Thursday, January 30, 2025

Ronald Reagan's dream come true

Vent Haven Museum, Ft. Mitchell, Kentucky

     The Reagan epiphany was a simple one. With overt racism fallen from favor, in some quarters, you could no longer directly afflict the people you are keen to scorn— the minorities, the immigrants, the poor, gays, not to forget women, who are actually the majority but historically vulnerable because of their sex. 
      But you could assail the government that helps them. Starve it by slashing taxes, for the rich. Smother programs. Jettison goals. Scrap supportive laws and pass restrictive ones.
    Public education, once the bedrock of American society, could be abandoned once Black people found their way into white classrooms. School choice could be boosted, and here "choice" means "using tax money to pay for private schools for parents who couldn't bear to let their kids rub elbows with their lessers." 
     People bought it.
    That many of your own kind are hurt — most people in poverty are white — didn't matter. Bigotry is both a kind of ignorance and a form of self-immolation. Southern towns would fill in their swimming pools in the 1960s after the courts ordered them integrated. If your own children sweltered, well, there are always private clubs, and another reason to hate the people you hate already. 
    And there's always someone to hate, to fear, if that is what you are looking for. 
    The task never ends, and when would-be demagogue Donald Trump took office, he arrived with a flurry of spite and vindictiveness, sprayed in all directions, against groups and individuals who dared stand up to him in the past, a practice, already rare, sure to become rarer. 
      Trans soldiers were ejected from the army, based on nothing more than malice and general distaste. The same calumnies directed at Black military personnel until Truman integrated the Army in 1948 could be retrofitted. Any port in a storm. The first thing the new secretary of defense did was strip former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark Milley of his security detail and security clearance, and take steps to bust him in rank in retirement. The first thing.
     Whatever pressing matters the country faces are pushed aside. The need for a functioning military is overlooked. 
     So, open season on vulnerable Americans and the government that serves them. The whole system torn down, as if by a child. That the government does so much, from building roads to testing the purity of food and drugs, that it helps so many, is simply ignored. Racism is both a form of ignorance and a powerful addiction that must be fed .... with somebody. Anyone will do. Democrats, liberals, will serve too, eventually. Does it seem the bond that should hold Americans together in unified purpose is easily dismissed? Apparently so. 
    Today's post is late — my apologies — and I know feels ... what? ... muted, wooden, subdued. That's an accurate rendition of my mood. There must be a lot of that going around.

36 comments:

  1. The revenge parade continues…

    ReplyDelete
  2. Earlier this morning I was reading about how DT might be able the become president again in 2028 by running on a ticket as VP and whatever stooge runs as president steps down. Then my wife woke up and we talked about that scenario. We didn't talk about our kids or grandkids or what we're going to do today. Thinking about our political situation is depressing. Talking about it is more depressing. It's like an infection or disease that gets worse with every bulletin out of DC.Sad.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've read some of those pieces about how Trump could continue for more years. Scary to think about-but he does what to be president for life.

      Delete
  3. Horrifying. All of it. Some kind of collective madness. We have to hold out hope somehow. Sanity must eventually prevail, right? The pendulum must swing back? At some point the self-immolation will be painful enough to wake us up, we just need to somehow keep a bucket of water nearby.

    ReplyDelete
  4. As much as I despise Reagan, I'm not sure that he should get the bulk of the blame for this -- not that he's blameless, but that he didn't start the fire. I think that this all goes back to the Southern Strategy, which really started with Goldwater, didn't it? Leveraging racism for votes has been the GOP's strategy at least since 1970, but they were testing it out way before that, I believe. But of course, I could be wrong.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are correct. You reminded me of a post by the historian Heather Cox Richardson where she traces the origins of the modern Republican party to the reaction to Brown v Board of Education, the SCOTUS case that ended school segregation in 1954. Following that decision Republicans like Goldwater were able to recruit Southern Democrats like Strom Thurmond, uniting the ideals of "small government", "state rights", and racism, under the name of Lincoln's party.
      The full post is well worth reading, and HCR is well worth following, she provides extremely informed commentary with historical context
      https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/p/may-16-2024

      Delete
  5. And nearly half the country's voters support this gangster lawlessness and cruelty. The more miserable he makes their lives, the more they'll love him. In the end, Winston Smith loved big brother.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Been a long time since I last read "!984", after discovering Orwell while in junior high. At the end of the book, Winston Smith loves Big Brother, but he is a broken man, physically and psychologically. He is a husk, a shell, and apparently addicted to the synthetic "Victory Gin" that he guzzles daily.

      I've always assumed that Winston was eventually smoked, but I've never seen any evidence of this in any written discussions of the book. But inside, he was already pretty close to being dead.

      Delete
  6. Neil used an image from Vent Haven. I'm not most folks know there is a rest home for retired ventriloquist dummies. A fascinating yet eerie place to visit for an hour or two. Vent Haven is supported by a considerable endowment from an old eccentric who loved the mysterious art. Investment income keeps the doors open by appointment. There is a Chicago connection in the form of Frank Marshall. (His actual surname was something much longer.) The master wood carver who created Charlie McCarthy, Jerry Mahoney & Knucklehead Smiff, Danny O'Day and Farfel--the list goes on. Marshall worked out of a modest unmarked shop on the south side where he'd be visited by the likes of Paul Winchell and Edgar Bergen. Verifiable Frank Marshall dummies are quite valuable to collectors and they do turn up. In another life I knew "Winch," as he was known to everyone. Never Mr. Winchell. Always Winch. A complicated and misunderstood man who struggled mightily with Depression. Winch and his fellow celebrity vents would meet yearly at the Magic Castle in Los Angeles where they were honorary life members. Always greeted warmly by the magicians. Winch always emphasized that "Ventriloquism is a first cousin to magic." Indeed. I know this has nothing to do with the topic of Neil's post today. I was inspired by the Vent Haven image. I'm sorry for rambling on so.

    ReplyDelete
  7. We are in for a long slog. But it's good, a way, to see how far back the roots of this moment go.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Warsaw ghetto uprising didn't happen over night.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Depends on what you mean by failure. Yes, all those who rose against the Nazis eventually died, either in the uprising or in the gas chambers,. But they died on their feet and not on their knees. They realized they would soon be killed anyway, in the camps. So why not die fighting your oppressors, and take as many of them with you as possible? Which they did.

      Not exactly a failure, even though they all died, They never had a prayer, any more than do the ants that small boys step on. But they chose the time and place and manner of their deaths, as martyrs and heroes.

      Gotta wonder what our own uprising will look like, and how many will fall on either side. Every goddamn day, that awful scenario now feels more and more inevitable. One final thought: When England faced a German invasion in 1940, it was Churchill who memorably said: "You can always take one with you."

      Delete
    2. And remember Treblinka. In the most horrible conditions, in the worst despair, one man helped another and so began the resistance to their fascists. Let us help one another and resist our fascists.

      Delete
  9. The Trumpista party is using the time proven plan of using hate and fear as a distraction to the masses keeping them so busy that they don’t notice the things their betters are doing. Stealing and power grabs are what has happened throughout history and will continue to happen as long as humans exist. Maybe after we fade from the scene the next creatures to reach the top of the heap will be different. Maybe….

    ReplyDelete
  10. When I encounter anything about GOP, I can't get this song out of my head.
    You've got to be carefully taught to hate.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VPf6ITsjsgk

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And yet I know people spouting MAGA, Q-Anon and more besides the usual spews who were not raised to it. An unhealed injury? Bactetia or virus? A satanic miasma across the land?

      Delete
  11. Stripping Milley of his security detail hasn’t been the worst thing Trump’s goons have done but it may be the most petty.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Neil, you nailed it with that final paragraph. That's exactly how I'm feeling today.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I am nowhere near you posters when it comes to your knowledge of history and politics. And I realize in many ways this country is in dire straits. But I'm hoping there's a little overreaction going on, as in the last couple of days I've seen our current situation compared to slavery, Warsaw ghetto uprisings, and people being carted off to the gas chambers. I've been around long enough to remember the Kennedy assassination, Nixon, and everything in between, so maybe it's ok to take it down a notch. Four years to go.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've been around a while, too...78 this coming summer. I remember news from Korea on TV and radio, Ike, Little Rock, Cuba, JFK being offed, and everything that followed, including the Vietnam Era. Didn't watch Chicago on TV...I was there. My wife was at Kent. And this is as dire a situation as anything I have ever experienced, or can remember witnessing.

      Had an anti-Goldwater button that said: "In your guts, you know he's nuts." Wish I still had it...now more than ever. He's getting more crazy by the day. Almost starting to believe that the Jethro V. Dance Troupe might be a welcome relief.

      He's half Dump's age, but at least he seems to be twice as mature.--like maybe 24 instead of 12. More importantly...he probably knows how, and when, to STFU. Especially after dozens have died.

      Delete
    2. If you remember Nixon, you might also remember that, after the "smoking gun" tape came out, he was informed by Goldwater and the House and Senate Republican leaders that he had to go. After all, he was the head of the "law and order" party.

      Fast forward to the orange felon. Fully supported by most Republicans and abetted by the legislators who could have sent him packing via either of 2 impeachments, who support him no matter what. Even after he tried to overturn the election on Jan. 6.

      He never conceded the 2020 election and has promptly pardoned his fellow felons who did his bidding interfering with the peaceful transfer of power. He's a criminal many times over who was voted for by 77 million of your fellow Americans. Because they're more concerned about the price of eggs and a trans person in the bathroom than the rule of law. He's appointing the most venal, unqualified administration in history, intent on punishing anybody who's stood in his way.

      With all due respect, "I'm hoping there's a little overreaction going on," too, but unfortunately this notch seems about right to me.

      Delete
    3. On January 7th 2021 some months after the election Donald Trump recorded a video in which he said a new administration will be Entering the White House it is my goal to have peaceful and orderly transition of power

      At the time it was considered a concession speech just to get the facts straight.
      His first week in office has been an utter catastrophe and I only expect more of the same still he was elected by our fellow citizens who were sick and tired of the liberal mindset and tossed the bums out of office which is how democracy works this is a democracy We had a free and fair election with no violence and there hasn't been any violence since he took office so maybe there is an overreaction I don't agree with the way he governs I find many of his policies of abhorront. He's the president and the Republicans are in charge and it's our fault just as much it is the people who voted for him we're all to blame for this s*** show

      Delete
    4. Just to get the facts straight: The felon's remarks on Jan. 7, 2021 were spoken the day after he casually watched on TV as his minions stormed the Capitol. At the time, the speech was considered by many, rightly, as being akin to a hostage video. A number of lies and some things that he HAD to say in that moment, that somebody wrote for him, that he certainly did not believe himself.

      He did agree to leave office and said nice things about the transition, but even in that speech, he did not concede that he had lost, only that the results had been "certified" by Congress.

      He also said: "TO THOSE WHO ENGAGED IN THE ACTS OF VIOLENCE AND DESTRUCTION, YOU DO NOT REPRESENT OUR COUNTRY. TO THOSE WHO BROKE THE LAW, YOU WILL PAY."

      Hmmm... Seems to me that I've read about him calling them patriots quite a few times since then. And oh, right -- he pardoned them all the first chance he got.

      "there hasn't been any violence since he took office" That's because he freaking won, Franco. And it's barely been a week.

      Holy moly! In no way do I consider it "our fault just as much it is the people who voted for him."

      Delete
    5. Of course we know the man is liar and we know he's lying because we can see his lips moving but it does not help our cause to Make incorrect statements.
      He said what he said it's on video he conceded the election. If we know anything about the man nobody's going to force him to say things that he doesn't want to say

      It is our fault that he is president again because we allowed the Democratic party to make decisions such as allowing Biden to run a second time then forcing him out and inserting a candidate who could not win.
      Then when left with that is the only choice not coming out in big enough numbers to defeat the orange one You can blame everything on somebody else but part of what happened is our fault.

      There hasn't been any violence for several reasons One of which is that Democrats are not going to take the streets and resort to violence after an election We can't say that about everyone in our country

      Delete
    6. As Bill Clinton might say, it all depends on what the meaning of the word "concede" is. What he said on Jan. 7, 2021 was: "Now Congress has certified the results. A new administration will be inaugurated on January 20. My focus now turns to ensuring a smooth, orderly, and seamless transition of power. This moment calls for healing and reconciliation."

      So, in a carefully worded statement, he admitted that he would have to go, not conceding that it was because he had actually lost the election, but because Congress had certified what we all know that he considered to be fraudulent results.

      He did not say: Joe Biden won the election and I congratulate him. He did not attend Biden's inauguration.

      I agree that "it does not help our cause to Make incorrect statements." The truism "never say never" scores again. My saying "he never conceded" may not have been correct. He argued for years after that Jan. 7 speech that he had won, which clearly indicates that he did not actually "concede" legitimate defeat in THOSE remarks. In September, 2024, however, he did acknowledge a couple times that he had lost "by a whisker."

      Of course, after that and after almost 4 years of promoting his "big lie" that he had won, he still said at a rally in October: “We did great in 2016 and a lot of people don’t know that we did a lot better in 2020. We won. We won. We did win. It was a rigged election.”

      As for "we allowed the Democratic party to make decisions," I don't recall being consulted about any of that. How are "we" responsible for the fact that other people didn't come out to vote for Kamala? Many people did their best to get those folks to vote, and cannot be blamed for the strange proclivities of certain voters. You can blame "part of what happened" on "us," if that makes you feel better about it somehow. I don't agree.

      Delete
    7. Nothing makes me feel good about any of this and I'm not trying to feel good.

      We live in a country where we get to vote but a large percentage of people who can don't.
      We make comments on a blog post and somehow seem to have an expectation that these words serve any purpose. Citizens need to take action One of those actions is to vote there are people who make the effort to get out the vote. There are people who donate money.
      There are people who work as poll officials. But a lot of people don't do anything that and complain profusely about the outcome and try to blame it on the people who actually did put up a candidate who could win and got out in large enough numbers to get him elected.
      WE didn't do that hence WE'RE at fault. You and I are part of a group we're part of the group that didn't get their party into power. That's why I say we should blame ourselves . In my opinion we share the blame for who got elected

      Delete
  14. Replies
    1. Free and Fair? They are all free. But fair? According to Greg Palast not so much. https://www.gregpalast.com/trump-lost-vote-suppression-won/ The following is from 2021. https://www.gregpalast.com/uncovered-illegal-attack-on-364000-georgia-voters/ There is a short video where he shows the woman who was responsible for purging many voters. She had never talked to any of those voters.

      Delete
    2. When Al Gore conceded the election to Bush in 2000 he could have continued through the courts and pursued the recount he didn't

      But a lot of people in the Democratic party said that there was funny business with the hanging chads
      When Hillary lost they immediately pursued the narrative that Trump had only won because of help from the Russians.
      Setting the precedent of disputing a free and fair electoral process in America.
      When Trump lost to Biden he latched on to that narrative
      The man is a piece of s*** and only out for himself but he uses every angle available within our system to achieve his objective
      The Republicans do this like Mitch McConnell did when he refused to even consider Obama's nominee for the supreme Court.

      When they play hard we lay down.
      I don't want elections in this country to become more contentious I just don't know how they could be unless both sides play it the way the Republicans do and the Democrats just don't they're soft and they imagine that they're going to get the what they feel is the best outcome have faith in the American people but they don't give us good candidates and they don't play to win they play to play fair but they have got caught playing unfair during the nomination process and it's got to stop worrying that they're going to get caught do everything you can to get your candidate in so you don't end up with one of these scumbags

      Delete
  15. All of this, as of yesterday. And then the idiocy and cruelty today with the rant about the plane crash layered on top. It won't stop.

    Re: Monica's comment - It was in Round 1 of this mess in 2017 when I was humming "You've got to be carefully taught." And it just so happened that South Pacific was playing at Drury Lane in Oakbrook. A reminder that hate and fear go way back, but what's happening now is just mind-numbing.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thoughtful piece as usual. I am just depressed and see no end any time soon. I think Trump and his heads of various departments will push the country into a recession and ultimately a depression.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Good summary of what happens when we elect someone who is there not to serve, but to be served.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.