| The Dark Horse, Boulder, Colorado, 2025 |
It’s best not to comment on specific mistaken remarks made by Mayor Brandon Johnson — the air is already thick with criticism, and once started, where does one stop? But there is one statement he says repeatedly that is almost Rahmesque in its misguided pretension:
“Chicago is a world-class city.”
Yes, there is the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, the Art Institute, Margie’s Candies and a few other first-rate institutions that might embolden a person to imagine Chicago is right up there with London and Paris and the other global big boys.
But the truth remains: Chicago is not a world-class city. It can’t be. We don’t have any public toilets. A survey by Nationwide Waste Service lists 21 cities. Kansas City is first, with 30 public toilets per 100,000 residents, while Chicago is dead last, with less than half, 14 per 100,000.
And those are not actual public toilets but toilets accessible to the public, theoretically, in libraries and hotels and restaurants that turn a blind eye to those in need. While a few city-run facilities no doubt lurk in remote park district field houses and other public buildings, this woeful sentence was published by the Sun-Times this week:
“The city’s sole public bathroom appeared near the CTA Blue Line station in the Polish Triangle at Division Street and Ashland and Milwaukee Avenues in West Town.”
The structure appeared, that is. Not yet open. Almost there. After decades of dithering. Chicago is about to open one sleek self-cleaning public bathroom. In Wicker Park. How many of those are found in Paris? A city of 2 million residents, or three-quarters the population of Chicago?
Answer: 435
Any idea how embarrassing this is? How bad for our reputation? Flip open a guide book.
“Public toilets are non-existent on the streets of Chicago,” a Frommer’s guide chides.
How long was this humiliation in the making? (pardoning the mild pun; we journalists love punning on this topic; doing so relieves — whoops — reduces our discomfort.)
To continue reading, click here.
Interesting timing re your subject. Not three weeks ago, here in the now People's Republic of NYC, Mayor Mamdani announced the installation of 17 new public bathrooms, a pilot program. "We are going to learn from this pilot and build a public bathroom network that meets the needs of New Yorkers in every borough."
ReplyDeleteLet's see Trump/MAGA make some scary attack ad out of that!
I'm not sure exactly what the purpose of bringing up the honorable mayor Brandon Johnson in this context hopes to accomplish.
ReplyDeleteA long line of mayors has failed to accomplish enacting a statute that would require gas stations to have public restrooms. Seems to work in the majority of other places that I travel.
You do understand what it takes logistically to have stand alone restrooms in a city where it often falls below 32°.
The plumbing will freeze unless they're also heated and they have to be heated 24 hours a day or the pipes break.
The history of this issue goes back to when pay toilets were outlawed it didn't only outlaw pay toilets it caused public restrooms to disappear.
The government is supposed to tend to our every need?
Come on man
The cleanest easily accessible restrooms are at home Depot ,Menards, Lowe's and other big box stores.
Fast food restaurants also are a good option but the bathrooms are usually a real mess.
Chicago drew millions of tourists last year and every year the people who really need outdoor toilets are the homeless.
Another poor option readily available is porta potties. Gross but pretty much everywhere tens of thousands of people use them at outdoor festivals throughout the city without incident though I recommend carrying around a small roll of toilet paper because often there is none.
I'm always impressed by your genius at shrugging off whatever I'm writing and disgorging your preconceptions, FME. A wonder to behold. The leap from providing toilets to "tend to our every need." Acrobatic. Other cities do it. If they provided stoplights and we didn't, you could refute an argument for them in the same manner. It is what I call a "self-own."
DeleteI missed the connection between being homeless & needing to use a toilet. I am pretty sure almost every human being has to empty their bladders and bowels on a fairly regular basis whether they are homeless or not. Even those with the using various alternative methods required for medical reasons often need a place to privately change &/or empty the devices they use. Many parents also have faced the challenge of finding public place for their small ones to potty. Public toilets would be a benefit for the ENTIRE public. In fact, I would bet that one of these days you will find yourself needing the use of a public toilet. Hope one is available when you need it.
DeleteYou sure did. I was referring to homeless people LIVING in the restrooms. Not using them. You might have realized this had you not been so keen to deliver your lecture. It must be hard to have that compressed sanctimoniousness built up inside you, desperate to get out.
DeleteI didn't actually aim the reply to you Mr. Steinberg. I was replying to FME. I was supporting your request for more public toilets. If you perceive my good intentions to be so unkind you evidently misunderstood the point I was trying to make. I volunteer large amounts of my time as an advocate for the homeless. I work first hand with them on a daily basis; I spend endless time trying to find them food, trying to find nightly sleeping quarters & permanent housing. I do several loads of laundry for them FREE each week. I store their blankets, pillows & sleeping items for them in my car every the day so they don't have to carry them around with them all day while they make the trips from hinder to yonder to try to keep the police off their butts. I make the rounds each night to several of the local homeless encampments to make sure they are ok. To call me sanctimoniousness hurts me deeply. My point was that we all need public restrooms - not just the homelss
DeleteAnonymous 10:59am
I'm not shrugging it off and I'm not anonymous above whatever similarities they have to my comment that's not me.
DeleteI understand that it would be nice to have public bathrooms I was dragging three toddlers around for a while too and even when they grew up they just needed to go to the bathroom and I understand that old people return to that circumstance where they can't go for 3-4 hours without hitting the can.
I tried to give everybody the heads up go to home Depot
My question was what does mayor Johnson have to do with this?
And you clearly stated in your piece that the society we live in isn't willing to accommodate others. Yeah but I mean we wouldn't do it as a group dedicated to building public bathrooms we expect the government to do it the city government in this case which is 1.2 billion dollars in debt in its structural budget I read about that in the Sun times last week we're not going to spend tens of millions of dollars so the tourists have bathrooms somewhere other than their hotel or Airbnb. Starbucks is always been a good option when you're out to go to the bathroom and obviously you mentioned most restaurants have bathrooms because it's a law but they don't actually have to let people who aren't customers use them.
I wish you wouldn't think I was attacking you personally every time I comment I appreciate it that you bring these things up but is it a conversation or a lecture because sometimes that's what it seems like you just want to lay it all out there from your point of view and if anyone else sees it differently they're an a****** I know I'm an a****** somehow it escapes you that you are sometimes too
Mayor Johnson, what a joke. Interesting about the blue light at Starbucks. One can see where a public toilet would be a problem in some areas.
ReplyDeleteThe city could take a lesson from rest areas along the highway. No sooner than you cross the border into Wisconsin, there's a large rest stop in Beloit. This place screams: "Welcome to Wisconsin! We got toilets!" Not to be outdone, if you drive all the way through there's a Welcome to Michigan in Ironwood, with, you guessed it, toilets! Comfort and compassion for visitors. The states have it figured out
ReplyDeleteA person should be judge on how they treat the lowest in our society.
ReplyDeleteToo often I hear complaints about free toilets being used by the homeless or un-housed.
We want good things in our world but refuse to pay for them or the upkeep they need.
There are enough places on the Howard CTA station where the smell of stale urine is stronger than anything else; So it doesn't really matter if we have public toilets or not, were there's a will there's a urinal.
When you start pushing 80, you have to do a lot more logistical planning. Simply put, you have to figure out where you're gonna pee. No matter what city or venue you're in.
ReplyDeleteWas able to deal with it a lot better when I was young. Like, say, at fifty. My most memorable experience at that point in my so-called life was in New York. I was on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan, at high noon, on a weekday. Near the Flatiron Building, I believe, because I wanted to see it with my own eyes.
Really had to whiz. And at that same moment, a little dude rushed past me on my left, turned his body toward the curb, whipped it out, and sprayed a row of newspaper boxes. Then he walked on. Just knew I would get arrested if I tried the same method of relief. So I didn't.
Finally went into a Mickey D's and paid five bucks...an outrageous price in 1997... for a McRib sandwich. Wolfed it down quickly, so that I could make use of their unspeakably filthy toilet. Hey, it was New York, and New York prices, and it was any port in a storm. Or any port-a-potty. Except there weren't any.
Most cities I've been to are similar. Could not use the rest rooms in San Francisco's brand -new main library, around the same time. Mainly because of the homeless. It was beyond description. Also had to watch where I stepped. And that was thirty years ago. Have heard it's a lot worse now.
I lived in Chicago ~17 years, getting around mainly on foot, bus, and El. I would have appreciated convenient public washrooms. You'd think restaurants and other businesses would welcome public washrooms to take the pressure off of them. "Let's Go Chicago!"
ReplyDeleteThere is a wonderful Japanese film from 2023 called Perfect Days. The main character drives around Tokyo all day cleaning public restrooms. He does so efficiently and with an upbeat attitude. The little buildings are architecturally interesting and aren’t all the same. There’s a plot twist at the end so it isn’t only the guy cleaning. The movie is available on Amazon to rent. I wish Chicago and most cities could come up with more public facilities.
ReplyDeleteI also read about the new public restroom- what struck me was it would be entirely self-cleaning after each use, including the floor, and there will be a time limit for using it. I wondered what the time limit will be and what happens if I over-stay.
ReplyDeleteStill, i applaud the investment as it's a definite community need. I hope the project succeeds.
The Chicago Park district provides and maintains dozens of public bathrooms
ReplyDeleteMany are found along the lakefront millennium Park has public bathrooms Harold Washington library has public bathrooms city hall has public bathrooms.
More public bathrooms would be awesome but there are quite a few