Thursday, January 4, 2024

A survivor’s legacy

Sam Harris

     This job has a way of circling back on you. I covered the opening of the Illinois Holocaust Museum on April 19, 2009, and wrote about deciding whether or not to talk with the Nazis who were picketing the event. I listened to the speeches, but didn't go inside — I'd been to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington in 1994. That was plenty. I finally visited Illinois's version in 2016, watching Chicago Police recruits get training there. 
     But when Rotary Magazine asked me to profile Holocaust Museum founder Sam Harris, I pulled the program from the opening — I have a good filing system — and there was Harris,  alongside Bill Clinton and future Gov. J.B. Pritzker. I was glad to meet Harris — to realize that the youngest holocaust survivors are still among us, a living link to the abyss — and to write this piece, which appears in the January issue of Rotary Magazine.    

    Sam Harris is passionate about it. He will meet you, even though he is 88 years old and uses a walker, in the somber industrial entrance of the museum he helped create, an institution dedicated to making sure the awful, important story that he lived is told, years after he is gone and his voice, among the dwindling firsthand accounts, is finally silenced.
     That wasn’t always the case.
     For many years Harris, a former insurance executive and a member of the Rotary Club of Northbrook, Illinois, didn’t want to talk about how the Nazis had come for him when he was a small boy. He didn’t want to talk about the terrible hunger. The fear. The machine guns. His murdered parents. The cattle cars. The concentration camps. It was old news, ancient history. What would be the point? He was an American now. First an American boy, living in Northbrook, a comfortable suburb north of Chicago. Then an American man who could choose for himself what to discuss. Or not discuss.
     His refusal went on for years. "I knew it troubled him, that it was all inside of him," says his wife of 62 years, Dede. "He just never spoke about his past. I could see it festering."
     The reluctance was complicated. He didn’t want people to feel sorry for him. And if he became successful, he wanted it to be because of who he was, not because of what happened to him, he explains, settling into a chair in the small but well-stocked library of his museum. If someone detected an accent and asked where he was from, he’d toss the question back: Where do you think I’m from? And if the person said "New York," Harris would say, "Yes, exactly! New York." Or if someone said, "Germany," he’d say, "Germany, yes, how did you know?" And smile.
     A trained social worker, Dede Harris eventually sat her husband down by a crackling fire one evening. "I asked him to tell the story," Dede recalls. "It seemed to have broken through that impasse. Once he was able to verbalize the feelings, he had to be open to other people."
     It began slowly. At a 1977 meeting of the Rotary Club of Wilmette, Illinois, Harris met a member, Rabbi William Frankel, who grew up in Vienna. Like Harris, Frankel had fled the Nazis, only he used his past as a springboard to a life of activism. Frankel had marched with the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. during the U.S. Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s and was prominent in Catholic-Jewish outreach efforts. He befriended Harris and convinced him that he owed it to future generations to tell his story.
     Around that time, a group of neo-Nazis planned a demonstration in Skokie, a Chicago suburb that was half Jewish at the time and home to many Holocaust survivors. Though a lengthy legal battle prevented the demonstration, activists like Rabbi Frankel believed silence and inaction were no longer an option. Waiting and hoping while evil rises to its feet was never a smart strategy.
     Meanwhile, Arthur Butz, an associate professor of electrical engineering at Northwestern University in Evanston, about 10 miles from where Harris lived, published a book with the claim that the Holocaust was a myth perpetuated by the Allies and Zionists. Frankel called Harris to express his abhorrence of the book. "Sam, I know it’s hard for you, but it’s time for you to talk," Frankel urged him.
     In Frankel’s basement, the rabbi interviewed Harris on video camera. "And it was the first time really, I was able to talk," says Harris. "I said to myself, I’ll never do this again. But he showed this to everybody in the congregation. And it was packed. And then he passed that around to other rabbis. That was all because of Rotary."

To continue reading, click here.



21 comments:

  1. What a story…I’m glad he changed his mind and decided to share it. I met a Holocaust survivor when I was a teenager. She was in a Polish slave labor farm for four years. It was the stuff of unspeakable horror, and for a long time, I was sorry that I asked her to tell me about it. When I hear about these deniers, it makes me furious. I met this lady in 1980. I wasn’t even aware of idiotic conspiracy theories back then. If we don’t know our history, we are doomed to repeat it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excellent, thank you Neil.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a wonderful article, what a wonderful man. (Keep hearing good things about Rotary). Thank you for briefly capturing this man’s experience for all of us to appreciate and remember.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Vitally important, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bravo, bravo, bravo. Bearing witness.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The article reminds me on one of Northwestern University's most disgusting decisions, its refusal to cancel his tenure & fire Arthur Butz. Edwin Black wrote an excellent article in the reader stating that NU had a fully supportable reason to fire him for moral turpitude over his utterly asinine & lies about The Holocaust. The bastard is still there in the electrical engineering department, but at least Amazon doesn't sell his vile books.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This shouldn't have happened...and in the modern age yet...too sad and unspeakable for words.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I remember the opening in Skokie, and I've taken several groups there.
    But here's my question:
    The Blues Brothers.
    It seems the vast majority of people only remembrance is from the film and the line, "I hate Illinois Nazis."
    What are your thoughts about this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, the march is a local event 45 years in the past, while the film is still popular, so I wouldn't draw too much from it. Rahm Emanuel's election elevated awareness of the local Nazi angle, because he was at the protest — I seem to recall seeing a photo of a shirtless 19-year-old Rahm, giving the finger to Nazis. But that could be an embellished memory. If you read the piece I wrote about my fleeting encounter with them, I believe "hate" is both an exaggeration and playing at their game — and they're so much better at it. Just as I pity Trump, so I pity them. Imagine spending your left in a cathectic trance, locked on the stuff that bothers you most. You know what I hate? Egg salad sandwiches. You know what I never eat? Egg salad. But if you want egg salad, well, heck, go for it. Doesn't hurt me at all. A lot of people are too stupid to make that leap.

      Delete
    2. Different folks see the same event differently. An Ohio teen will not see (Nazi?) what a thirty-year-old in Evanston sees. The march started out as a strictly local affair, and was covered by the Sun-Times as such. I was there when the first attempt was made. The Nazis were turned back at the Edens off-ramp. It was rather disconcerting to witness sixty-something men tapping baseball bats on the pavement, near the Skokie town hall. Many of those with the bats in their hands also had tattoos on their arms. The numbers were plainly visible.

      While the Nazis went slowly through the courts and announced their plans to attempt to march, Skokie eventually became an international story, one that drew media coverage and media people from around the world. The town was going to be sealed off by the National Guard (I knew how to get around that...I grew up there. A fact that I rarely disclose, even today...mainly due to the town's association with this event, and also thanks to all those decades of "Skokie stereotyping.") But as a Jew by birth, I wanted to kick some ass. I was offered a gun. Which I declined.

      The march was called off in June of '78. So the Nazis took their flags and shirts and shields to Daley Plaza, and there was a nice little Saturday afternoon riot downtown. Rocks, bottles, garbage, and recycled byproducts from police horses. I had to assist an attractive and well-dressed young lady , a reporter from the Los Angeles Times, whose head got in the way of a rock.

      Frank Collin, the local Fuhrer, finally went to prison---for molesting a couple of his Hitler Youth boys. Danny Kaye made a terrible on-location TV-movie, in which he did little more than scream at his daughter. A Holocaust memorial was dedicated at the site in 1988, in a downpour, by President Reagan. It was immediately vandalized. By a new crew of Nazis? Who the hell knows?

      Ah, Skokie...Skokie...time has erased so much. My old school is long gone. It's only about one-third Jewish now. It's far more diverse. Do most people even associate Skokie with Nazis anymore? Forty-five years is a long time.

      Delete
    3. Frank Collin was a joke. He had a weekly, I think, recorded message that was good for a few laughs. In hindsight, I feel slightly guilty about finding humor in any Nazis, no matter how pathetic. Collin's rally fizzled, but the current version holds many in thrall. Chicago ran both would be Hitlers out of town, but Herr Drumpf deserves his own band of bat wielding survivors to finish the job. During the period of the Yom Kippur War, I managed the Arco station at Howard and McCormick. In fair weather, no day passed without seeing arms, a variety of tattoos, obviously done quickly, and no two the same. It was a constant reminder of the scope of the Holocaust, and concrete proof of the tragedy that no single word could adequately describe and that no book of lies could disprove before honest men.

      Delete
  9. What a wonderful human! Thanks for relaying his story.

    ReplyDelete
  10. What a remarkable man! Did he talk about what happened here in Chicago to his sister Sara?

    ReplyDelete
  11. "It combines artifacts ... with timelines and narratives to help visitors grasp the ungraspable."

    This excellent, concise article about Mr. Harris' compelling story and life certainly helps, as well.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Never forget.

    Thank you, Neil.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for the local details, Grizz.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad to oblige. It may not be a BFD anymore, but it certainly was at the time. And it will always be one to me. I lived there for eleven years.

      Delete
    2. Grizz — a fellow reader would like to bond with your over your mutual roots in Skokie. If you're interested, please send your email to me at dailysteinberg@gmail.com and I will forward to you his particulars.

      Delete
    3. Will do, Mr. S. Haven't bonded with anyone from my kid days since 1987.

      Delete
  14. I have a very good friend. His father fought in Europe. He and I became close, I too am a Vet. He had a few mementos in his house relating to his service..a few Nazi flags .a Hitler youth knife. On certain evenings after a Bears game and more than a few beers we sometimes would talk on things. See...he saw the camps..he never claimed to have liberated anyone..but he saw. And he'd cry a bit. And he would say...these people today say it never happened..but it did . I saw it. I never forgot him. Ernesto Zamarripa. United States Army. ES.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your service, sir. I greatly appreciate it.

      Delete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.