Monday, January 29, 2024

Elon, boychik, welcome to the tribe!

Another local Jewish person contemplates Elon Musk in 2018.

     Elon, my man! Bagrisn aheym mayn bruder! Welcome home, my brother!
     Oh sorry, Getting ahead of myself. Last Monday, the world’s richest man, Elon Musk, visited Auschwitz and declared himself “aspirationally Jewish.”
     As someone who is not aspirationally but actually Jewish, that is a slow pitch right down the pipe. A guy’s gotta swing.
     Judaism is a great religion. That fact often gets lost, what with all the people hating us and wanting us dead. Great food. Great traditions. Not a lot of rigid rules, except for the Orthodox.
     But is Jewishness something one “aspires” to? Does anyone need to aspire? The bar is very low. You wanna be Jewish? Be Jewish. It’s not like anybody’s going to stop you. Buy a pair of candlesticks. Say Sabbath prayers.
     You don’t even have to do that. In my book, you’re Jewish if you say you are.
     Which Musk pretty much did. Though he seems to think Judaism is something you get from close contact with others, like pink eye.
     “Two-thirds of my friends are Jewish,” Musk said. “I have twice as many Jewish friends as non-Jewish friends. I’m like, Jewish by association.”
     It doesn’t work like that. Having Christian friends doesn’t make me Christian, I hope. Rule of thumb: If you’re using your friends from a certain group as a human shield to deflect charges that you’re actually a bigot who hates that exact group, then you probably are.
     Which reminds us: Musk’s remarkable theological self-transformation doesn’t spring from nowhere. It was last November, not that long ago, particularly when discussing a faith that goes back to ancient Babylon, when Musk declared the idea of Jews — then a people quite apart from himself — pushing “hatred against whites” while welcoming “hordes of minorities” to be “the actual truth.”
     To his surprise — isn’t he supposed to be some kind of business genius? Because me, I’d have seen that coming (savviness; an alleged Jewish trait) — the X advertisers started bolting in droves. Leading to Musk’s in-the-trenches conversion.
     Supposedly. Skepticism is another Jewish quality. So let me roll my eyes and be so bold — again Jewish, though we call it chutzpah — as to point out that Musk doesn’t really want to be Jewish. Rather, he’s reading from the “Heck, I’m Jewish myself” playbook, a cliche among haters.

To continue reading, click here.

26 comments:

  1. Very good column! As for Musk: he's a POS.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Please don’t count him as Jewish. I cannot think of a greater insult. Musk, I’m afraid is of non-human form. I don’t know what he is, but he’s no human. He’s as bad as Chump parading around with a Bible in his hand, claiming to be Christian. All the while, only worshipping himself. Two peas in a pod.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Is Elon related somehow to George Santos? He too is "Jew-ish". Judy

    ReplyDelete
  4. So many of the problems in the world have a basis in tribalism. race, ethnicity, religion, political affiliation, even gender and sexual orientation result in division , derision and conflict. too many divisions and dividers too few uniters.

    I'm a real mutt. with several national origins in my heritage. a fallen away catholic , I dont claim any particular group and am not claimed by any one in particular. im often accused of representative of many. white? hardly - the moors-. male? I suppose . boomer? right on the cusp, christian? nope! sis? I guess, except for that boy sophomore year of HS :) American? not in that USA! USA! sort of way. wealthy? relatively I guess compared to the poor.

    I dont see myself as anything in particular and try not to see others for anything more than human beings . why can't we all just get along? RK even with others?

    ReplyDelete
  5. What a delightful piece. I know you've been a writer your whole life, but damn, that's well written and hilarious and insightful. Everything I'd want to be if I was a columnist. Mazel tov. One highlight for me was the use of jawbone. His "Jewish by association" comment reminds me of a crass joke my Jewish ex-husband used to make, which I will not repeat. IYKYK as the kids say.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Was it JBI? My wife thought it was cute, but she finally got sick of hearing it.

      Delete
  6. Musk is as Jewish as Reinard Heydrich, one of the worst piles of shit the Nazis had. But the Nazis loved him, because bizarrely, he also could speak Yiddish.
    But after the Czechs ambushed & murdered him, the Nazis wiped out the entire town of Lidice Czechoslavakia, by killing all the men & sending the women to concentration camps to be killed.
    Musk is total scum!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Such a great engineering mind, all else such a waste.
    Your column has so many clever turns of phrase, thanks for another good start to the day.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Does he have a great engineering mind? Or just the ability to hire great engineers? (Not snark, truly asking. I try to avoid info about this awful person.)

      Delete
    2. 🤣🤣🤣

      Delete
    3. Probably both, but hard to deny his creative mind. If he’d just keep his mouth shut…and stick to engineering

      Delete
    4. Is he creative, or is he good at recognizing the innovative ideas of others and acquiring and exploiting them?

      Delete
  8. One point not hitherto addressed here is why the hell do we care what Elon Musk has to say. He's an ill informed blowhard with an obvious agenda of self promotion and an antipathy for and plain dealing. But he's rich and successful (except of course for X). So we're obligated to pay attention, even (or especially) when he spouts nonsense. I can only hope that the attention will not turn him into another would be dictator like the former you know who.

    john

    ReplyDelete
  9. Maybe Elon Musk is modeling himself after Henry Ford?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had the same thought. Only Musk I want anywhere near me is Jovan Musk Oil, which I used in my fox hunting days and which I don't think they even make anymore. What an asshole...

      Delete
    2. Is UNMENSCH really the opposite of Mensch? That's what the internet said; maybe it's AI logic?

      Delete
    3. Is UNMENSCH an acronym for some relief agency that feeds starving Palestinian refugees? No...no...wait...that would be UNRWA...The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (for Palestine Refugees in the Near East). Perhaps you meant "untermensch" instead?

      That is a German word literally meaning 'underman', 'sub-man', or 'subhuman', used by the Nazis to refer to non-Aryan people they deemed as racially, culturally, and socially inferior. It was mainly used against "the masses from the East", mainly Jews, Roma, and Slavs. Who, naturally, deserved to be persecuted, enslaved, or exterminated. Hope that helps.

      EDIT: Never mind. There IS a German word..."unmensch." A "mensch" is "a person"...in both Yiddish and German, but to Jewish people, it means "a good, decent, honorable, admirable person." "Unmensch" is German for a brute, a monster. "Ich bin ja kein Unmensch"...I’m not an ogre. So your screen was right .And it isn't AI. It's German.

      Delete
    4. Ah, now I remember: "The Man From UNMENSCH"...United Nations Middle Eastern Network Stopping Civilian Hunger...yeah...that's the one...

      Delete
  10. In the Christian tradition, people can undergo "conversion experiences," like Saul had on the road to Damascus. So maybe Elon had a "conversion experience" in Auschwitz. He may start observing the Sabbath, along with other high holy days of the Jewish year. Who knows? Time will tell, etc., etc., etc.

    ReplyDelete
  11. After reading your excellent as usual column, I decided I want to be Jewish. Can I become Jewish through reading enough of your columns ? Or…where should I buy a coupla cheap candlesticks?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Terrific piece today and really great replies; I will just enjoy it all and reread.

    ReplyDelete
  13. It's not very often that I actually chuckle at something that I read, but such was the case with the photo and caption for today's post.

    "... a slow pitch right down the pipe. A guy’s gotta swing." Indeed!

    For the many skeptical folks who I believe are among EGD's faithful readers (is that a paradox?), I think y'all would appreciate this rather long interview with magician extraordinaire Penn Jillette. It's pretty wide-ranging, but one of the reasons I'm putting it here is because he discusses his attitude about the concept of being "culturally Jewish," as Elon purportedly aspires to being.

    Unrelated to that, he observes: "I said to anybody who asked me, 'No matter how bad you think Trump is, he’s worse.' ... I never met anybody that I noticed with two qualities that Trump has — someone that never made a joke and never appreciated music."

    https://www.cracked.com/article_40871_penn-jillette-wants-to-talk-it-all-out.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Jakash. Well worth the time. Penn Gillete is my kind of guy, not that I share any of his qualities other than self deprecation.

      john

      Delete
    2. I haven't listened in years. But he has a pretty good podcast called Penns Sunday School

      Delete

Comments are vetted and posted at the discretion of the proprietor.