Usually, alas, it's the latter.
Take the meme to the right. What they're saying is, here is this 1967 medal, showing a plane flying into the Twin Towers. They knew 34 years ahead of time. It's all preordained, part of a long term Jewish plot.
Now look closely at the medal, and the supposed World Trade Center. See the little nubs on top? See the writing? It's clearly a torah. You don't have to be a genius to figure that out. All you have to do is look closely.
Take the meme to the right. What they're saying is, here is this 1967 medal, showing a plane flying into the Twin Towers. They knew 34 years ahead of time. It's all preordained, part of a long term Jewish plot.
Now look closely at the medal, and the supposed World Trade Center. See the little nubs on top? See the writing? It's clearly a torah. You don't have to be a genius to figure that out. All you have to do is look closely.
It's the same mistake of those who see an oblong object in somebody's hands in a photo from the 1920s and declares that it's a cell phone and time travel exists. Can people be so dumb? Again, alas, yes.
This is not news. So why am I writing about this?
Good question. I guess Saturday was busy — working on Monday's column (AND Wednesday's column. AND preparing a string of posts to run after some upcoming surgery. AND working on the book — news about that this week. And visiting the Lincoln Park Zoo. And dinner on Wells Street, at Topo Gigio).
So I needed to write about something. And this meme...
I write about what interests me. Mostly. Sometimes I write about something suggested by an editor, or a reader, but I suppose that's still about something I find interesting, with a helping hand.
Occasionally that thing that caught my fancy will resonate with readers — such as the column on Indiana Fever star Sophie Cunningham, which pinballed across the country — so much so that an editor mentioned it to me, which seldom happens. But I knew I'd grabbed the brass ring, after John Williams asked me to talk about it with him on WGN. To me, that means I've snatched the brass ring.
During our conversation, I said something to the effect that, if I made a practice of writing about stupid stuff found online, it's all I'd ever do. That's true. Low-hanging fruit. A duck in a bucket. Too easy. And too common. All the deniers and misunderstanders and toxic haters and glint eyed fanatics pushing every subject through the keyhole of their fixations. It's endless.
However, sometimes something is just, well, too good to pass up. Like this meme.
A reminder that conspiracy theories are history for stupid people. They prefer airy fictions to actual facts, I suppose, because the latter require thought, and reading, and a base of knowledge, while the former you can grab one fact — or, in this case, one mis-perception — and run with it.
When I look through Instagram (I don't do TikTok or Threads. Instagram is plenty) and consider how much political opinion is formed by this process, and how little is formed by essays such as this one, well, the temptation is to abandon all hope. But that doesn't strike me as a success strategy either.
Good question. I guess Saturday was busy — working on Monday's column (AND Wednesday's column. AND preparing a string of posts to run after some upcoming surgery. AND working on the book — news about that this week. And visiting the Lincoln Park Zoo. And dinner on Wells Street, at Topo Gigio).
So I needed to write about something. And this meme...
I write about what interests me. Mostly. Sometimes I write about something suggested by an editor, or a reader, but I suppose that's still about something I find interesting, with a helping hand.
Occasionally that thing that caught my fancy will resonate with readers — such as the column on Indiana Fever star Sophie Cunningham, which pinballed across the country — so much so that an editor mentioned it to me, which seldom happens. But I knew I'd grabbed the brass ring, after John Williams asked me to talk about it with him on WGN. To me, that means I've snatched the brass ring.
During our conversation, I said something to the effect that, if I made a practice of writing about stupid stuff found online, it's all I'd ever do. That's true. Low-hanging fruit. A duck in a bucket. Too easy. And too common. All the deniers and misunderstanders and toxic haters and glint eyed fanatics pushing every subject through the keyhole of their fixations. It's endless.
However, sometimes something is just, well, too good to pass up. Like this meme.
A reminder that conspiracy theories are history for stupid people. They prefer airy fictions to actual facts, I suppose, because the latter require thought, and reading, and a base of knowledge, while the former you can grab one fact — or, in this case, one mis-perception — and run with it.
When I look through Instagram (I don't do TikTok or Threads. Instagram is plenty) and consider how much political opinion is formed by this process, and how little is formed by essays such as this one, well, the temptation is to abandon all hope. But that doesn't strike me as a success strategy either.
"Conspiracy theories are history for stupid people." I like that.
ReplyDeleteSorry to hear about the surgery in your future.
Just keep writing Neil -- you give me hope!
ReplyDeleteDon't forget all the nuts who insist there is a conspiracy to cover up that the US Government is hiding the evidence of UFO's from outer space that are piloted by aliens & that we have aliens either in custody or their bodies.
ReplyDeleteThey refuse to believe that the great distances make it impossible to come here or the facts that there have been hundreds of thousands of people could actually keep this a secret.
Even more idiotic is the fact, why would we be spending billions on new jet aircraft, if we had that amazing technology!
To me the proof of no UFO’s is reductio ad absurdum. The fact that there are a billion or more cell phones and yet no increase in UFO sightings.
DeleteMaybe stricter immigration enforcement is keeping aliens away? Hmm
Delete
ReplyDeleteMaybe it's not that people are simply stupid but they are frightened and have a lack of agency. The general population is provided with a lot of false information as well as information that is withheld leading to:
Thirty shades of truth: conspiracy theories as stories of individuation, not of pathological delusion - PMC https://share.google/JHkKVrvei8cbPgTy
That link gives an error page.
DeleteThat's silly Franco. For instance, the truth about Sept. 11 is plain. It takes true perversity to embrace malign explanations. They don't do so because of their lack of agency. They do so because they can't stand the conclusions. Alex Jones didn't say Sandy Hook was a faked because he lacks agency, but because he couldn't contemplate something that suggests guns should be more tightly controlled. Antisemites don't deny the Holocaust because they're fed false information, but because they embrace and seek it out, if not create it themselves. And you, well, I don't want to speculate what's driving you.
DeleteI appreciate your patience on this matter and I would just like to give you a little context.
DeleteMy 30-year-old son valedictorian of his high school went on to earn a master's degree in electromechanical engineering.
Pretty smart fella. Talks to me from time to time about various conspiracy theories.
911 being one of them. As you may imagine this causes me some concern he's never mentioned anything about the pictured coin.
His ideas seemed to come from a mistrust gosh of so many things.
This caused me to try to figure out why intelligent people not adults addled from drug addiction or alcohol or Fox News might give in to these theories or even embrace them
I noticed somebody said that that was an error page I doubt that you read any of it but it's just not because people are stupid like I said. The government has a history of withholding information and people feel like they don't have agency
I'm aware of some of the examples that you set above and honestly I don't know the truth about any of it I just know what I read just like you do and it's not that I don't agree with it it's just hard to know for sure what's accurate what the facts are in a lot of circumstances
I hope my son's okay like psychologically emotionally mentally because a lot of really smart people struggle with their mental health mental health is different from being stupid it's a lot different anyway I'm trying not to be silly or mean I'm just another guy trying to figure out what's going on in my life personally I don't really care so much about the big issues of the day
Franco
I know nothing about your son, and I wish he and you only the best, Franco. So, I'm not addressing his case specifically.
DeleteYet, being a "pretty smart fella" doesn't prevent one from believing things that aren't true. There are pretty smart fellas who are followers of many different religions, for instance. That doesn't mean that they're all correct about beliefs that can vary widely.
One of the most disturbing things about the state of the union is how many smart people have somehow convinced themselves that there is any justification at all for supporting the most dangerous, corrupt, criminal, deceitful, incompetent, sexist carnival barker in the history of the presidency.
One can have a mistrust of many things without needing to look for alternative explanations for the remarkably well-documented events of 9/11, in particular.
"Somebody said that that was an error page I doubt that you read any of it..." Munchygut was clearly prepared to at least give your link a look. The reason he said it was an error page is because, when one attempts to view the link, it says: "Something went wrong and this URL isn’t available."
Thanks, Jakash, for your reply to Franco. I agree with what you wrote. I wanted to add that I also tried to cut and paste the link Franco shared, but was unable to load the page. I tried with the letters "PMC" included, and without. Also tried to load the page from the PMC website.
DeleteFranco, I am sorry you are concerned about your son's mental health. I've got nothing to add that would be helpful. As Jakash suggested, intelligence does not correlate with mental illness. These days, even the company you keep - in person or on social media, or what channel you tune your TV to, can influence your belief system. I pray that when the spell is broken, the misguided souls find their way back to a place where we all can share at least a small set of facts and reality.
Jakash
DeleteOne of the most disturbing things about the state of the union is how many smart people have somehow convinced themselves that there is any justification at all for supporting the most dangerous, corrupt, criminal, deceitful, incompetent, sexist carnival barker in the history of the presidency.
I have made this point a number of times and I think that imagining them all to be stupid is a mistake on the part of our side..
These are very shrewd people and they've wrestled the levers of power out of the hands of more reasonable people.
Hopefully we'll find the energy to look away from the clown show long enough to get to the polls and regain one of the houses of Congress.this fall. Though I'm worried we won't.
Personally I don't care if someone thinks the moon is made of green cheese. So long as they get out and vote. It's the only real power we have. We're distracted by so much nonsense we don't focus on what's truly important
Here are some of my favorite quotes that relate to your column:
ReplyDeleteThere are only two kinds of really fascinating people: people who know absolutely everything, and people who know absolutely nothing.
Everyone is entitled to be stupid, but some abuse the privilege.
A fool's brain digests philosophy into folly, science into superstition, and art into pedantry. Hence University education.
They say ignorance is bliss. But you don't seem very happy.
You are not entitled to your own opinion. You are entitled to your own informed opinion. No one is entitled to be ignorant.
People demand freedom of speech as a compensation for the freedom of thought which they seldom use.
Joseph Wambaugh, cop turned writer, said he believed all conspiracy theories until the police were involved. He said anytime a good-looking reporter stuck a microphone in a cop's face, the cop would immediately give the plot away.
ReplyDeleteThat's my favorite take on conspiracies.
I had to dump a pal for getting obsessed with conspiracy theories, on covid, or the moon shot being fake. Don't you dare mess with my hero: Neil Armstrong. The internet doesn't help and some idiots will believe anything.
ReplyDeleteI saw this in an article about a court filing where👍🤡👍is suing a pollster for $1bn because he didn't like the poll results. “Everything looks like a conspiracy to those who don’t know how anything works.”
ReplyDeleteAttributed to Einstein: “ Two things are infinite – – the universe and human stupidity. And I’m not sure about the universe.“
ReplyDeleteHope you'll be okay.
ReplyDeleteLate to the conversation and maybe no one will read this. I know one thing for sure. There is much more that we don't know than we do. I have to accept the possibility that some things exist even if we don't yet have the capacity to understand them.
ReplyDeleteYou did that all in one day Neil? Who are you — Ferris Buehler? I went to a kid’s birthday party, had a piece of cake, and I was EXHAUSTED
ReplyDelete