of book stores was -- and is -- wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Did the trouble arise from "The remaining books weren’t worth the match needed to burn them"?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love bookstores both new and used . Recently completed the last of 20 bookcases we were contracted to build for Heirloom Books on Clark st.

    They are an all volunteer not for profit serving the community through scholarships and other programs. Great selection. Very inviting

    ReplyDelete
  5. Been gone from Evanston for over 30 years, but I lived there from 1975 to 1985, and again in the early 90s. And I have to admit that I just don't recall the Book Bin at all. Don't know how that's even possible. But it is what it is.

    Also grew up in Skokie, from '54 to '65. Buses and cars took me east on Church St. to places like Wieboldt's and Field's and the rest of downtown Evanston. Does that make me sound old? Guilty as charged. Google Earth just confirmed what I remember...Church St. has always been residential apartments, mostly high-rises, east of Ridge. Bottom line: 1151 Church does not sound right.

    My go-to bookstore was the Evanston branch of Kroch's, across from the Varsity theater and Field's. The mother of my kid sister's best friend was the manager. She reminded me that shoplifters were not only arrested and charged but also banned from the entire chain for life. A word to the wise, and all that. Her warnings did not go unheeded. Got my five-finger discounts elsewhere.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The column specified the store is in Northbrook, not Evanston.

      Delete
  6. I dont't understand people who choose only ebooks over hardbooks. To me, they must read throwaway easy reads or something only transitory, or they live backpack lives always in physical transition. And what happens when the power goes oit? Because it will, and thanks to continuous greed decisions driving everyone in power, for longer and longer times.
    And while I'm puzzling, how do people really save money when you learn the cost, the corporate underwriting-structure for the physical data centers (Hint: the billionaires are not paying) . The environmental damage needed for such power generateion will make us commoners' power unaffordable, rationed or non-existent.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I read books almost exclusively on my iPad. A power outage has never been lengthy enough to cause a problem, especially since I keep a power bank handy in case the battery is depleted. I read many different kinds of books, some “throwaway“ (I prefer to consider them light reads), some literary fiction, some non-fiction. I recently finished Ron Chernow’s Mark Twain biography and am currently reading The Demons of Unrest by Erik Larson.

      Both my husband and I are avid readers. I made the transition to ebooks years ago because he reads only physical books, and buys them, so our shelves are full. I save money because I borrow 95% of what I read from the library.

      Ebooks have some advantages over traditional ones, and not just the space and weight differences. I can press on an unfamiliar word and instantly get a definition. If I’ve forgotten who a character is, I can do a quick search to the other places in the book they’ve appeared.

      What I don’t understand is people who assume choices other than their own are inferior, rather than just different.

      Delete
  7. I have always been a slow reader, but as an art student I often scoured the tables and bookracks in the art and art history section of Kroch's & Brentano's on Wabash Ave. That became a routine hangout for me because of Henry Tabor, a jovial know-it-all who was the department manager. Never shy about expressing his opinion or sharing his vast knowledge, his passion for art oozed out of him like paint from a tube of cobalt blue or cadmium red onto a rainbow palette. All these years later, I remember him for his generous time, stimulating my curiosity, and inspiring me to love books. Those encounters with Henry still motivate me and resulted in a library that has served me well for over 60 years, something that would be almost impossible today.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor. Comments that are not submitted under a name of some sort run the risk of being deleted without being read.