Thursday, March 21, 2024

"I have a voice!"

     Do you prefer to watch new movies or movies you've already seen?
     It might seem an odd question. Who doesn't want to see a new movie? But given how many films are garbage, the question can be seen as: is it better to take a risk, or go for the sure thing?
     Sometimes I prefer the safety of the familiar. I know I'm going to enjoy "Master and Commander" for the characters, the dialogue, the action. Some other film? Who knows, except it probably won't be as good.
      Or "The King's Speech." I can't tell you how many times I've watched the 2010 film about Lionel Logue, the speech therapist who helped King George VI overcome his stutter in the years before World War II.
     Why that movie? A trio of fabulous actors. Colin Firth plays the stuttering monarch. Firth has a presence that somehow far surpasses his bland handsomeness. Viewers have to like him, even when he is playing an aloof king, or, in "Bridget Jones Diary," a jerk barrister. He's also the cuckold Lord Wessex in "Shakespeare in Love," which put him in the same movie with his star here, Geoffrey Rush, who plays Logue with an unshakable dignity, going toe-to-toe with royalty. "My castle, my rules."
     The third is Helen Bonham Carter, as Queen Elizabeth, who is something of an emissary between the royal world and the grungy environs of an Australian self-taught audiologist. Her face is an essay of pained concern as her husband blubbers that he's a naval officer, not a king. The pivotal moment of the movie is hers as she pops up unexpectedly in the Logue apartment and encounters his wife Myrtle, who learns what her husband's been up to by finding the Queen sitting at her dining room table.
      "It's "Your Majesty" the first time," the royal consort explains, a bit wearily. "After that, it's 'ma'am.' As in 'ham.' Not 'mum' as in 'palm.'"
    The writing is just top notch — the royal couple, his brother, the short-reigning King Edward VIII and the woman he loves, Wallis Simpson, plus the Logues at home, the way their children gather around the radio as war is declared, stand-ins for all those young people about to be swept up and perhaps killed.
    What I didn't know was the story of the film, laid out in the obituary of screenwriter David Seidler, who died last week while fly-fishing in New Zealand at age 86. A thoroughly unexceptional Hollywood journeyman, "The King's Speech" reflected his own experience with stuttering, and shows how important first-hand knowledge is to creativity. His other films — "Tucker" and "Come On, Get Happy: The Partridge Family Story" are uniformly ordinary. Only "The Kings Speech," labored on over decades, stands out as extraordinary. He won the Academy Award for best original screenplay.
    If you haven't seen it, well, you know what to do — you can watch the trailer here. Honestly, I'd rather watch one great movie a dozen times than a dozen so-so movies one time each.

28 comments:

  1. I rarely rewatch movies but I make exceptions for LADY BIRD and HELL OR HIGH WATER.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for reminding us about this excellent film. Those I like to watch more than a few times: The Unbearable Lightness of Being and Local Hero.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I share your opinion and frequently watch The King’s Speech for inspiration to overcome challenges we may have inherited from our childhood. Steven A. Ludsin East Hampton New York

    ReplyDelete
  4. Firth is good in many roles, like the PBS, MP Theater- Pride and Prejudice from some years back. Loved, "The King's Speech."

    ReplyDelete
  5. I rewatch movies all the time because I love movies, especially ones with good writing or Chris Pine in them. An Aaron Sorkin film with Chris Pine would be ideal.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Since this is becoming a thread of rewatchable films, and I'm being reminded of some old favorites, I'll throw in my own: Gosford Park. Julian Fellowes (not just phoning it in) and Robert Altman and a phenomenal cast. (I love the King's Speech, too.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love Gosford Park. Watching Downton Abbey gave me a greater appreciation for Altman and Balaban

      Delete
  7. The one thing they left out of the movie was that George VI was a lifelong anti-Semite.
    I always wondered how angry he was when Prince Philip had Charles circumcised by the chief mohel of London on Charles's eighth day of life, just any Jewish boy. But one of Philip wasn't one & one of his best friends was an Austrian Jewish refugee from the Nazis named Kurt Hahn who ran that very tough private school Gordonstoun in Scotland, where he sent Charles as a teen & Charles hated the place.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes Clark Street, that's really what's missing from any depiction of a historical figure from before 1950. The narrative should underscore how much of an anti-Semite they were. Because that's really necessary when building a truly sympathetic character. "Shakespeare in Love" had the same problem — it really left his anti-Semitism unexplored. And "Downton Abbey." And "The Crown." And....

      Delete
    2. Glad you said that, Neil.

      And I'm glad that you haven't discussed anti-Semitism here since October 7, 2023 -- no winners there in any sense of the word.

      john

      Delete
    3. Why leave it out, it's an historical fact?

      Delete
    4. Ummm ... because fiction is the art of putting in certain things, and leaving others out, so as to create an effect. You're like someone insisting that characters should pause to go to the bathroom in Casablanca. "Why leave it out, it's a natural process!" That's why I'm against prejudice of all sorts — both against others, and for yourself, in excess. It makes people stupid. I don't expect you to grasp this, CS, but rest assured, other readers do.

      Delete
    5. Damn betcha they do. And it's getting stale and tiresome. Thanks, Mr. S.

      We've seen that movie several times. Never gets old. Would watch it again. And again.

      For every person who's a fanatic about about the Royals (we have an old friend who has a "Queen Room" in her house), there's a corresponding an equally fanatic hater, it seems. When you pay attention to their doings, the Royals often sound just like any "normal" family down the street, or next door, or even your own. Good members and bad ones, sane ones and nutcases. Nice people and total a-holes.

      It was Tolstoy who famously said: “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” The Royals seem to fall into the latter category. Hard to blame them, as.they're under the world's biggest magnifying glass, every waking moment.

      Ordinary people...people like you and me...often wish they had all the trappings of a royal family. Or of THE royal family. The ones in the UK. Truth be told, I don't think most of them would like it all that much. Having a security guard standing by every minute, even when you pee and poop, would get pretty old, and pretty fast.

      Delete
  8. Geoffrey Rush…he was just a great actor. Carter and Firth are perfect here too. There should be an award for whomever chooses actors for roles…casting director? I cannot imagine any other three actors for this movie. One wants to cheer when Firth gives the speech.

    ReplyDelete
  9. There will be an Oscar awarded for casting starting next year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Far better would be an Oscar for stunt men & women!

      Delete
  10. To recommend a first run movie to friends is one of life’s pleasures. I use a simple review method. Rush out and go to the cinema, wait till it streams, or don’t waste your time; big screen, small screen, or no screen. Most of my friends agree. Those that don’t sometimes change my mind.
    I reviewed NAPOLEON as a big screen especially for the visuals. Most of my friends that went big screen found it a skip because it was terrible acting and dialogue. They are demanding their money back. Then I want a bonus when we agree.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I started watching it at home and bailed after about 40 minutes. No plot, wooden acting.

      Delete
  11. The scene where Colin Firth finally makes his big radio speech to the British people, with the film's soundtrack playing magnificent music (Beethoven's 7th?) while Geoffrey Rush silently directs him like a maestro. I'm bawling just thinking about the power & beauty of that scene.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I would like to re-watch lots of movies, but really don't very often, because I disagree that it's not worth it to take risks on new movies. Obviously, there are a lot of bad movies, but there are enough good ones vying for attention. If you add in all the classics through the years that one might not have been aware of, there are more than enough to keep us from re-watching many, alas.

    Having seen all of the Best Picture nominees that year, "The King's Speech" was the one I would have chosen for Best Picture, which it won, of course. ("Winter's Bone" was another nominee that we especially liked that year. Its screenplay was nominated for Adapted Screenplay, which was won by "The Social Network.") Since a lackluster script is often the weak link when it comes to movie-making, winning the screenplay Oscars are important indications to me.

    That being said, we've not watched it a second time.

    Colin Firth, who won Best Actor for that performance, is a favorite of ours. If you've not seen him in the 1995 BBC miniseries of "Pride and Prejudice," that's well worth seeing, too. I see that Private already mentioned it.

    Oh, now that you've mentioned "Casablanca" in your reply to Clark St. -- that's one that we've certainly seen multiple times and would still watch again! : )

    ReplyDelete
  13. King's Speech is one of my favorites for all the reasons you mention. It's on my DVR list along with a bunch of other movies I've already seen. If you've seen the movie, you're assured of liking it the 2nd, 3rd 4th time. I consider this one of "the movies I watch when I can't get back to sleep at 3am", along, among others, with To Kill a Mockingbird, Double Indemnity, Bullitt, White Heat (love Cagney), Sunset Boulevard, Witness. When I first saw The King's Speech, I was surprised by how much laugh-out-loud dialogue there was, particularly from Logue. And as Anonymous said, the final scene brings me to tears every time. I love when Elizabeth calls him Lionel for the first time, as a friend. Get me a Kleenex!

    ReplyDelete
  14. RE The Bigotry of Historical Figures
    Few are perfect. Hate the imperfections, appreciate the qualities.
    However, the movie was perfect, on many levels.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Movies to rewatch: Casablanca, of course. The Last of the Mohicans. Best date movie ever.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Any good movie is worth watching twice, and any great movie should be watched as often as necessary. Inside Man holds up to more rewatching than Do the Right Thing. The Fabulous Baker Boys and Searching for Bobby Fisher are just comfy, like warm socks. Enemy of the State is not as good as Heat but it's still good to watch if you run across it at random. Think of rewatch able movies like grilled cheese...the always tadte the same and they always satisfy

    ReplyDelete
  17. We all have favorites to watch time and time again.
    It would be interesting if you could ask Richard Roeper if he does this, even though he watches hundreds of films yearly.
    The two I can watch, starting anywhere in the film, are the previously mentioned "Shakespere in Love" and a film I wish everyone would watch, "Good Night, and Good Luck." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pv4s0wdDOK0

    ReplyDelete
  18. I have watched the movie Yesterday probably 7 times ( and any time I could on an airplane flight! ) .Such a sweet feel good movie, with one scene that makes me sob every time. Hope you’ve seen it Neil.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I try to watch the more popular films each year, especially as Oscar night approaches, because the awards show is so much more interesting when you have a dog or two in the fight.

    This is how I ended up viewing "La-La Land," as a sort of self-imposed homework assignment to watch as many nominees as possible before the Oscars aired, and was so impressed by it that it's one of the few films I've bought on Blu-ray, in order to enjoy repeated viewings on a whim. Heck, even the trailer for it (the first one that pops up if you look up the film on IMDb.com) is a mini masterpiece.

    Films that draw me in are the ones with smart characters acting in logical ways, doing what I might do if driven by the same motives, or trying to puzzle out situations in the best way. A really good actor can even convey thinking... watch Bernard Hill as Captain Smith in "Titanic" as he learns that the ship is in fact sinking, and he takes some time in agonized silence to decide what to do next.

    Any film I recommend (and especially those that I own) will have many near-perfect scenes that are enjoyable just to watch piecemeal: the launch sequence of "Apollo 13"... the Titanic setting out to sea for the first time... Zero the Lobby Boy learning his daily routine in "Grand Budapest Hotel," or the novelist's dinner with him (as a much older man) that bookends the film.

    When you do get involved with a film and you're comfortable enough to let it take you wherever it wants to go, the ending can be a memorable gut-punch, and not necessarily in a bad way. There are the obvious twists and surprises -- endings of "The Sting" and (especially) "Field of Dreams" for example -- but also more low-key endings that can still overwhelm you, such as the final act of "La-La Land" that explores what might have been, takes you out there, and then brings you back again.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I'm perhaps giving away my age, but although it doesn't rate as a great film I watch "It's a Wonderful Life" every holiday season, and still have to dab at my eyes in a few scenes. As for classic or great films, perhaps because I grew up during "the big war," I rate "Casablanca" as Hollywood's all-time greatest film.
    dannyathome

    ReplyDelete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.