Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Not my circus: religion small and large


     Noticing this sign in the hallway of a Washington DC apartment building sent me tumbling down an interesting mental tangent. 
     I know a bit about Islam, and knew that shoes are removed during prayer in a mosque. But did not realize that also extended to quotidian life in the home. Makes sense — live a life of purity, keep the dirt outside. My daughter-in-law insists on the same thing, not out of religious scruple, but just trying to keep germs off the babies. I brought slippers and tried to remember, though old habits die hard.
     There are two tracks that religion occupies. Think of it as two levels. There is the individual, daily pathways each we blaze for ourselves, deciding how we pray, what to think, what we eat, whether our shoes stay on or off indoors
     And then there is, for want of a better term, the public track, faith as image, metaphor, communal consensus, political club to be wielded, for and against. Religion as concept, as it is talked about rather than lived. Not a distinction I see discussed much, which is unfortunate, because it strikes me as useful.
    They almost seem like two entirely different animals, do they not? Personal and public faith. I've said many times before that religion is a tool, like a hammer. You can build a house with it, or hit someone in the head. Same hammer. 
     But there is also religion as different tools, put to different purposes. A micrometer and a yardstick. Religion small and large. People rarely complain about religion small, religion as it actually manifests itself among regular folk. As much as people hate Jews, in often spectacular, creative fashion, you never hear bigots raging about the fuckin' Jews and their damn Sabbath candles and their yamulkes and their affinity for education. Not to give haters any ideas. I'd almost call it an unexpected charity, if I didn't know it's just an oversight. When you're damning people for being murderers drinking the blood of children and running the world, you don't think to add that they also eat gefilte fish.
     No, the faults of Jews bruited about by haters are either entirely imagined — run the banks, Hollywood, the world, whatever. Or attached by association — how do you expect me to be kind to you when all those kids are being killed in Gaza? Which is your fault. Because you're Jewish, and Jews also live in Israel. It makes as much sense as firebombing a Belgian waffle stand because of those historic atrocities in the Congo.
     I'm not sure why I shifted from Islam to Judaism. Maybe I was reluctant to reel off the generalized faults assigned to Islam — scary sharia law, responsibility for all terrorism everywhere, head scarves. (I can never quite get my head around that last one. Nuns sure got away with that, prior to the 1960s; what changed?) You can treat your own team more roughly. You get a pass.
      I did think about hammering on the door and asking about the sign. But that seemed, oh, intrusive. I'm sure guests appreciate the reminder. I sure would appreciate one in my son and daughter-in-law's apartment. Maybe I'd be less inclined to go blasting in, attending to some grandchild-related issue, only to be told, three paces in, to remove my shoes. It's an awkward moment. Not that I'm complaining, mind you. Nobody ever removed their shoes with more alacrity. As if God Almighty was looking down going, "Tsk, tsk, shoes Neil." One key to successful grandparenting is to understand that this is not my circus, not my monkeys, not my rules. I'm just trying to follow them best I can. 

32 comments:

  1. When it comes to head coverings, as you say, it's not my circus, not my rules. And maybe I'm missing something, but I always find the nun comparison puzzling. Nuns take a vow to devote their life to the church, and the habit is/was part of showing the world they are religious sisters. It's not like all Catholic women are required to wear a head covering. Years ago, it was required for church, but no longer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are, missing something, that is. Religious Muslim women are also required to wear head coverings. It's not like all Muslim women are required to wear a head covering. But some are. It is illustrative that one case — the one you're familiar with — makes perfect sense. While the other is causing confusion.

      Delete
    2. "For 2000 years in the Orthodox Church, the tradition has been for women and girls to veil their heads during worship, whether at church for the liturgy, or at home for family prayer time."
      https://catalog.obitel-minsk.com/blog/2018/05/a-guide-to-womens-headcoverings

      Delete
    3. Oh comeon, Neil! You are comparing a small group of religious women who chose to join an order back in the day and had to cover their heads, to a religion, as interpreted in some nations where you can be beaten or flogged or it's against law if you don't cover yourself. Stop being so pc, you are wiser than that.

      Delete
  2. Religion is a very interesting and strange thing.

    It has helped me to know what's right and wrong.

    I am.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent column. Planning to share it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You may want to remind your daughter in law of a science theory known as the hygiene hypothesis proposed by British epidemiologist David Strachan in the 80’s. The theory suggests that growing up in an environment that is “too clean” can prevent a child’s immune system from properly developing, making them more likely to overreact to harmless substances and develop asthma or allergies. The best real world evidence of this is based upon the “farm effect” where children are raised on livestock farms. Their rates of asthma and allergies are much lower than suburban or urban raised children. Good luck raising the grandkids. I’m sure you will spoil them rotten and teach them well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. An absolutely adorable example of this is the Instagram account of Williamsonsquackingeggs. It is a farm near Durham England where the ridiculously charming children do chores and make videos. Right now it may be my favorite thing in the whole world.

      Delete
    2. Or...you may choose not to give your son and DIL unsolicited advice. I know which one I'd pick.

      Delete
    3. Or....maybe you would, particularly if your son and DIL are establishing house rules that are actually making their kids more vulnerable to sickness. There are lots of parents who do not get their kids vaccinated on the erroneous presumption that vaccines are harmful to them. Should unsolicited advice be withheld from them as well?

      Delete
    4. I say yes, unless you have reason to believe you have information they do not. Shoe removal has not been shown to be a danger to children's health; in fact, the opposite is true.

      Delete
  5. We take our shoes off when visiting several in my family, because it’s what they do. Like your daughter in law they don’t like dragging the dirt from outside through the house. But one of my nieces is married to a Muslim. I didn’t realize until your article that was the reason we did it at their home. Thank you for enlightening me.
    We always bring bedroom slippers to all their homes.
    It’s also a practice in Hawaii.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You're wrong they don't care about yarmulkes. They call them "Tiny hats" & use that as a code word to get around the censorship of many commenting sites & also call Jews the Tiny hat people"!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Long ago, I learned that the white ones are for home games, and that the black ones are worn on the road. Pink ones are worn on special occasions, such as at all-star games and playoffs...and Jewish weddings. Those are monogrammed, with the name of the happy couple on the inside, and the date of the nuptials.

      Delete
    2. There were even Teen Age Mutant Turtle ones for the boys in Hebrew school years ago.

      Delete
    3. You remember the song about blue suede shoes? Well, I met a guy in the bleachers at Wrigley, about 40 years ago, who said he made customized yarmulkes.

      When I jokingly asked him if he could make me a blue suede one, he replied: "Sure, boychik. Not a problem. When do you need it?" "No rush," I told him.

      He even painted a Cub logo onto the blue suede. Still have it.

      So don't you...mess with my yarmulke...
      You can mess with me...but don't mess with my yarmulke...

      Delete
  7. I am no expert but aren’t all orthodox married Jewish women required to hide their hair?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. Most use wigs but some do wear scarves. They also dress modestly. Not the same as full habibs, but similar reason.

      Delete
    2. "Habib" is an Arabic masculine given name, occasional surname, and honorific, with the meaning "beloved" or "my love", or "darling". Not to be confused with a haboob, which is a blinding dust storm that is a result of thunderstorm outflow winds.

      Perhaps you meant a hijab...which covers the head?
      Or maybe a burka, which covers the entire body?

      Delete
  8. Religious culture is always more interesting than the religion responsible for it. You don't have to do a deep-dive into a person's faith, to be fascinated by their culture.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Understanding that at least you might be wrong about something sometime is important.

    Understanding that you are wrong when you are is very important.

    Not everyone has a disability. Most religions assure us that if we adhere to the teachings in the book we're always right.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The key to being smart is being knowledgeable enough to know that you don't know anything.

      But I would argue that the religious I know preach that if we adhere to their teachings we will be "OK" in the next life. I was never taught that you were right or wrong, it was just "that's the rule. follow it."

      I suppose in its own way that is considered being "right"

      Delete
  10. People are free to believe, privately, whatever gets them through the night. That seems to include an imaginary bearded old white guy in the sky who is described as loving yet wreaks havoc and destruction upon his "children". The big three religions are based on patriarchy, the theory that men are superior and entitled to rule in the name of Daddy God. Religion is neither fact nor science based and there is no evidence that it is anything other than the fount of all that is evil in the world. I have no clue why anyone, women especially, espouse such nonsense. But go ahead .. take off your shoes, cover your head, await the Rapture, and embrace those chains.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Growing up, I was baffled when people walked around their house (or our house for that matter) without their shoes on. It seemed silly to me. Now, Having been married to a Korean woman for more than 40 years, I feel guilty if I don't immediately remove my shoes when visiting someone at their home. But even given that Korean traditional culture leans heavily patriarchic, I don't think there is any religious significance in Koreans going shoeless; it mostly boils down to hygiene and the Korean custom of living closer to the floor than other people generally do. When in Rome...or in Seoul.

      tate

      Delete
    2. In the Korean language, the name for the Korean peninsula is "Chosen."
      Therefore, the Koreans--and not the Jews--are really the Chosen People.

      Delete
  11. I saw three women clad in long black dresses and veils walking along south Harlem Avenue the other day. For a second, I thought they were nuns. I wondered if there is a common origin of the clothing or if they evolved differently.
    I am a bit envious of people who practice their religion in their daily life; the discipline, faith, and contentment.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Maybe you felt the urge to veer into Judaism for reasons other than you touched on here with us. Maybe.
    I have studied “religion” and it's counterfeits virtually my whole life. I respect them in terms of mystical intent, but the forms faith takes in human translation (practice) are often a problem, making me a poor joiner of groups.
    Reb Zalman, an Hasidic rabblerouser, was one of my finest teachers, ~ 2010 convincing me that my own encompassing perspective was neither nuts, nor woo. Anyone interested can look him up, but here’s a composite summary of the”tracks” he followed as a Jewish leader:
    Islam: He was initiated as a Sufi sheikh, and in 2004 he co-founded the Inayati-Maimuni Order, which blends Sufi and Hasidic practice.
    Christianity: He corresponded with Thomas Merton and joined Thomas Keating's interfaith gatherings of contemplatives.
    Buddhism: He joined the 1990 Jewish dialogue with the Dalai Lama and held the World Wisdom Chair at Naropa University. Roger Kamenetz wrote his best-selling The Jew in the Lotus based on his involvement in the dialogue.
    Each faith, the Rabbi believed, is a distinct organ of one living body, and their mystical cores touch the same Divine reality.
    Our finite bodies pick and choose and affirm and reject based on what we feel is true. Honest folks in my view learn mainly through some wisdom tradition, which offers imagery and bits of language and story to frame up one’s innermost thoughts; in tandem with hard experience and a measure of self-awareness, without which there can not really be other-awareness.

    BTW I would take my shoes off. There is a symbolic land of encounter for some, in theory if not in practice, as the Sufi mystic Rumi wrote in oft-quoted lyrics, as translated my Coleman Barks:

    Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing,
    There is a field. I'll meet you there.
    When the soul lies down in that grass,
    The world is too full to talk about.
    Ideas, language, even the phrase each other
    Doesn't make any sense.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I know what you mean. My coworker is a devout Jehovah's Witness, and she regales me with information that I find kind of ridiculous. But she truly believes that evil is taking over, and this world as we know it will be ending soon (maybe not too ridiculous). But that she will return to earth and we won't need hospitals or cemeteries because no one will get sick or die. She's also doesn't stress about politics because they don't believe any man has the power to rule over you (again, something to think about.) I still try to convince her that you may not think so, but these people are still making laws that affect you. Or that you could ignore your birthday, but you're still a year older. Anyway, all I really meant to say is, even though I could never believe these things, her, and my Mormon niece, and my evangelical friend, have something to hold onto; that gets them through this life. And as long as they're not hurting anyone, I think that must be kind of comforting

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This column or blog today certainly struck a nerve for some folks.

      Delete
  14. One reader, Howie, tried to leave this comment and couldn't, so I said I would post it for him: My Muslim friends tell me they take their shoes off in the spirit of Taharah (cleanliness) they are to follow. They are not zealots about it, they tell me it is not commanded specifically, it is a more custom that aligns daily practice with scripture. They also feel it is good hygiene. If they come into a home that does not follow this, they leave their shoes to avoid soiled socks.
    I’m an old Jew from Chicago. They came from Gaza 40 or so years ago, discontented with their leaders, so before Arafat signed the Oslo agreement on 1993. They believed and still believe that the only way to solve the crisis is to have a 2 state solution with all countries in the area doing regular business with each other. They believe there is no chance of it unless major powers stop with arming each side as their proxies.
    They get that Israel will not go back to ‘48 boundaries, but still think there should be something better than total annexation of their population and their homeland. I do, too. Maybe your grandkids and theirs will learn how to bring peace to the Middle East after we are gone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of the most interesting places -- for me at least -- in Israel is the Church of the Holy Sepulcher.

      Why? It's a christian church, in a jewish state, with the key to all of the locks kept by a muslum man.

      Delete
  15. One of my best friends in childhood was a Korean boy whose mother always reminded us to take our shoes off in the house, doubtless because she liked to have a clean house (the forest came right up to their back yard) as they were definitely not a Muslim family. She also had a tendency to bake delicious blueberry muffins that I remember to this day.

    Thus I didn't ascribe any more importance to removing our shoes than to having blueberry muffins during my visits; I just assumed that other peoples' families did all kinds of things that my family did not, and over the years since then, I have found that to be true. I just go with the flow. (Here in present-day life, daughter-in-law #2 routinely orders me to remove my shoes in their house.)

    The last thing I would do is try to drag a religious dispute into a family's home practices. I vaguely recall a quote from many years ago by author Dave Barry, possibly on the endless fight over abortion rights rather than the endless fight over religion, but the gist of which was, "Why don't you both just go outside and whack each other over the head with your signs, and leave the rest of us alone?"

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.